Vitalism

This article is about the non-mechanist philosophy. For other uses, see vital

Vitalism is the doctrine that "life forces" are active in living organisms, so that life cannot be explained solely by mechanism. That element is often referred to as the "vital spark", "energy" or "élan vital", which some equate with the "soul". Vitalism has a long history in medical philosophies. Most traditional healing practices posited that disease was the result of some imbalance in the vital energies which distinguish living from non-living matter. In the Western tradition, these vital forces were identified as the humours; eastern traditions posited similar forces such as qi, prana, etc. Vitalism is largely seen as pseudoscientific (Williams et al 2000).

History

Aided by the invention of the microscope in the 16th century, the germ theory of disease gained momentum and challenged the role of vitalism in Western medicine. Attention was also drawn to the role of the various organs of the human anatomy, as opposed to vital forces, in the maintenance of life.

Experiments in the early 19th century continued to erode support for vitalism in the Western scientific community, beginning with Carl Reichenbach's theory of the Odic force. As an implication of vitalism, organic compounds were thought to be only produced by living organisms, as a byproduct of the presence of the vital forces. However, as chemical techniques advanced, it was found that many of these compounds, such as urea, could be produced using the same types of chemical processes that produced inorganic compounds.

Further chemical and anatomical discoveries pushed aside the "vital force" explanation, as more and more life processes came to be described in purely scientific terms, and as the medical model of disease came to be more and more focused on the failure of particular organs and processes in the body.

Vitalism in medicine (and more generally, in society) experienced a resurgence beginning in the late 20th century. Although scientific understanding of the biochemical processes which distinguish living from non-living matter has become increasingly sophisticated, so has the realization that these fundamental processes are incredibly complicated; no complete, reductionist theory has yet been proposed which coordinates all of the actions which occur in a single cell (let alone a higher organism). Just such a thing, however, is an explicit goal of several currently working molecular biologists, some of whom speak of elucidating the complete "wiring diagram" of a living cell. Vitalism is a key aspect of many alternative medicines, and is often considered pseudsocientific (Williams et al 2000).

Variations

Sometimes a division between soft vitalism and hard vitalism may be drawn. The former have a vitalist world-view but employ common scientific methods in their conduct, stating that their metaphysical ideas have nothing to do with their work. The latter is the category usually identified with vitalism, clearly stating that life processes are radically different from the processes in non-living matter.

Modern medical vitalism, as represented by such schools as homeopathy, naturopathy, acupuncture, anthroposophy, biodynamic agriculture and chiropractic, tends to emphasize a holistic approach to the cause and treatment of disease.

In terms of the biology of the cell itself, a return to vitalism is seen in the proposal that life is an emergent process which cannot be accurately described simply by understanding any number of chemical processes which occur in the cell.

See also

* Dualism
* Henri Bergson
* Odic force
* Philosophy of biology
* Qi

References

Williams, W. 2000. Encyclopedia of Pseudoscience.

External links

* Vitalism - the Skeptic's Dictionary