Expert: Robert P. Firriolo - 11/10/2008

Question
I just received my NYS pistol permit. I originally applied for a business carry, as I am a self employed business owner, but received a target hunting permit. I have provided all necessary bank statements and eligibility info (meeting all required criteria)with the application...also I have no prior criminal events.
When I inquired as to why I was denied I was told that they did not have that info, and to write a letter.
My question is to whom do I write this letter, and does it ever make a difference. Do the judges even look at these letters?
Thank you in advanced for any information you can provide me.  

Answer
It would have been helpful if you told me what county you are dealing with. However, generally speaking, you should address your letter to the same judge who issued your license.

Each upstate county has a judge or justice in a court of record designated as the handgun licensing officer. If you are in NYC, Nassau, or Suffolk, you would need to contact the police department (or the sheriff, if in eastern Suffolk).

The judge _should_ look at your letter, as that is what he or she needs to review to determine what restrictions (if any) to put on your license. I know that there are some counties where it is not uncommon for judges to "upgrade" a previously issued license upon appeals from licensees who make the case for removing restrictions.

Be sure to include with your letter another copy of whatever documentation you included with your application that supports your "business need." If the clerk or sheriff's department told you "they did not have that info," it may have become lost and not made it to the judge for review.

Good luck.