You are here:

Advanced Math/Amount - Concrete Follow-Up


I will try to reword the question:

For the 1:2:3 ratio, 7 bags of cement, 14 cu. ft. of sand, and 21 cu. ft. of rocks/gravel are used to make 1 cu. yd. of concrete.  Additional information in the article says from 1 bag of cement, 3.9 cu. ft. of concrete can be made from the mixture.  

My question - How is the 3.9 cu. ft. for the 1 bag calculated, and  the 7 bags of cement, 14 cu. ft. of sand, and 21 cu. ft. of rocks/gravel calculated for the 1 cu. yd.?

It's a simple proportion.
1 yd = 3 ft, so 1 yd³ = 27 ft³
7 bags of cement are used to make 27 cubic feet of concrete.
1 bag × 27 ft³/(7 bags) = (27/7) ft³/bag ≅ 3.9 ft³/bag
One bag of cement is used to make approximately 3.9 cubic feet of concrete.

As for how 7 bags of concrete combine with 14 cubic feet of sand and 21 cubic feet of gravel to make 1 cubic yard of concrete:
The volumes cannot be simply added together. 14 ft³ sand + 21 ft³ gravel  does not yield 35 ft³. When you mix sand and gravel, the sand falls into the spaces between the pieces of gravel, so the mixture is more dense and takes up less total volume than the sum of the components.

Have you ever pondered the question of why brazil nuts seem to end up at the top of a can of mixed nuts? Brazil nuts, being heaviest component, could reasonably be expected to work their way to the bottom of the can. It seemed obvious (to me, at least) that while the other nuts are lighter, they are also smaller and tend to fall into the crevices around the brazil nuts.

Researchers at Carnegie-Mellon received a grant to study this and came up with the same conclusion. It might seem a waste of resources to study something that seems obvious, but even the obvious needs to be verified, and there are many more applications than just the brazil nuts question. Concrete, for instance.  

Advanced Math

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Janet Yang


I can answer questions in Algebra, Basic Math, Calculus, Differential Equations, Geometry, Number Theory, and Word Problems. I would not feel comfortable answering questions in Probability and Statistics or Topology because I have not studied these in depth.


I tutor students (fifth through twelfth grades) and am a Top Contributor on Yahoo!Answers with over 24,000 math solutions.

Co-author of An Outline of Scientific Writing: For Researchers With English as a Foreign Language

I have a Bachelor's degree in Applied Mathematics from the University of California at Berkeley.

Past/Present Clients
George White Elementary School. Homework Help program at the Ridgewood Public Library, Ridgewood, NJ. Individual students.

©2017 All rights reserved.