Expert: Kenton Scott - 2/5/2010

Question
QUESTION: I found this Baritone on EBay & looks not bad for it's age(don't really know it's age or model #) but would like to bid on it. comes w/ mouthpiece & case... Have 1 day to go & so far is going for $86. What do you think should be my top bid & what "s your opinion on the Collegeate. Looks like 1 I played in high school 45 yrs ago. Try to hurry w/ your answer so I can bid on it   Thanks

ANSWER: Collegiates were student level instruments, but probably better than the average student model.

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: Now I need to get your opinion on a good mouthpiece for this vintage (front facing bell), Holton Collegiate... Can you recommend where to begin for a perfect mouthpiece?  Should I stick w/ a Holton mouthpiece? Oh by the way...I won this horn for $182

Answer
If the silver is basically intact on the Holton mouthpiece, I think I'd recommend starting with it.  If nothing else, it should be matched to the characteristics of the horn. Mouthpieces are a personal thing and no one mouthpiece is going to satisfy every one.