Expert: Jamshaid Zubairee - 2/26/2009

Question
QUESTION: If you are saying that "Ya Ali Madad" is not correct due to death of him then what will you say about Aayat of Quraan "The person who is died in the way of God. Dont think that he has died but he is live and take Rizq from his God", and Hazrat Ali (A.S.) spend his whole life in the way of God. According to Quraan we will have to accept that he is live and in Sharyat e Mustafawi we can call any person for help.

ANSWER: Wa salam Dear
You said that saying "Ya Ali Madad" is allowed because Ali RA was a "Martyre" (died in the Path of Allah) and he served Islam etc etc so in this way you are opening a DOOR for praying to all of the other people who have served Islam and died in the path of Allah.
Keep in mind that praying someone else other than Allah Almighty is shirk.
visit
http://www.esnips.com/user/Jam2000 (here you will find many good books on Islamic creed)
Allah Hafiz (may Allah protect you)


---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: Salaam
I want to Inform you that In Jang e Khaiber Imam Ali(A.S.) was not present from starting He was in Madina due to Ashob e chashm and here in Khaibar Lashkare Islam daily going to fight but not successing and then at the day of last means 40th Day Paighamber Mohammad (S.A.W.W.) call him then he came from madina and then Paighamber Mohammad (S.A.W.W.) gave him Alam and then Imam Ali(A.S.) won to the Qila e Khaiber if you don’t know or not accepting please read follwing books for Khaiber and some other references in which Imam Ali (A.S.) said Ya Rasool Allah I will help and Rasooll Allah said Ya Ali you are my Wali

Masnad          Imam Ahmad bin Hambal
Khasayas e Alwiya
Sahih Mustadrik 3rd Volume Page 133   Imam E Hakim
Talkhees Mustadrik         Allama Zahabi
Siratun nabi(S.A.W.W.)       Maulana Shibli Nomani


Answer
Wa salam Dear
I simply want to tell you that saying "Ya Ali Madad" is not allowed because itg caontains the notion of PRAY that we are PRAYING to Caliph Ale R.A. but you said that Prophet Muhammad PBUH called Ali R.A. from Medina to participate in war than how do you compare your saying "Ya Ali Madad" with "CALLING" from Medina??? that of course had been done by some messenger "IF IT REALLY HAPPENE" because I don't have these book available to me and even many books are available but I don't have enough time to waste on such things.
From this incident as you describe according to shia traditions you infer that Prophet Muhammad PBUH "PRAYED" to cliph Ali R.A. than it is very strange!
May Allah Help You
GOOD LUCK
http://karaoke.esnips.com/user/Jam2000