Expert: Rikki Nyman - 6/4/2010

Question
Rikki, my wife and I spent about 3 mos. coming up with to-scale plans for turning our 1 story ranch into a Queen Anne inspired 2-story. I needed an architect to provide options and limitations for the roof so we could finalize window, balcony, and porch placement. Ten weeks, 3 preliminary plans, and $5,300 later we're still trying to get the architect to understand the difference between Queen Anne and "McMansion" and why he shouldn't try to interject his "design" ideas without consulting us first. When should we give up on him?

Answer
Picking an architect can sometimes be difficult because some get so caught up in their idea of what you want they don't hear what you're saying. I think you've given the current architect plenty of time and money to get a clear sense of the direction this project is going to take. It's okay to cut him loose and look for an alternate.

Look for someone who has a background in architectural history and understands the distinction of what you're doing. This is a big project and to get the look you're aiming for means you need someone who understands the exuberance of QA detail, not just size!

In addition to looking through past projects and gathering work references, find out how responsive the new architect was to the homeowner's desires. When you talk to prospective architects, explain what you are looking for and why. A good architect is not only a competent designer and engineer, but they are also part psychologist. Don't give up until you find a design partner who is capable of helping you express your vision.

Good luck with your project!
Best regards,
Rikki Nyman
www.antiquehomestyle.com