Expert: Rikki Nyman - 4/12/2011

Question
Hello,

We are remodeling an 1842 stucco Federal style farmhouse.  It is very humble and plain, with a center hall design.  We are adding an 'Ell' addition. My question is about what color to paint it.  We will be getting a new metal roof in an Aged Copper )light green) color, and we want the addition (hardie plank) to be different than the main (stucco) house. I would like a light tan for the stucco, and then quite a few shades darker for the siding.

What do you think? Or do you have any better ideas?  My husband would like to go more bold with our colors, but I think having a green roof is pretty bold all by itself!

THANKS,
KATIE

Answer
I'd stick with a lighter color that plays to the traditional and classical design elements that define the Colonial and Federal periods. White, ivory, light butter yellow, or buff (light tan) would all be pretty attractive especially with the roof color you've selected. When a building is simple, go for the best quality you can afford with respect to remodeling materials, and embrace the simplicity. Use landscaping to enhance the appearance. It will be beautiful.

Best regards,
Rikki Nyman
www.antiquehomestyle.com