Architecture/Mansard Roof


I am looking to "flip" a 1977 home with a Mansard roof.  I want to create a better curb appeal without making a huge investment that will put my investment upside down.  With that said I've had some contractors come up with two options.  One is to replace the shingles on the Mansard portion with new asphalt shingles, basically the same dated look.  Or to replace the shingles with vinyl shake shingle siding.  The first contractor said the vinyl concept can't be done due to water and ice damming issue #this is in Wisconsin#.  I feel the vinyl is a more updated look and would compliment the brick base of the house.  Would appreciate you thoughts!

Jim - thanks for your question.

I'm not familiar with any particular problems with ice-damming due to choice of siding; ice-damming is caused by venting and insulation problems, and is a roof issue, not a wall/siding issue.

But I'm a long way from Wisconsin...

I am familiar with vinyl shakes, however, and think they're "ok" for certain projects.  I prefer fiber-cement products, but they're much more expensive.

If you like the look, and there's no ice/snow issue that particular to WI, then go for it!


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Richard Taylor, AIA


Ask me about all aspects of house, remodeling. , and room addition design and construction. Ask me about historic homes, renovation, and restoration. Ask me about materials and techniques, and about how you can get the best value for your design and construction dollar. Ask me how you can make your home a very special place. I can't, however, answer specific structural engineering questions in this forum - that's something you'll need on-site observation for.


I own a full-service residential architectural firm, and have been designing custom homes, remodelings, and room additions across the country since 1983. Check us out at Richard Taylor Architects and RTA Plans. I have written and been published extensively on the subject of residential architecture.

American Institute of Architects, City of Dublin Architectural Review Board, Vice Chair of City of Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission, American Planning Association, Board Member Historic Dublin Business Association, Past Editor of SPLASH (a software forum), Past Editor of Open Directory Project, Assistant Scoutmaster, Boy Scouts of America

Business First of Columbus, Suburban New Publications,, Cleveland Plain Dealer, Columbus Dispatch Residential Architect Custom Home Architect Remodeling Architect

Bachelor of Environmental Design (Architecture) Miami University 1983
For more about home design, check out my blog at Sense Of Place and join the conversation on our Facebook Page.

Awards and Honors
2010 Dublin Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year

©2017 All rights reserved.