Expert: Charlotte Sherrell, DVM - 12/19/2009

Question
Hello,

I have recently been forced to switch my cats' litter, as it is no longer carried in my area.  I was using Cat's Pride clumping flushable litter.  I have since switched to Swheat Scoop.  I transitioned them by doing half and half in between.  I have two cats and my 2-3 year old has started leaving us presents (of both kinds) on our couch/bed (we use a couch for the bed).  We keep the box very clean.  At first we thought it might be emotionally triggered by jealously regarding attention to our other cat, but it has only progressed further even after we have made constant notions to show him as much love and attention as possible.  My boyfriend gets really upset with him when he does poo or pee on the couch.  He did it twice today within 12 hours - once while we were sleeping and again later this afternoon.  My boyfriend punishes him as you would a dog, but I am aware that he does not learn this way.  I am at a loss of what to do.  Should I give a different litter a shot?  I just wish the old litter was still available.  Thank you for your time and your help.  

Answer
Kathleen -

Often when there is a change in litter, cats will resent the change.  However, most cats would just defecate or urinate outside the litter box if they do not like the litter.  You should have the cat examined by a veterinarian just to make sure there are no physical problems causing him to behave in such a manner.

Usually cats will urinate or defecate in an inappropriate place to inform you that they need medical attention.  There is usually no other way for them to get your attention except to urinate in an area that you will notice. Punishing the animal will not do any good - the animal will only go in another place and will only fear the person that is handing out the punishment.   

Contrary to popular belief, cats do not behave in a vindictive manner as humans do.  Cats will not do things to "get back" at the owner.  They do not process things the way humans do, and they do not have the behavior traits that humans portray.  Cats do, however, have emotions - they feel sadness, excitement, anger, jealously etc.  

However, if the cat feels intimidated by your significant other - that may be the reason why he may be leaving "presents" in your bedroom. The territorial nature of the cat may cause him to "go" on your bed.  You should rule out illness first, then look at behavior as a cause of him inappropriate bathroom habits.  

Have your pet examined by a veterinarian as soon as possible to rule out any physical problems - then you can address the change in litter.

Best Regards,

Charlotte Sherrell, DVM