About Heather Expertise Amature astronomer, can answer most simple questions about planets, constellations, stars, galaxies and more. No Physics questions please
Astronomy - STAR CLOUDS IN RELATION TO BLACK HOLES
Expert: Heather - 7/30/2004
Question Heather,
First of all I am not qualified to rate you. Refinment possiblities and your knowlege are what I am looking for.
There IS NO answer that I am looking for, I need additional imput and I thank you for providng me with that. If we had the answers then I have no theroy. Also I should not have numbered my staments in 2-sets of 3 It is confusing when you reply to me and that is my fault.
If you agree with the first 3 staments then there is still a ball game here, let me know. Your critic (?) or constuctive critsisim is more than welcome. I have bounced this question on the web for more that a year now and finaly have two replies in hand. Past replies came in as "not qulified to answer"! Which in itself is exciting!
Jayendra mistook my theorys as statments of fact and she also apologized that this is what I did not want to hear. They are theroys only. There is nothing that I do not want to hear! I have an open mind to this!
Also my wording that Black Holes are "Definitly" recycle bins was an error on my part. I Stongly "Belive" that they are. "Definatly" can only be proven over time but I think we are close.
Ok, nobody is aguing the first 3 statements. It is the last three that need to be worked on.
1. You agree that Black Holes could possibly be recycle bins.
2. A possiblity of a "WHITE HOLE"? WHY NOT? For each action there is an equal and opposite reaction as we all know.
3. Matter goes down the void, not waste, it all has purpose.
4. If matter cannot be created or destroyed and there is a finite amount, then it must be going somewhere, nobody knows of course, but would love to hear/read any other theroys. Of couse it cannot "Build" onto the the Universe, it cannot create matter. Just recycle it. ("Maybe")
5. As far as the universe expanding in all directions at once this is TRUE and I apologize if I mislead you to belive that I thought otherwise.
Proved by the "COBE" high altititude expements using the reflection of the Earth? and "Doppler" I think? That book after 75 pages cramped my brain! Out of my leage!
6. Do you agree or disagree that time travel is possible? Lets leave the human traveler out of this, but what about "Qurks" & "Netrenos" (cant spell)
I respect you thoughts and opinions and they wll definatly help with my refinment of my therory. I hear that Fred Hoyle, Bondi, Naralikar have come up with a theroy of "Continuous Creation of Matter" from Jayendra and I will try to find some reading on that. Let me Know Where?
7. Am I stating past and future as far as Time or the Universe?
Excellent Question! I cannot find Steven Hawkins or Einstin's phone number.
I would have to say that without the Universe time does not exsist.
(In fact I belive that time does not exsist at all)
8. Lets all give dark matter our full support! Without it we cannot collaps upon ourselfs and begin again. Will it be the Begining or the End?
Neither. It is without Begining or End.
I was very happy with your reply, I need the support of intellegent minds in the field of the Cosmos! (none around here!)
What is the density of 1 partical of "Nebuli or "Cloud" of gas in space?
What is/are "MESSIER OBJECTS"?
I read once that if we figure it all out we will look at each other and say "How could it have been any other way"
Should you want any further referance to the last stament see "The Bible"
Hope to here from you,
peter
Answer I'm kinda confused as to what to say next, but I'm glad I at least helped you with this :) I was tempted to use the "out of my leauge" option when answering the question, but it was just to unique for me to pass up. I believe I'll start with your #4. You say matter isnt created or destroyed, but there is a finite amount? I disagree with that a bit, I believe matter can be created and destroyed. Going with your theory, then there is a finite amount, and it IS being recycled, or else there would progressively become less and less due to the black holes destroying it all. Perhaps if the theory of a finite amount of matter is correct, but the recycling theory is wrong, perhaps the matter just keeps escaping due to black holes, and in the end the universe will become so dense like a neutron star, it will implode and begin its life cycle again (it sort of ties in with the big bang theory, exploding out and then comming back in for some reason, and repeating) granted this is very far fetched, you wanted opinon and theory, you got it! For #6, Yes I believe in time travel. I haven't figured out exactly how it could be done, but it would have to do with time and dimentions (are you familiar with any theories regarding dimentions?) I read somewhere that time (or what feels like time, as you said it may not actualy exist) is passing faster then it was before. I believe that as time passes, it leaves behind something, and indescribable something that we will be able to acess later. Perhaps dimentions are really just time, future and past. A way to think of it would be like a radio dial...you move up one station (dimention) and it brings you to a different point in time, a little bit ahead or behind depending on where you put the dial. Again this is very far fetched but I'm having fun putting all these ideas out there. For #8, I still have trouble with the concept of dark matter, so I wouldn't be able to give you my full ideas on that. Im not sure on the density of a particle of nebuli gas, and the messier objects are just a set of named galaxies and nebuli with numbers following. M31 is Andromeda (heres a great website with all of them, http://www.seds.org/messier/objects.html#nebula) Again, I hope I've helped you and hope to hear from you again!
