Ayurveda/Garlic and onions


Dear Dr. Dehal,
as I understand, in Ayurveda garlic and onions are considered good from the point of view of physical health, but not recommended from a spiritual point of view due to their tamasic nature, and perhaps for other reasons.
I have recently come across the view that garlic and onions should be avoided because they kill the beneficial bacteria in the intestines.  
- Is this true?
- If it were true, wouldn't it also be true of turmeric and ginger?
- And would there be a difference between cooked and raw garlic and onions from this point of view?
Thank you in advance for your help and all best wishes,

Garlic and onions should be avoided because they kill the beneficial bacteria in the intestines.  This saying is totally wrong.
Infact in condition of diarrhea and vomiting we give onion juice to the patient to kill the bad bacteria or microbes in the intestine.
In raw garlic and onion their chemical constituents like Sulfur is more active.


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Dr.Gary Dehal


Any question related to Ayurveda.


Now i have a total experience of around 19 years including 7 years of clinical experience. http://divyasanjeevani.webs.com/ http://garydehal.blogspot.in/ https://www.facebook.com/ayurvedasanjeevani http://www.ayurvedaconsultants.com/adgolden.aspx?ivalue=632 http://www.allexperts.com/ep/4033-113681/Ayurveda/Dr-G-Dehal.htm

Divya Sanjeevani Ayurveda Hospital Ayurveda Himachal

Amar Ujala,Punjab Kesari,Arogya patrika,chikitsa pallav...

I am studying the different system of medicines since 1989.First i did 4 years BEMS and then MD(AM),Ayurveda Rattan,Vaidya Visharad,certificate in Food & Nutrition,BAMS(bachelor of Ayurveda) and now doing DNYS(diplome in yoga and naturopathy).

Awards and Honors
Distinguised Pattron-All India Ayurveda Congress,New Delhi. Vice-President-Himachal Pradesh State Ayurveda Doctors Union. Fellow Academy of General Education,Manipal. Special Life Member-AYUSH medical Association. Special member-Bharat Swabhiman Trust,Patanjali Yogpeeth Trust,Haridwar.

Past/Present Clients
Civil servant,bureaucrat,senior police officer,professor,businessman.

©2017 About.com. All rights reserved.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]