You are here:

Baptists/voluntary castration and is it ok?


Hi! I was wondering what the baptist faith feels about voluntary castration. So many parts in the gospel seem to say that if something causes you to sin you should cast it away, but I was also told that eunuchs were looked at as lesser men, and were forbidden to enter service.

I would appreciate your input.

Howdy, Justin!

Unfortunately, those passages are some of the misunderstood passages in the Bible.  Jesus was speaking to their false belief that your body parts caused you to sin, not your heart.  If I have a lustful eye it is my eye's fault. If I steal is because of my hand.  That way they thought they escaped personal responsibility by blaming their part and not their heart.  Jesus was saying that if you truly believe that then it is better to lose an hand than go to Hell with all your parts.  

There are similar superstitions that arose after they started heart transplants.  Supposedly, people who never smoked or drank started having the desire to do so because the heart donor smoked and drank or they stopped loving their wife because they loved the wife of the donor.  That is poppycock and balderdash because the heart and seat of the emotions is not in the blood pump, but rather your brain.  Jesus tells them their real source of their problem in these verses.

Matt 15:19-20

19 For out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, false witness, blasphemies:
20 These are the things which defile a man: but to eat with unwashen hands defileth not a man.  KJV

It is not your eye, hand or genitals that are causing you problems nor is it your blood pump that we call the heart.  It is the core of your being that is the problem for all of us are sinners.  Mutilating your body will not solve your problem.  You will still lust and it will be worse because you will never have a righteous way of the satiating that lust.   It will be a taste of Hell since all the sins in a person's heart will still be with them in Hell with no way of fulfilling them.  

Ask any man that may be impotent if he thinks any less about sex since his equipment has failed to operate and he may well tell you he thinks about it even more and is miserable.  If it was just about the equipment then Viagra might not sell as well. When it quit working you would just quit thinking about it.  Not true so castration will never be an answer.  Indeed, it may open you up to a worse problem.

If you are not a born again Christian then I beg of you to find a good Baptist Church and let the pastor show you how to become one.  If you are one, then you need to still find that pastor and get some guidance on how to walk in the Spirit so that you can gain some victory over your problem.  Castration will not help.  

Please, please, please, do not harm yourself.  God is not telling anyone to do that.  He is pointing out that such theories of your parts being the problem are wrong.

May God grant you wisdom as you seek His will through His Word!


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Dr. Ronald E. Shultz


I am more of a polemicist than an apologist. I especially desire to answer questions concerning discipleship/holiness, "gray areas", etc. If all you wish is an argument then I am not your man. Sincere seekers only need e-mail me.


I have ministered in several states since my conversion in 1975. I participate in many forums and have written two books. I recently changed to Assembly of God, but after 40 years, I can still answer questions about Baptists and doctrinal issues that are common to many sects.

American Association of Christian Counselors since 2009
Texas Navy Association since 2008
Texas Civil Defense since 2008-10
American Legion since 2002
Honorable Order of Kentucky Colonels, since 1994
Life Member NCOA, 1973
Dover AFB Honor Guard, 1971-73

Poem, "Cowboy Up" published in an anthology by American Poets Society, 2004
Author, Jail House Religion, Xulon Press, 2004
Author, The Power of Holy Women, Xulon Press, 2003
Messianic Literary Corner published 45 poems, 2003+
Tract “Which Way To God” published on, 1998
Several poems published on various web pages, 1997,1998,1999
Author, Metamorphosis, copyrighted, partially published collection of poetry, 1968-94
Article, “Why I Prefer Expository Preaching”, published in Canyonview Bible Seminary's Expositor, 1988

Doctor of Theology, Slidell Baptist Seminary, Slidell, LA, 2001, Summa Cum Laude
Master of Theology, Christian Bible College, Rocky Mount, NC, 2000, Summa Cum Laude
Bachelor of Religious Education , Administration minor, Piedmont Baptist College, Winston-Salem, NC, 1982, Cum Laude
Evangelical Teacher Training Association, Teachers Diploma, Winston-Salem, NC, 1982
Other study: Community College of the Air Force, Maxwell AFB, AL - 1975-78
Upper Iowa University, Fayette, IA - 1976-77
Interim Ministry For Today's Churches - 2000

Awards and Honors
Heritage Registry of Who's Who, 2006-2007
Editor's Choice Award, International Library of Poetry, 2003
America's Registry of Outstanding Professionals 2001-2002
Stratmore Who's Who, 2001-2002
Guest Class Speaker Texas A&M, Commerce, 1999
Gubernatorial Commendation by Texas Veterans Commission, 1999
Dallas VA Certificate of Pride in Public Service, 1999
Guest on the Kevin Bullard radio program KPBC AM 770,1997
Who's Who in the South and Southwest, 1996
Editor's Choice Award, National Library of Poetry, 1995
Who's Who in Poetry, 1992
United States Army Achievement Medal, 1990
Personal testimony dramatized for international radio program Unshackled, 1986
Outstanding Young Men of the South, 1981
United States Air Force Commendation Medal, 1978
Two USAF suggestion awards, 1976
NCO of the Quarter, 1975
Freedom Foundation Award, 1975

©2017 All rights reserved.