You are here:

Baseball Instruction/Questions Answered by Expert Andrew Senger

SubjectDate Asked
Double play2/10/2012
  Q: Senger, Consider the following situation: one runner on 1st base and one runner on 3rd base ...
  A: Mike, The run would not score. Using Official Baseball Rules, Rule 4.09(a) states: "One run shall ...
intentionak walks10/25/2011
  Q: It seems to me that until recently (if at all), it was not possible to issue an intentional walk (or ...
  A: Charlie, Intentional walks are nothing more than four balls thrown to a batter, only the pitches ...
Delay of game rule6/23/2011
  Q: Recently, I noticed an opposing coach slowing down a game against us in order to limit how many ...
  A: Kevin, In generalities, there is nothing illegal with most of his stalling tactics. There is a rule ...
appeals6/15/2011
  Q: What is the proper way to appeal a call regarding a runner leaving the bag early before tagging up ...
  A: Mike, There are two ways to appeal this: 1. Have a fielder, with the ball, touch the base that was ...
Pregame4/15/2011
  Q: I always get nervous before a game any tips you recommend on what to do before a game and what can ...
  A: Are you a baseball player or umpire? In either case, listening to music before the game helps. I ...
DH question.3/30/2011
  Q: my question is if a player is taken out of the game, say left field player substituted for someone ...
  A: Brian, This isn't allowed for two reasons: 1. Once a player is removed from the game, he cannot ...
Interference by batter/runner?3/23/2011
  Q: Batter takes a big swing and drills the ball straight down into the batter's box where it comes to a ...
  A: Mark, As long as the contact is not intentional, it's a foul ball: 8.4.1 SITUATION B: B1 squares ...
11U Baseball3/18/2011
  Q: During a pitch, infield umpire calls balk, bases loaded, batter hits a ball. Is the ball struck dead ...
  A: Jess, It depends on the rule code being used. In high school rules (NFHS, or Fed), the ball is ...
college and high school ruling3/6/2011
  Q: Is a player out for hurdling over or jumping over the catcher who has the ball and is attempting to ...
  A: Doug, NFHS does not allow jumping or hurdling over a player UNLESS the player is lying on the ...
Intentional walk rule change in MLB2/28/2011
  Q: What year did the rule change requiring a pitcher to pitch 4 balls to issue an intentional walk. ...
  A: Sandy, According to Jim Evans Annotated Rules, there doesn't appear to ever have been a time that ...
Running to first without hitting11/21/2010
  Q: Runner on third. Batter leaves the batter's box without hitting and runs to first to draw attention ...
  A: Bill, This is how I'm understanding the situation: Runner on third, number of outs doesn't matter. ...
Rule 4.04: Definition of "ill"11/16/2010
  Q: Rule 4.04 states in “NOTE 2” that “…when a child is injured or becomes ill…the team will skip over ...
  A: David, If I were asked as an umpire to determine if a kid is ill simply because he's scared of a ...
play at home plate11/14/2010
  Q: I have a question pertaining to any play at home plate, is it mandatory that the runner slide into ...
  A: Sharon, I am not trained in Little League rules, so I cannot answer the situation for their rules. ...
run downs and in or out of baseline11/8/2010
  Q: runner is between 1st and second - 2 baseman is in the outfield side of the baseline without the ...
  A: Kendall, First of all, I apologize for the delay in answering the question. I have been on ...
Safe or out?10/23/2010
  Q: 2 out, runner on 3rd. Ball is hit between 3rd & SS. SS fields ball and throws to home as runner ...
  A: John, If the umpire determines the catcher did not have secure possession during the tag, or the ...
dropped 3rd strike with runner on first stealing9/13/2010
  Q: Runner on 1st with 1 out. Runner attempts to steal 2nd while pitcher is in delivery motion. The ...
  A: Mike, The determination is made by the runner's position at the time of the pitch. I doubt the ...
is the ball fair??9/12/2010
  Q: in a recent game a ball was hit and hit the third base unfortunately the base had been staked ...
  A: Franklin, The rules state that the bases are in fair territory. The foul lines are used only as a ...
Player position in fair/foul territory8/20/2010
  Q: I am trying to instruct my first and third baseman on how to hold a runner on base. I was told by ...
  A: Todd, It depends on what ruleset your league is using. With that said, there is no penalty in any ...
running and more.7/14/2010
  Q: I have some questions. I appreciate you asnwering them. 1)If there's a runner on first and ball is ...
  A: Certainly. If a runner is stealing home and the batter interferes with the play, who is out is ...
running and more.7/13/2010
  Q: I have some questions. I appreciate you asnwering them. 1)If there's a runner on first and ball is ...
  A: Heather, There are a lot of questions, but that's no problem. Overall, you have a good knowledge of ...
Fair or Foul7/4/2010
  Q: Ok so if the batter hits the ball it bounces once before it goes over the third base in fair ...
  A: Heather, To determine if a ground ball is fair or foul, you take the ball's position when it passes ...
Balk- Ball in play6/30/2010
  Q: In American Legion Baseball, runner on first base, trys to steal second, umpire calls balk. Catcher ...
  A: Tom, There are two possibilities, depending on what ruleset your American Legion is playing under. ...
Batting6/28/2010
  Q: If a batter is at bat and gets injured (like hitting a foul ball off his leg and breaks a bone) and ...
  A: Ron, In all rule codes I know, a substitute batter will take the place of the injured batter. This ...
Home Plate Umpire overrules Field Umpire without request6/17/2010
  Q: Setting: U10 Boys Travel Baseball Game, close game, extra innings. Situation: On a force play at ...
  A: Lisa, Simply: No. An umpire should NEVER change the call of another umpire. If an umpire feels ...
3 foot running lane6/17/2010
  Q: In a game last night played under Major League rules, a batter was pinch hit for by another legal ...
  A: Justin, This call is umpire judgment, and the judgment is different depending on the ruleset used. ...
Pinch Hitter6/15/2010
  Q: In a game last night played under Major League rules, a batter was pinch hit for by another legal ...
  A: Justin, According to OBR Rule 3.03, "A player, or players, may be substituted during a game at any ...
Hit By Pitch/Protest6/10/2010
  Q: In a Babe Ruth league, a batter is hit by a pitch. The umpire rules that the batter never tried to ...
  A: Anthony, Whether or not the batter moved is a judgment call by the umpire. However, the coach could ...
Continuous play/does run count?6/9/2010
  Q: This happened in our little league game yesterday. Two outs, runner on third. Ground ball to ...
  A: Bud, The run would not count. I do not have the Little League rules, but I know they closely follow ...
Official scoring5/23/2010
  Q: I remember a few years ago, Big Papi was playing first base and a ball hit hard to him broke ...
  A: Mike, According to the Official Baseball Rules: 10.12 Comment: ...For example, the official scorer ...
pick off play5/7/2010
  Q: Runner leading off first, pitcher throws over. Runner trying to get back ends up with his foot on ...
  A: Gary, Technically, the runner would be out, as he is not touching the base. Thinking of it another ...
dropped 3rd strike5/5/2010
  Q: Is a pitch that bounces prior to reaching the catcher, but is feilded(picked) cleanly by the catcher ...
  A: Brad, Yes. In every rule code, the rules state the catcher must "catch" the third strike. All ...
running out of base path4/24/2010
  Q: recently in a little league game my grandson, a first base man was involved in getting a runner in ...
  A: Eddie, First off, the umpire was wrong. Once the runner goes more than 3 feet away from the ...
Cal Ripken baseball rules3/29/2010
  Q: Question about Cal Ripken baseball rule interpretation...this situation was presented during the ...
  A: Chris, I am not experienced in Cal Ripkin rules. However, I don't see how this situation would be ...
pinch runner3/23/2010
  Q: I have a son playing high school baseball. He was used as a pinch runner twice in the last game. ...
  A: Debi, I am unable to answer the scorebook question, as I have no training in completing an official ...
Bat Rules3/9/2010
  Q: I am considering buying my son a new bat for junior leaguel. He is 14 and will most likely play ...
  A: Joanna, I cannot speak for Junior League, but I can tell you what is in the rules for High School. ...
base running2/23/2010
  Q: can a runner after reaching first base take a lead towards home plate in an attempt to cause ...
  A: Tony, There are two things to consider in this situation (Official Baseball Rules): 7.08(a)(1) Any ...
Foul tip1/8/2010
  Q: I am reading the official Cal Ripken 2009 rule book definitions and have a question about foul tips. ...
  A: Chris, I do not have experience in Cal Ripkin rules, but high school rules are written the same. ...
Sliding rules11/17/2009
  Q: In the Little league world series there were several games that the catcher was in front of the ...
  A: Brian, You are correct. A fielder without possession of the ball cannot stop a fielder from having ...
Runner out at 3rd base11/16/2009
  Q: At my team's last game, there was a situation on which there was a runner at 3rd base, the batter ...
  A: Diego, In most baseball rules, this is an incorrect call as you describe it. If the runner at 3rd ...
Definition of Intentionally Dropping a Ball10/29/2009
  Q: "Here is mycan you please define intentionally dropping the ball?...let me expand, further, if there ...
  A: Winston, Most interpretations of the rule state that the ball must hit the glove for it to be ...
Umpire call reversals10/1/2009
  Q: I am President of the Royal Belgian Baseball & Softball Federation (www.frbbs.be). I would have ...
  A: Jerome, Overall, the umpires did exactly what their job expects them to do: Officiate the game in a ...
Interference9/25/2009
  Q: Mr. Senger, we had the following situation last night in our game and would like to know what the ...
  A: Michael, Using Official Baseball Rules, the call was correct: 7.09 It is interference by a batter ...
pitcher/2nd base8/31/2009
  Q: I would like to know if a pitcher can fast roll/toss a ball backwards towards the second base to ...
  A: Vince, You are correct. As long as the pitcher is not touching the rubber, then he can do whatever ...
pitcher/2nd base8/29/2009
  Q: I would like to know if a pitcher can fast roll/toss a ball backwards towards the second base to ...
  A: Vince, A pitcher would not be allowed to attempt a pick-off as you describe it. The main reason on ...
baseball8/28/2009
  Q: This also happened in a JV game. Not quite sure of ruling. In the game runner on third with one out! ...
  A: John, After the ground out, there were two outs. The runner from third then abandoned his base, ...
baseball8/27/2009
  Q: This also happened in a JV game. Not quite sure of ruling. In the game runner on third with one out! ...
  A: John, Once the umpire determines the runner at third has abandoned his base, he would be called out ...
delayed dead ball8/26/2009
  Q: Happened in a jr high baseball game last night.Runners were on 1st and 2nd and a groundball was ht ...
  A: Mark, In every ruleset I umpire under, the ball is immediately dead when it hits a runner prior to ...
intentional walk rules8/18/2009
  Q: During the Oakland A's TV broadcast on 8/17, there was a trivia question asking why the catcher put ...
  A: Jeff, There are no rules that would answer the question. After asking several fellow umpires, no ...
Appeal8/9/2009
  Q: Two Outs Two Strikes, runner at second. Umpire calls a strike three based upon a swing. No one ...
  A: Mike, Simply: No. Once a strike is called on a check swing, it cannot be reversed. The offense ...
Fair or Foul Balls8/7/2009
  Q: Mr. Senger, I have a couple of questions on whether a ball is fair or foul. 1) If a batter swings ...
  A: Michael, With any foul balls up to (and including) first and third bases, the decision on whether a ...
Can we protest a game after the end of the game?8/2/2009
  Q: In our league in Colorado we have a written rule that states "All players in uniform who are not ...
  A: Charlie, There are no rules that pertain to this type of situation, simply because the "must play" ...
Official Game Line Up Card7/31/2009
  Q: I am an American Legion coach and we are currently playing in our state tournament. We play American ...
  A: Stephen, Depending on how strict the rules were, the player could be ineligible to play. In Major ...
ruling7/24/2009
  Q: There was a play at the plate. Catcher was 4 ft. in front of the plate on the baseline and had ...
  A: Henry, The ruling here all depends on the Official Rules for the league you're umpiring. I'm not ...
Balk7/21/2009
  Q: Game being played under PONY rules. Runner on 2nd, pitcher throws ball and a balk is called batter ...
  A: George, I'm not experienced in PONY rules, but I will give you the answer based on Official ...
Pitching7/14/2009
  Q: After coming to the set position, can a pitcher throw to any base without removing his back foot ...
  A: Of course he can. The easiest example is a left-handed pitcher attempting a pick-off to first base. ...
Does the run count?7/14/2009
  Q: Bases loaded, 2 outs. Batter hits a soft liner to short which is dropped. Runner on second is ...
  A: Randy, I had originally given you the Official Baseball Rules definition of Force Play: A FORCE ...
Pitching rules7/13/2009
  Q: In a recent cubs game, they pulled the pitcher and placed him in the field, another pitcher came ...
  A: Bill, This is allowed: Rule 3.03 Comment: A pitcher may change to another position only once ...
Does the run count?7/12/2009
  Q: Bases loaded, 2 outs. Batter hits a soft liner to short which is dropped. Runner on second is ...
  A: Randy, As long as the runner from second is in a force play, the run would count. A FORCE PLAY is ...
Baseball7/6/2009
  Q: What happens when a foul ball is caught and the fielder accidently runs past the dead ball line with ...
  A: Graeme, If the fielder catches the ball while in dead-ball territory, the ball is a foul ball; no ...
Do the runs count?7/2/2009
  Q: Here is the scenario. Runners on 2nd and 3rd with 2 outs. Batter hits a line drive to the outfield ...
  A: Wes, The runs would not count. The following is from the Official Baseball Rules: 7.12 Unless two ...
baseball rule clarification7/2/2009
  Q: I know from some prior situations that it is hard to correct things once a player goes to the ...
  A: Karen, For situation #1, I will need further information. When you say "the umpire did the quick ...
foul tip out7/2/2009
  Q: Why is a foul tip into the catcher's glove an out on the third strike but not the first two? If a ...
  A: Andy, The difference between the two is found in the Definitions section of the Official Baseball ...
Home Run or Out6/30/2009
  Q: A batter hits a ball that is clearly on its way to leaving the yard. The left fielder continues to ...
  A: Bob, In the situation you gave, the batter would be out as long as the fielder was still in-play ...
Fly ball catch with a runner on first6/29/2009
  Q: I was hoping someone could shed some light on this scenario. Base runner is at first base the ...
  A: Robert, It is correct to award the runner third base. However, the runner must touch first before ...
first baseman causing balks6/27/2009
  Q: Does the first baseman need to be within tagging distance of the runner to receive a throw over from ...
  A: Ron, Official Baseball Rules do not specifically state the rule, but it has been interpreted that ...
Interference by on deck hitter6/26/2009
  Q: There was a play at the plate where the throw from the OF went by the catcher and sliding runner and ...
  A: Vic, Unless the on-deck batter purposely interfered with the play, there is no call. Official ...
batter-runner interference6/24/2009
  Q: this is the scenario: A right handed batter hits a dribbler in fair territory just out in front of ...
  A: Bill, Generally, umpires will ignore this, as both players were doing as they should and no one got ...
Coaching conduct6/23/2009
  Q: Can a coach stand behind the homeplate umpire, behind the backstop while the opposing team is ...
  A: Stacy, Coaches are not allowed behind the umpire during a game. Depending on the ruleset used, the ...
batter6/23/2009
  Q: Does the batter have to make an attempt to avoid being hit by a pitched ball in a major league game/
  A: Armando, In general, a batter must attempt to avoid a pitch. However, some leniency is given on a ...
Rules to protest a game6/22/2009
  Q: Can a manager or team official file an official protest after a game had been officially completed? ...
  A: Roland, The umpire's duties do not carry into ineligible players (other than what has occurred in ...
Rules to protest a game6/22/2009
  Q: Can a manager or team official file an official protest after a game had been officially completed? ...
  A: Roland, For most protests, the protest must be made to the umpire-in-chief prior to the next pitch ...
rubber baseball6/20/2009
  Q: We were playing a baseball game(age 14). The bases were loaded. There were 2 outs. The opposing ...
  A: Sheila, As far as I know, there are no rules governing the penalties of an illegally-used ball. ...
Balk Call6/17/2009
  Q: We play Federation Baseball Rule in our league in Virginia (NVTBL). My pitcher was called for a balk ...
  A: Joe, A spin move is definitely not a balk. In order to pick off a player, the pitcher must gain ...
Runner hit by ball6/16/2009
  Q: College baseball- ball is struck by batter propelling ball on ground thru I field toward right ...
  A: Michael, The main question to ask here is if the ball had passed any infielder other than the ...
11U AA, Nations Baseball6/14/2009
  Q: On live ball play, runner from third attempts to score, runner from second goes touches third and ...
  A: Jose, First off, I had no luck in finding a definite answer in the OBR Rules. However, I've been ...
Game called on account of darkness6/12/2009
  Q: Please offer your opinion on how this should be handled....Game is called at top of 5th inning ...
  A: Anji, The answer all depends on how many innings the game was scheduled for. If it was scheduled ...
Force out in baseball6/10/2009
  Q: We had a situation where there was a force at 2nd base. The second baseman had the ball in his hand ...
  A: Liz, For any force out at a base, the fielder can touch the base with any part of his body, as long ...
throwing a glove and touching the ball6/4/2009
  Q: I understand the rule is three bases if Contact is made but as an umpire how exactly is the call ...
  A: Jim, I would signal obstruction, which is my left arm straight out and hand in a fist. I would also ...
overthrow to first gets stuck in the fence6/3/2009
  Q: I have a rules question for you On an overthrow to first base where the ball gets stuck in the ...
  A: William, Any ball that lodges into a fence is considered an immediate dead ball. In your scenario ...
runner interference5/31/2009
  Q: Runner on 2nd. Batter hits ball towards shortstop, shortstop moves up to play ball and runner on ...
  A: Steve, No, that is not right. The ball is dead immediately on any interference, so whether he was ...
Fair/Foul Ball5/29/2009
  Q: Batter hits a ground ball in the infield that starts in fair territory; the infielder while in fair ...
  A: Ken, When calling a fair or foul ball, the location of the player or where the ball last bounce has ...
catching a fly ball in the outfield5/26/2009
  Q: If an outfielder catches a fly ball and then drops as he exchanges to his other hand to throw back ...
  A: Sandra, According to the Official Baseball Rules, "In establishing the validity of the catch, the ...
Stealing Home, Overrun bases, "Time"5/21/2009
  Q: Several rules involved here- (Minor League 9-12,Kid pitch) Scenario- 5th inning, bases loaded 1 ...
  A: Chad, I'm not familiar with the rules the league you mention uses, but I would assume it's a ...
rules5/20/2009
  Q: ther are runners on 1 and 3 2 out. The batter hits a home run over the fence but the batter fails ...
  A: Both runners will score. An appeal is a time play, so both runners scored before the appeal was ...
Interference5/19/2009
  Q: during a little league game the runner on second was stealing third and the pitch was in the dirt ...
  A: Chris, In your situation, it would definitely be batter's interference. In fact, a batter can still ...
Carrying a caught ball out of play5/18/2009
  Q: In asa softball does the runner have to be in contact with the base occupied when a fielder catches ...
  A: Richard, I am not trained in ASA rules, but I did find a copy of their rulebook online. According ...
majors pitchers5/15/2009
  Q: If the pitcher has control of the ball on the rubber, and runners on first and third, with the ...
  A: Randy, I am a bit confused on what you are asking. I'm assuming the following: After a base hit, ...
running out of base path5/15/2009
  Q: a player is forced to run from 2nd base to third on a ground ball. the ball is fielded by the third ...
  A: Daniel, If the play happened exactly as you mentioned, the runner should not have been called out. ...
Balk Rule Situation5/6/2009
  Q: Runners on first and third, 2 out. Pitcher begins his move, runner on first breaks for second. ...
  A: Baylor, I'm not trained in PONY rules, but I've heard they use modified OBR. None of what you said ...
Balk Rule Situation5/6/2009
  Q: Runners on first and third, 2 out. Pitcher begins his move, runner on first breaks for second. ...
  A: Baylor, I will assume the game was being played under OBR (Official Baseball Rules) rules, which ...
deadball ruling4/30/2009
  Q: This has to do with a recent local high school baseball game. There was a runner on first which had ...
  A: William, The umpires got the call right. According to the NFHS's Baseball Rules, "runners return to ...
Rules4/20/2009
  Q: Please explain the "infield fly" rule. ANSWER: The infield fly rule is a bit like learning to ride ...
  A: When you think about it, it's a great rule. It protects the offensive. If there were runners on ...
Rules4/19/2009
  Q: Please explain the "infield fly" rule.
  A: The infield fly rule is a bit like learning to ride a bike -- it's complicated to understand at ...
Obstruction of a base4/15/2009
  Q: In my opinion, in order to avoid injuries and to be fair to the runner, the fielder, including the ...
  A: John, Catchers feel they have to do it because it's allowed. The difference between home and other ...
Obstruction of a base4/14/2009
  Q: In my opinion, in order to avoid injuries and to be fair to the runner, the fielder, including the ...
  A: John, I am all for safety in sports, especially in non-professional leagues. However, to make a ...
HBP Rule4/13/2009
  Q: I have seen a shifting of umpire calls on batters hit-by- pitch calls. In the last month, I have ...
  A: Julian, In NFHS, the rule simply states that the batter must not "permit a pitched ball to touch ...
scoring and stats question4/6/2009
  Q: I am preparing the stats for a game in which a player was injured, and was out for 2 innings, and ...
  A: Karen, Because you mentioned the re-entry of a player, I'm assuming you're using NFHS (Fed) rules. ...
Balk4/5/2009
  Q: Is it a balk if a a right handed pitcher's right foot leaves the pitching rubber while pitching ...
  A: Laura, I can't find any rules to substantiate my ruling, but I would have to see what you mean. If ...
Out of Play Situations3/26/2009
  Q: I was in a high school game and a ruling was made on the field which I am not sure was correct or ...
  A: Lawrence, I apologize for the delay in answering -- baseball season is beginning to get busy! For ...
Baseball rules3/24/2009
  Q: My son sge 10 asked me if a runner and the baseman who catches the ball reach the base at the same ...
  A: Dixie, According to Official Baseball Rules (OBR, the rules used by Major League Baseball): 7.01 A ...
pitch count when a player competes in a league and in weekend travel ball3/23/2009
  Q: Little League Baseball of course employs pitch counts with all age groups. an 11-12 yr old can throw ...
  A: I cannot speak for this particular weekend league, but most have a supplemental set of rules that ...
Home Run Stolen? Or Not?3/12/2009
  Q: Ball is going over right field fence when fielder jumps up, catches it (glove over fence) and goes ...
  A: If I felt the ball would have gone over the fence on the fly, I would rule this a home run. If I ...
covering 3rd and 1st3/4/2009
  Q: Sorry in advance about the length of this question... 3rd baseman straddling the bag while a runner ...
  A: Doug, OBR 4.03 states: "When the ball is put in play ... all fielders other than the catcher shall ...
interference2/9/2009
  Q: I get a little confused with 7.08g and 6.06c with regards to the batter interfering with the catcher ...
  A: This situation would fall under 6.06c. The Comment for the rule states "If the batter interferes ...
interference2/9/2009
  Q: I get a little confused with 7.08g and 6.06c with regards to the batter interfering with the catcher ...
  A: Roger, The rule is set the way it is to penalize the offense. For example, if the batter were ...
dead ball ques.2/4/2009
  Q: runner on 1st,batter receives ball four. catcher catches ball four. runner on 1st hassles to 2nd but ...
  A: Jorge, I will assume that the ruleset used was Official Baseball Rules (OBR). If another ruleset was ...

All Questions in This Category

Baseball Instruction

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Andrew Senger

Top Expert on this page

Expertise

Anything related to baseball rules.

Experience

I am a baseball umpire. I am certified for High School (NFHS), and work in Missouri (MSHSAA). I also umpire for local leagues that use both NFHS and OBR.

Organizations
NFHS - National Federation of High Schools MSHSAA - Missouri State High School Athletic Association GSLAU - Greater St. Louis Association of Umpires

Education/Credentials
I have attended numerous training lessons on umpiring. Many of these lessons including Rules Interpretations.

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.