Bible Studies/Romans 3:23

Advertisement


Question
Is the Catholic Church belief that Mary was without sin a
contradiction of Scripture (Romans 3:23 "all have sinned and fall short")?  Otherwise I would accept that Mary was
without sin according to oral tradition.

Answer
Great question and the answer is YES! It is ABSOLUTELY a contradiction of Scripture to say that Mary was without sin, whether before of after the birth of Jesus. as you pointed out with Romans 3:23, Scripture says that we are ALL BORN sinners and the mother of Jesus is absolutely included.

Thanks for the question!

Todd

Bible Studies

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Todd Tyszka

Expertise

My degrees and studies are mostly in Christian doctrine but I will answer questions having to do with almost any aspect of Christianity and The Bible.

Experience

My experience consists of over 20 years as a Pastor, Youth Pastor, missionary, counselor, teacher, writer, Bible quizzer, and various other leadership positions. I've studied the Bible for over 20 years at 5 different schools/seminaries but I can explain things in simple terms anyone can understand and currently teach Sunday School to 1st-5th graders. I specialize in Christian apologetics (evidences for Christianity) and Polemics (debate denouncing false teachings), as well as understanding difficult verses, and topics such as heaven & hell, denominations/sects, false teachings/heresies/cults, the Holy Spirit, gifts of the Holy Spirit, spiritual warfare, apostolic reformation, emergent/emerging church, prosperity teaching, contradictions/discrepancies, charismatic studies, creation/evolution, Greek/Hebrew studies, end times, deliverance, the apocrypha/pseudepigrapha, etc. I daily answer questions on Global Media Outreach, AllExperts, YouTube, through email, and various personal websites where I have posted many Christian videos.

Education/Credentials
Graduated from a private Christian High School, went to Nazarene Bible college and then Eastern Nazarene College (Boston) for Youth Ministry and Pastoral Studies/Christian Theology, transferred to Asbury College where I completed my degree in Christian Education and Missions, and most recently attending the Calvary Chapel Bible Institute.

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.