Expert: Dan Griffin - 3/31/2008

Question
I have a stone fireplace with stone storage/seating that extends from the hearth along a wall. This was all put in long after the house was built. I do not have a brick chimney. There is a metal vent that extends from my roof. I want to remove the storage boxes as well as the entire fireplace. What is the best way to get rid of the stone and mortar? Would this be done with a chisel? Any help you can give would be helpful. It appears the previous owner cut into the paneling and put in the fireplace.

Answer
Kayla, this will be a chore.  Neither you or I know what size stone or how good of mortar he used, but there is sure a bunch of weight to remove.  Is there another use for the stone outdoors?  This is one of those jobs that almost no one can screw up so it can be fun to make a party occasion.  Organize several wheel barrows, buy some cheap gloves, buy some Harbor Freight 2-5# hammers and heavy cold chisels.  I don't really feel you would gain anything with a power hammer, though you could sure rent one for the day.  They are heavy and brutal on the operator.  A chip hammer is not the right tool, nor is a pavement breaker.  Invite an assortment of friends, neighbors, family, co-workers for a demolition party that happens to include beer and burgers.  You should have done a few so that you know exactly what is involved as far as stone chips, visqueen protection, exit path, what to do with the stuff, container(s) for dust and mortar.  It may be quite possible to sell or at least get rid of the stone on Craiglist or Freecycle.

Be prepared to remove and seal from the top down.  Have the chimney down before the demoltion party or have a smaller party for it.  YOu will probably be removing the paneling also and will need to develop a plan for new surfaces.  I don't suppose you would like a nice stone wall? <grin>