Expert: Ted Barnhill (Principal, Design45 LLC) - 11/20/2009

Question
We purchased new home with real stone fireplace.  I believe the stone is placed over a cinder block fireplace structure. Can this stone be removed so that we can make it more contemporary with Marble or Tile?  and if so is it easy to do or is the cinderblock going to get damaged in the process?

Answer
Ross,
Stone comes in a seemingly infinite array of choices, from full field stones to thin veneer in a range of finishes.  It is usually considered a "premium" material and adds value to your home, but if you truly want to replace it, there are several options.  If it is full thickness masonry (normally 4" or more), then it most likely sits on a "brick ledge" or thickened foundation, and may extend through your roof as a stone chimney.  If this is the case, then removing the stone will cause a range of problems, as you cannot removed the interior stone and leave the chimney alone.  If the stone is a thin veneer (less than 2" thick) then it can be normally removed and replaced fairly simply.  You mason or tile setter should have no problem removing it without damaging the concrete block structure.

Either way, another option to consider is to leave the stone in place and tile over it.  You may need to use cement or cement board to level the surface first.  Depending on your particular situation, including the floor condition, any mantle, etc., this may be easier and less messy than removing your stone.

Good luck, and enjoy your new home.

Ted Barnhill
Design 45, LLC