Expert: Eileen Cronk - 6/28/2008

Question
I want to refinish or paint existing oak bathroom cabinet to a black color. What would be the best method/paint/stain to use?

Answer
Hi Kevin
Nice to hear from you.
It would be real easy to answer this by just telling you to paint.
But when I do a job for myself I always strive to do it the very best way I can.
I was glad to see you want the "best method" too.
But best is usually the most time consuming so be prepared for some work.
First the cabinet must be stripped of all existing finish.
Here is a stripper I recommend.
http://www.jamestowndistributors.com/userportal/show_product.do?pid=1694&familyN...
Follow all precautions.
Next is the stain.
First try a small can of Minwax black stain.
Simply wipe the stain on with a rag.
I would test it on the back of a door (just a small spot).
If the color is not dark enough to suit you, and it may not be as oak often does not absorb stain well (but sometimes does LOL), then you must get a dye stain and practice applying it on some scrap wood.
It can be tricky stuff to use so don't by pass the practice.
This will be dark enough to suit I'm sure.
After the stain, 3 coats of Minwax fast frying oil based poly in a satin finish.
You will now have a cabinet that will look good for many years.
Unlike a painted surface that will need redoing in a year.
More work in the beginning but in the end this will save you time and money.
Regards
Eileen
PS..If you have any problem removing the finish get back to me.
I am hoping this cabinet is old enough that it does not have one of those hard to remove lacquer finishes.