Expert: Jamie Yocono - 4/5/2009

Question
QUESTION: in a former article re cabinets, you discussed the choices of hardwoods,ie alder,
birch, maybe oak, never maple. please advise, "why never maple."

ANSWER: Hi Robert,

I think that previous answer of mine that said "never Maple" was referring to something specific about their question. I don't remember the EXACT question, but I think it was about staining or finishing Maple, and they were asking which wood would give the best results. Maple is often problematic when finishing it. With the way it's grain can swirl, it often results in splotchy results. It can be completely frustrating to many woodworkers.

There is a book - Understanding Wood Finishing" by Bob Flexner, that is most helpful when finishing wood. It discusses a variety of techniques for ensuring good results, and it give info about fixing problem finishes, too. Bob discusses Maple in depth here, and his tips would be invaluable to someone wanting to use Maple.

It's just more difficult to work with -it's hard and often doesn't machine that well in the planer or jointer. But if you know how to work it, and can apply a decent finish, it's a wonderful wood.

I hope this helps clarify my thoughts on Maple, honestly... I like it! If you have more questions, write back.

Jamie Yocono
Wood It Is! Custom Cabinetry
Las Vegas, NV
www.wooditis.com

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: hi jamie, thanks for being so prompt.  re maple, if i choose maple from a
reputable dealer and cabinet doors were professionally stained and installed,
would i most likely be as satisfied with maple as with other woods.the finished
{honey maple} samples i've viewed looked very satisfactory. should i be
concerned that a light maple will "yellow" over time.

Answer
Robert,

Don't get me wrong, Maple is a lovely wood. As a woodworker, it's a little difficult, in terms of machining, sanding and finishing. But as a homeowner, I welcome it as a gorgeous wood. Yes, it will yellow a bit over time, depending on what finish is used, but it is amazing in it's durability and beauty.

If you're someone who enjoys wood and it's aesthetic value, you will enjoy having Maple in your home. Years ago, I had a veterinarian who remodeled her entire office in Birds Eye Maple. It was the most gorgeous animal clinic I've ever seen, and it remained so, despite all the wear and tear that it underwent from it's "patients". Thinking of that place reminds me how lovely Maple can be.

I wouldn't be that concerned about the yellowing. I look at it this way - about the time it starts yellowing, you'll be getting on in the years and your eyes may not be as sharp. So you won't even notice it!

No, I'm kidding. If you get a professional to do the finishing, they can suggest some finishes that won't yellow as bad as some can. Rely on their years of expertise and you should do fine.

Good luck!

Jamie in Vegas


____________
Jamie Yocono
Wood It Is! Custom Cabinetry
Las Vegas, NV
www.wooditis.com
My woodworking blog: www.wooditis.blogspot.com