Expert: Jamie Yocono - 5/22/2007

Question
Hi,
I am struggling b/w buying a self-storing table and chairs made of Maple or Birch. I have found one that is very similar made from Birch that is less money.
I have small children and I want something that can take their abuse. Which one would you recommend for durability?

Answer
Hi Kelly,

Someone asked me a question quite similar to this recently. I'm going to use part of that answer to answer this question.

Both of the woods you mentioned are deciduous hardwoods, meaning that they come from trees that lose their leaves. Hardwoods are considered the best woods to use for furniture making, so you're having to decide between two very durable woods.

That said, Maple is probably considered the premium of the two species. Birch grain is just a little more plain than Maple, and when it's finished, it doesn't give you the "wow" factor that Maple gives.

To tell you the truth, it's like choosing between a Chrysler and a Dodge. Close.... but it depends on what you're attracted to.

So.... in my opinion, if the prices are close, I would chose the Maple. If there's a huge difference in cost, Birch would be a good way to save some money. But logically speaking, both woods are quite similar in durability.

Maple would be my choice. Some wood "snobs" consider it to be the Cadillac of domestic hardwoods.

Hope you didn't mind my automobile comparisons... it just seems an easy way to explain it!

One last thought- is it possible there are constructional differences between the two sets you're considering? Are they made with the same quality? Do the joints look strong? Is the finish nice, with no bubbling or flecks in it? These would be other things I would look at when making your choice. Wood is a factor, but the way it's constructed is another factor.

If you want to send me a link to the two pieces that you're considering, I'd be glad to take a look at them and see if I can figure out any discernible differences. But if you're just deciding by wood (and price) alone, Birch is probably just as durable as Maple, in my opinion.

OK, good luck, I hope this helps. Please feel free to write back if you have any further questions after reading this. And if this answer was helpful... please take a minute and rate my service. Thanks!

Jamie Yocono
Wood It Is! Custom Cabinetry
Las Vegas, NV
www.wooditis.com