You are here:

Calculus/AP Calculus Implicit Differentiation, Vertical Tangents, and Second Derivatives


This is a two-part question:

First, how do you find the derivative of y+cos(y)=x+1? I know you need to use implicit differentiation, but I don't understand how you would use it in this case.

Second, how would you determine the coordinate points for the derivative's vertical tangents?

For y+cos y =x+1, when you differentiate both sides with respect to x, you will have

   (1-siny) dy/dx = 1 =====>  dy/dx = 1/ (1-siny)

Note that implicit differentiation is carried out on the LHS of the above because
the expression for the LHS is purely given in terms of y, and you are differentiating indirectly wrt x.

If this still bothers you, here is a more fundamental explanation for how I obtained the LHS of the above:

   d/dx ( y+ cos y) = d/dy (y+cosy) * (dy/dx) = (1-siny) dy/dx

When the derivative has vertical tangents, it simply means the gradient function dy/dx equals infinity, or dx/dy =0

In this case, we set 1-siny =0 , ie siny =1  which therefore means y=pi/2 , x =pi/2 -1 (this is obtained through substituting the y value found into the original expression)

Hope this helps. Peace.


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Frederick Koh


I can answer questions concerning calculus, complex numbers, vectors, statistics , algebra and trigonometry for the O level, A level and 1st/2nd year college math/engineering student.


More than 7 years of experience helping out in various homework forums. Latest Presence is over at . You can also visit my main maths website where I have designed "question locker" vaults to store tons of fully worked math problems. A second one is currently being built. Peace.

IEEE(Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers )

Former straight As A level student from HCJC (aka HCI); scored distinctions in both C and Further Mathematics B Eng (Hons) From The National University Of Singapore (NUS) B Sc (Hons) From University of London External (Grad Route)

©2016 All rights reserved.