Careers: Acting, Performing, Directing/Films (Movies) v/s Plays (Dramas).


Dear Peter

which according to you for an artist is a more challenging role to portrait i.e In Movies  or Plays (Dramas) ?.

Is it not always the Plays or Dramas because In Plays (Dramas), the artist has to perform live before the audience ?

Example :

There is a Movie "Romeo and Juliet" - 2 hours duration.
There is also a Play "Romeo and Juliet" - 2 hours duration.

Now the artist who has portrait the role of Romeo in both is common. i.e Same Artist has acted in both the Movie as well as
in the Drama.

Is it possible that An Artist who is acting in both Movies as well as in Plays may or may not be successful in one of them ?
i.e. Audience have appreciated his/her acting skills in Movies but not in Plays or vice versa.

if that is the above case what could be the reasons ?. Script,
Co stars, Direction, Music, Environment etc

Awaiting your reply,

Thanks & Regards,
Prashant S Akerkar

The opinion or each artist will differ, as you imply, but for me the film role would be more challenging.

On stage, after considerable rehearsal and cast discussions, in costumes and a setting that is familiar, the performance is shown to an audience in a two-hour unit that runs continuously.

In film, after some discussion with the director, the actor starts playing sections of the performance completely out of chronological order. The party scenes will be shot together so that there is minimum use of dancing extras in the backgound, followed perhaps by the final scenes around the suicides, followed by the street fights, then the close-ups at the party, etc etc.

In film, the emotional journey is constructed by the editor out of fragments of performance, abetted by music and other post-production effects.

It is quite possible that the stage Romeo may not be as popular in the film version, not because the audience sees his skills or not, but because he could not hold his performance in his mind's eye as he jumped here are there in it. The director or editor may not have been in sympathy with his interpretation -- most film acting is not strongly opinionated in its attitude, and allows all sorts of interpretations to be applied to it -- and may have presented a reality around a gloomy hero, full of shadow and suspicion, in which the normal likeable but doomed teenager looks like a self-absorbed fool.

Careers: Acting, Performing, Directing

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Peter Messaline


This is the place for Canadian answers! My company runs "The Advisors", a Toronto-based career-power network for performers, producers and entertainment artists of all sorts. I am a performer, and I have not had a joe-job in the last thirty-odd years, so I must be doing something right. I can talk about career moves, self-promotion, self-production, and the business sense that turns your art into a living.


I am the most published Canadian arts entrepreneur.
The Actor's Survival Kit, Tax Kit 2000+, Tax CD, The Art of Managing Your Career.

Canadian Equity, ACTRA, AEA, BAEA

The Actor's Survival Kit, Tax Kit 2000+, The Agents Book, The Art of Managing Your Career, The Organizer, Equity News, ACTRA newsletters.

Awards and Honors
"Many people in the audience applauded warmly when it was time for him to leave the stage" (Local review of my Bill Walker in "Major Barbara" at the Shaw Festival.

©2016 All rights reserved.