Careers: Military--Army, Navy, Airforce, Marines, Coast Guard/A bit of a complicated question ...

Advertisement


Question
Well ... this is a question for a story.  It's a bit complicated so I hope I can explain properly :D  It seems your experience that you listed might be well suited to answer this ;)

First off, this takes place in an entirely fictional setup that I did not create all of ... but things are based almost *directly* off of the current US Navy (ok, I know you're in the Coast Guard)

Essentially, it's as if there is the UN, and the naval force then is part of the *UN* and not part of the individual member countries ...
(The analogy does not quite hold up when it is the current setup of federal govt. vs. state govt. and laws.)
All people are citizens of their country and the "UN" and are of course subject to the laws of both.  The "UN" upholds its members' laws of course but does not have the jurisdiction to enforce laws that are not its own.  (Yes, just like federal vs. state.)

So.

A guy, an officer in this, commits a crime which is only against the laws of his own member country (which he retains citizenship to), while on board ship ... the victim is not a citizen of the same place he is.  Due to several irrelevant factors, she chooses not only to let the entire matter go, not to press charges or pursue any type of investigation or *anything*, but also will not identify him as the one who did it ...

My question is: what legal authority does the ship's commander have in this situation?  He is aware of the guy's country's law, at least.  Can he press for an investigation or conduct an investigation based on that he knows this is a crime in another jurisdiction?  Can he be a part of or conduct an investigation at all, regardless of jurisdiction?
Does it make a difference that the victim is being so ... unhelpful? :D

I hope I haven't left out any major information!

Answer
Caren,

I think your question is a matter of jurisdiction.  There are three components of jurisdiction (persons, location and substantive law).  For example as a federal law enforcement officer I have jurisdiction over people (example us citizens), in certain areas (example us territorial sea), for the enforcement of certain laws (example federal fisheries laws...of note I can't enforce state fisheries laws).

In your situation the CAPT would have jurisdiction over his(or her) crew, the ship but the law broken would need to be one that he(or she) is permitted to enforce.  

In reality we have UN naval task forces that serve under the TACTICAL control of UN commands but remain under the ADMINISTRATIVE control of there national fleet.  Rarely if ever do you have crewmembers from differing nations aboard one ship for really the very situation you propose.  Certainly you can have liaison officers attached to a unit but actual crewmembers are usually citizens of the same country subject to the same laws.

R/

LCDR John Fiorentine USCG

Careers: Military--Army, Navy, Airforce, Marines, Coast Guard

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


John Fiorentine

Expertise

Active Duty Coast Guard Lieutenant Commander. My specialties are opertations afloat and operations ashore; three afloat tours and three ashore tour under my belt including command afloat and navy exchange. My staff assignments have been with Officer Personnel Management as a Career Counselor, White House Military Office as a Social Aide, and at the Office of Law Enforcement within CG Headquarters as a program analyst. I can answer questions related to the Coast Guard, the assignment process, officer specialties, OCONUS duty, afloat and ashore operations. I can also answer questions related to the White House Social Aide Program.

Experience

WMEC Deck Watch Officer Portsmouth VA; DD Combat Info Center Officer Yokosuka Japan (Navy Exchange); WPB Commanding Officer San Juan PR; Enforcement Div Sector San Juan PR; Career Counselor (OPM-4); Law Enforcement Program Analyst (CG-MLE); Command Center Chief Sector San Juan PR

Organizations
USCGA Alumni Association, OutServe, Society of White House Military Aides.

Education/Credentials
B.S. in Government from the US Coast Guard Academy; M.S.A in Leadership from Central Michigan University

Awards and Honors
CG Commendation Medal, USN Achievement Medal, CG Achievement Medal, CG Commandant Letter of Commendation

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.