Expert: Cynthia Bedell - 7/9/2007

Question
Hello, I  originally injured my knee during a company function(ski trip)in 2001. The condition was bad but being the "high speed" person that I was at the time I ignored it and continued to suck it up even though I was in consistent pain. I ended up getting a P2 profile. In 2005 while deployed I severely re injured my knee.  I received a P3 profile, physical therapy, steroid injections and all kinds of medication and have had two surgeries since. The injury has not got better and I have recently requested an MEB.   (I'm tired) I am an MP prison guard and can no longer do my job the way I should. I can't respond to disturbances or even protect my self in needed  because my knee is so unstable. I have  10 years service E-6. The cause of the re-injury can't be disclosed because of "security reasons"  will this effect me being medically retired or receiving separation pay?  It is documented that there is a legit injury that is not getting better. But the cause is not disclosed. Also if I can no longer function as a soldier AT ALL such as   Running, 3-5 second rushes, crouch position during ranges, move with a fighting load, and if I can't funciton as an MP( respond to disturbances, use unarmed self defense, respond to emergencies etc... can I even be declared fit for duty.  I honestly can no longer do these things.  Its upsetting because I was that High Speed soldier that every unit has.  Now I have been reduced to "watching from the sidelines"  especially as a Military Police Corrections Guard.  
Thank you for your answer.

Answer
Dear Ezekiel --

I understand your frustration.  Asking for a medical evaluation board is difficult for someone dedicated to service and to doing a great job.  You served your country for ten years, and were injured in service. Your medical needs should be taken care of by the government.  

You have a couple options.  

1)  You could transfer to a branch that needs your brains and leadership more than it needs your brawn, and remain on duty with your P3 profile.

2) You could get a complete replacement of your injured knee, and after a recovery period, see if you are capable of doing the job you love once again.

3) You can accept a medical discharge.  (Not recommended in your case, you will lose the benefits you deserve).

or

4) You can insist on a medical retirement.  To get a medical retirement, you will have to be willing to accept a branch transfer to a less physical MOS.  The reason for this is you must be able to convince the board that you had every intention of doing at least 20 years in service, before you got out.  The only reason you are even considering getting out now is because your military related injuries are keeping you from safely and effectively doing your job.  If you convince them of this they can recommend you for military retirement (small pension and benefits come with this).  Or they can recommend to transfer you to an MOS what does not require you to have the same level of physical prowess as you need now.

The fact that they cannot be told the event that caused your injury during your deployment should not be a problem.  The only way it would be a problem, is if you were doing something illegal when you were injured and your injury was declared "non-line of duty."  If your injury, is "line of duty" non-disclosed for security reasons, you should have no issues.

Good luck to you.  Write back, if particular questions come up, that I may be able to help you answer.