Expert: Dick Rogers - 7/24/2009

Question
I recently graduated from Colgate University, in May 2009, with bachelors degree in Sociology.  I consider myself to have great problem solving and analytical skills as well as drive and determination in anything I do.  I've been speaking with my father regarding career options and I mentioned my desire to become a detective, yet I'm not sure in which field.  Although we had the same feelings regarding the work and career path, he offered a different approach to an overall goal.  

My notion was that I could start out as any other going through the academy and entry-level patrol duties, hopefully working my way up the ladder to eventual becoming a detective.  My thoughts, through researching information on-line, is that is would take roughly 1-2 years to accomplish my goal of detective in a big city such as New York, D.C., Chicago, L.A. or other high traffic areas.  After spending time as a detective, I would then consider options of joining organizations like the DEA or FBI, depending upon my progression.  

His opinion, while he agreed I would be great as a detective, was to start out with Marine OCS, spend my 5 years, and then pursue a career in DEA, FBI, or even as a Police detective.

But, the end result of our conversation was his confession to me that everything I have done, I have done with drive and excellence.  Given my own personal skills and my willingness to succeed and help, he thinks I would make a fantastic officer and a great detective.  His rationality is that, in order to be with the best I need to train with the best.  Given the brief information I have supplied for you; what would be your thoughts on the best path?

Answer
Brian, both of you have really good insights on what would be a valid path for your career.  I think what you have to do is determine what type of investigative field interests you.  Frankly, I would stay away from any drug enforcement unit.  I see it as a frustrating and unrewarding type of work...plus our direction in this regard has been too long flawed.  To be a good detective requires what I call the three "S"requirements...Shoe leather, Scotch and Snitches.  All are symbolic.  The FBI is a stellar organization but much of what you do is directed until you reach a level where you can do the directing.  There isn't much you figure out as an individual.  Being a detective on a large department provides you with the skills needed to do straight forward police work.  You have one of what I call the basic requirements in todays world...a college education.  You should then decide on what department interests you...apply, become a patrol officer, develop all of the skills needed in detective work, i.e., rules of evidence, case law, requirements in affidavits for search warrants, etc.  You should be able to transfer into a detective unit in four or five years, and if homicide interests you, in ten to fifteen years.  I sort of boils down to whether you want to be the conductor or one being conducted...if you get my drift.  Good luck.