Expert: Loren Stevens - 2/11/2007

Question
Hi Loren,

After visiting a few forums comparing HKs & Sid Sauers, I decided I would choose a Sid because of their accuracy & trigger action. I will be using this as a concealed weapon with a handgun permit/training. I might go to the range & fire a box maybe once each month. The Sid I desire would be ss lightweight as possible & easily to fairly concealable, of the .40 or .45 caliber size. I realize that handling/firing one will also help refine one's choices. I read that the P 239 is concealable.

Could you assist my gun selection decision by relating which model of Sid Sauer semi automatic in a .40 or .45 caliber you would prefer to carry as a personal defense concealed weapon, if you're only choice in a gun would be a Sid?

Should I examine any things closely or in particular regarding these Sid handguns while shopping at gunstores?

Thank you greatly,

Mike E.  

Answer
Hello Mike,
I think you mean a "Sig"..
Anyhow, choice of a weapon is a very personal decision. It boils down to preference, and which one you are more competent with.
I'm "old school"  I preferred a Browning Hi-power, 1911-Colt, or Colt Commander, and an Iver-Johnson .22LR auto as a backup.
Today, there is alot of support for a variety of choices: Glock, Sig, Heckler&Koch etc. et al.
Along with the weapon you are considering, the caliber should also be a consideration. What is the intent of the weapon???... A .45 has alot of shock power to it, assuming you get the right grain, and type round. A 9mm, is a very fast round, but not alot of shock, or stopping power. Some folks like to load their own, and make a very "HOT"  round. If you don't know what you are doing, this is very dangerous.
Some people labor over a choice between a revolver and a semi-auto.
What is arguably the best factoid for a revolver, is you get 6 ways to say no...EVERY TIME!! There is no jamming, no "stove-pipe" of shell casing etc.
And, along with other issues, which is the easiest to conceal?...If that is a concern, you need to entertain that too. Some hand guns are just difficult to hide and/or carry. I always hated to carry a mdl 59, or 39 Smith...They just set wrong with me.
When you get down to it, you'll STILL need to consider issues that are relevant to your choice, then factor in your personal choice too.
Don't forget to consider cost, ammo cost resale value etc. And, what research exists on each weapon, reliability, repair costs, parts etc.
On a closing note, I'd urge you to formally document all training and instruction you do with your ultimate choice. If you ever get into a "shootemup" where somebody ends up leaking, you'll favor your position, if you call illustrate a measure of "due diligence."
Good Luck, and be careful,
Regards,
loren