You are here:

Catholics/Am I considered a satanist?


There are two reasons that I believe may class me as a satanist.
Please note: I do not mean to offend anyone of any religion!

One- I believe that it was Satan that created free will. For in Genesis, God did forbid Adam and Eve to eat from one tree in Eden, it was Satans doing that lead them to the freedom of eating whatever they wanted.

Two- this may not make me a satanist but I have met a few Christians that have hated me forth is belief. I believe that Judas did no wrong! God tricked Judas in to deceiving Jesus then punished him for doing this. Would you tell someone your son went to school with to steal his lunchbox and then give him detention for it, even though it was you that made him do it???

Thank you and I eagerly await your response!


You are not a Satanist, but you hold some mistaken beliefs.

First, God created free will.  Free will is a capacity to chose one thing over another.  God created everything, including Satan and free will.  He gave some creatures (such as angels and humans) the capacity to make choices.  He did not give this to other creatures (such as trees and rocks).  Satan did lead them to make the wrong decision, but it is an error in logic to say he created what was (necessarily) already present.

Second, I have no idea why you say that God tricked Judas into betraying Jesus.  There is no where in the Bible where such an idea is held.  Judas betrayed Jesus out of his own free will as a result of his greed.  Any of the other 11 apostles could have betrayed Jesus.  None of them did.  Judas didn't have to betray Jesus.  God did not make him do it.  The devil did not make him do it.  No one made him do it but himself.

Furthermore, it is wrong even to say that God punished Judas.  Judas punished himself by committing suicide.  He could have gone to Jesus and asked for forgiveness, which is what Peter and Thomas did.  Instead, out of his own free will and guilt, he decided to punish himself by cutting himself off from that mercy by means of suicide.

With prayers,


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Cody Sain


Society for Re-Evangelization

I will answer questions regarding Catholic teachings and Catholic philosophy, including misconceptions and objections to the faith. I will usually recommend further reading, and I welcome follow-up questions.

In particular I welcome questions about:
-Mary & The Saints
-The Pope, Bishops, Priests, Monks & Nuns
-Vatican II
-Women in the Church
-Justification & Sanctification
-The last judgment, Purgatory, Heaven, Hell
-What the Catholic Church says about the "rapture" and the "millennium"
-Anti-catholics, esp. Jack Chick
-Angels & Devils
-The Eucharist (Holy Communion, Lord's Supper)
-The problem of evil
-The problem of divine foreknowledge, free will, and predestination
-Questions about love & sex, abortion, contraception, homosexuality, and other "HOT TOPICS."
-Questions about Church policy in regards to Catholic politicians in the United States.

I prefer not to be asked questions about canon law (the law of the church) especially with respect to marriage and annulments, or other personal questions of a spiritual nature. I can give you general answers, but I find that these questions are best asked by a priest or spiritual director. Your local pastor or diocese should be able to help you.

Restrictions: **Please ask one question at a time. Do not come to me with a laundry list of questions and expect me to answer them all together in one fell swoop. If I feel your question is less of a question and more of an attack, I may refuse to answer it.**

Guidelines for follow-ups:

When engaging in an extended discussion, I will respond to the specific points you make, and I expect you to do the same. If you are argumentative and ignore my points in order to make your own, I may decide to refuse to answer your question altogether.


I was raised Southern Baptist and converted to Catholicism in 2003. I'm familiar with many the misconceptions of Catholicism. I also hold an MA in philosophy from Boston College. I have been on All Experts since 2001, when I was in high school, before I was Catholic. I will be reviewing my old answers and offering any corrections or further explanation when necessary.

Knights of Columbus (both 3rd and 4th degree)

BA, Philosophy & Religious Studies: Texas A&M University
MA, Philosophy: Boston College

©2017 All rights reserved.