Expert: Marco - 6/25/2004

Question
Hi how are u Marco thank you again for your nice answer...sorry i didnt answer you before but i was a little busyI have a few more questionss.. to discuss :))

>>>>Why physics deny the hipotesis of materialism?Why consciousness is against the law of physics?

Because the laws of physics prove that matter does not generate consciousness (in particular, they prove that cerebral processes do not gnerate consciousness).

**1)Can you explain to me a little more especific why law of physics prove matter does not generate consciousness.. ?is interesting because the book I told you write bye Edleman (nobel prize in medicine) and Tononi, is called " A universe of consciousness, how matter becomes imagination"..


>>>>I believe the part that consciousness can came from evolution , i think God with one thing can do anything and He just did it like when you play cards one and next other to reach the end.. do u think is posible?

No. According to the laws of physics, consciousness cannot come from evolution; the existence of consciousness requires the existence of an unphysical/unbiological element. Evolution is related only to material/biological elements.

*2)maybe not consciosness but what if or brain is like a radio recibing and emiting conections with brain.. maybe we should need a special structure that cames from evolution to do it..dont you think its possible? Structure is improtant in brain and maybe a little difference between animals and humans can help a little..to be consciousness of us of God dont you think so?

>>>What happend in a person with multiple personality desorder, where for now there is no organic finding and is think as a mind disorder or separation.. ?

I think hat psychical disorders are always a consequence of sin. I think that sin generate in man a psychical instability which, like a cancer, destroys gradually our mind. Onl God can heal us from our sins and give
us a pure and holy life.

*3)Well in this question i must desagree, i believe that yes sin can generate a psychical instability but under no way multiple personality disorder is a sin problem you are being a little "reduccionist" in this :PP, there are a lot of physical or psichical trauma probe to be one of the motives of this disorder some kind of selfdefense mecanism from our mind agains a trauma (like rape, etc) from this point of view how can you explain so division? how can soul be divided? is imposible.. but i believe is posible that mind divides, i think mind us a part of soul.. not the soul itself..i think tht soul is the escence of anyone but im not completaly sure is mind..well nice to chat with you.. wait for next talk :))
see you nacho..


PD: by the way.. a completaly different question..that you can answer mne if you like soccer maybe, as i told you im traveling to italy today..i want to see the semifinales of the America Cup (is like champions league for you) agains River Plate and Boca Juniors, do u know where i can see it i mean a TV channel at italy that shows international soccer live? like espn maybe? well i hope you can answer both ejje see you thank you again..


Answer
**1)Can you explain to me a little more especific why law of physics prove matter does not generate consciousness.. ???

Dear Nacho,
The laws of physics prove that all cerebral processes consist only in some successions of elementary kinetic and electromagnetic processes, that is motion of elementary particles and emission and absorption of photons. This is sufficient to prove that brain and matter do not generate consciousness. I have explain this at the best of my possibilities in the articles presented in the site

http://xoomer.virgilio.it/fedeescienza/englishnf.html

>>>>*2)maybe not consciosness but what if or brain is like a radio recibing and emiting conections with brain.. maybe we should need a special structure that cames from evolution to do it..dont you think its possible? Structure is improtant in brain and maybe a little difference between animals and humans can help a little..to be consciousness of us of God dont you think so?

I am sorry, but I do not understand your point. As I have said, there is no doubt that an interaction between psyche and brain must exist. However my point is that consciousness and every psychical experience cannot be generated by the brain; the brain may have only a preliminary role. Think about the example of the eyes; if your eyes are damaged, you can no longer see anyhing clear; This however does not mean that the visual sensation is generated by our eyes; the eye has only a preliminary role in the process that leads to the creation of the visual sensation. The creation of the visual sensation, as well as of every other psychical experience, transcends the laws of physics. This is sufficient to prove the existence of an unphysical element in man; the psyche or soul or mind, who cannot be indentified with the brain.


>>>>*3)Well in this question i must desagree, i believe that yes sin can generate a psychical instability but under no way multiple personality disorder is a sin problem you are being a little "reduccionist" in this :PP, there are a lot of physical or psichical trauma probe to be one of the motives of this disorder some kind of selfdefense mecanism from our mind agains a trauma (like rape, etc) from this point of view how can you explain so division??

This is exactly my point. Multiple personality is a psychical disorder caused by sin, for example a rape (which is a sin, even if not a sin committed by the victim of the rape)


>>>how can soul be divided??

I have never said that the soul is divided; the soul can never be divided. You must have misunderstood my words.

>>>PD: by the way.. a completaly different question..that you can answer mne if you like soccer maybe, as i told you im traveling to italy today..i want to see the semifinales of the America Cup (is like champions league for you) agains River Plate and Boca Juniors, do u know where i can see it i mean a TV channel at italy that shows international soccer live?? like espn maybe?? well i hope you can answer both ejje see you thank you again..


Unfortunaely I cannot help you. I do not know where you can see it in Italy.

See you,

marco.