AllExperts > Catholics 
Search      
Catholics
Volunteer
Answers to thousands of questions
 Home · More Catholics Questions · Question Library  · Free Encyclopedia ·
More Catholics Answers
Question Library

Ask a question about Catholics
Volunteer
Experts of the Month
Expert Login

Awards

About Us
Tell friends
Link to Us
Disclaimer

 
 
 
About Edward Bode
(Top Expert on this page)

Expertise
Catholic dogma, especially as related to Scripture. I have a doctorate in biblical theology [University of St. Thomas, Rome].

Experience
I have taught Catholic thought in grade and high schools, and in college and universities.

Organizations
Catholic Biblical Association

Publications
Catholic Biblical Quarterly, The Bible Today

Education/Credentials
Graduate degrees in theology from the Pontifical Gregorian University, in scripture from the Pontifical Biblical Institute, and a doctorate in theology from the Pontifical University of St. Thomas; all in Rome

   

You are here:  Experts > Religion/Spirituality > Christianity - Catholicism > Catholics

Questions Answered By Expert  Edward Bode 
In Category  Catholics

SubjectDate Asked

What is grace?11/7/2009
  Q: Could you please tell me : (1) What the church defines as "Grace"? (2) What grace mean in day to ...
  A: For a more complete look at justification, grace and merit, please check all the relevant paragraphs ...
What is grace?11/6/2009
  Q: Could you please tell me : (1) What the church defines as "Grace"? (2) What grace mean in day to ...
  A: There are two main types of grace: Sanctifying [habitual] -- The justified people share in the ...
Communion11/4/2009
  Q: With my retirement, I have become very interested in Medieval church history-say 600-1500, currently ...
  A: For many centuries from mediaeval times in the Latin Rite, the practice of the laity receiving Holy ...
Marriage annullment9/14/2009
  Q: Raised in the Episcopal Church, I went through the RCIA program 17 years ago and today I continue to ...
  A: I am not a moral theologian. However, from the facts that you related: as a Catholic, you need to ...
eternal damnation9/12/2009
  Q: Is a person who has never heard about Christ doomed to eternal damnation? If so, what does that say ...
  A: God wills that all people to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the truth. See 1 Tim 2:4. So, ...
Eternal Happiness8/30/2009
  Q: 1. What is Eternal Happiness and How do I obtain it? 2. How reliable is expert opinion from 0 to ...
  A: Christianity teaches that perfect and everlasting happiness after death [heaven]comes from doing the ...
Eternal Happiness8/30/2009
  Q: 1. What is Eternal Happiness and How do I obtain it? 2. How reliable is expert opinion from 0 to ...
  A: 1. I have sent two answers on this question -- Do the will of God and observe his commandments. 2. ...
Eternal Happiness8/30/2009
  Q: 1, What are the rankings of Gods and practically everything else? 2. What are the all the name of ...
  A: Concerning Christianity: God wills that we know, love, and obey Him in this life and share His life ...
Revelations 21:4-58/22/2009
  Q: How can torment in Hell be eternal when in the world to come there "shall be no more pain?" ANSWER: ...
  A: Lamentatiions deals with the destruction of the city of Jerusalem, not with divine punishment after ...
Revelations 21:4-58/21/2009
  Q: How can torment in Hell be eternal when in the world to come there "shall be no more pain?"
  A: The verses to which you refer belong to the wider context of the final judgment [20:11ff]. The new ...
Gaming in Bible8/20/2009
  Q: Many nonprofit organizations including churches use some benign form of gaming (Bingo, raffles, ...
  A: I know of no biblical verse that approaches the issue of gambling for charity. I do not think that ...
reincarnation8/20/2009
  Q: I truly believe in Jesus and the Holy spirit and God and i have been raised Catholic. I am just ...
  A: Reincarnation does not agree with the basic Christian doctrine that each person is responsible ...
The boundaries of faith8/14/2009
  Q: Ever since I was a child I was taught Bible stories and loved them. Even though they made little ...
  A: Again, Augustine: Our hearts were made for Thee O Lord and they are restless til they rest in Thee. ...
The boundaries of faith8/13/2009
  Q: Ever since I was a child I was taught Bible stories and loved them. Even though they made little ...
  A: The latest is not always the best. Collins' book is a very substantial study that deals with the ...
The boundaries of faith8/13/2009
  Q: Ever since I was a child I was taught Bible stories and loved them. Even though they made little ...
  A: I cannot speak for the mind of Ray Brown, now deceased. Nor can I pole the current Catholic clergy ...
Practices of Catholics8/2/2009
  Q: I'd like to hear directly from a Catholic WHY your church focuses more on the worship & praise of ...
  A: Robyn, nice of you to ask a question about the Virgin Mary, Mother of Jesus. In the fifth century, ...
intertestamental writings7/31/2009
  Q: I am trying to locate a couple of verses from the Testament of Issachar, namely: 5:2 and 7:6; and ...
  A: RH Charles, The Apocrapha and Pseudepigrapha of the Old Testament, Vol. 2[Clarendon: Oxford, 1913], ...
Family Tree - Scriptural Basis7/27/2009
  Q: I would like to know if you know if the Family Tree Masses / Generational healing have any basis in ...
  A: I am not familiar with the type of Mass intentions about which you ask. Not knowing the exact ...
Eastern Orthodox Church7/23/2009
  Q: Why did the one Christian Church divide into the Catholic and Orthodox church ANSWER: In the 11th ...
  A: "Filioque" [Latin: and the Son] refers to a phrase in a statement of belief [creed] that within the ...
Eastern Orthodox Church7/22/2009
  Q: Why did the one Christian Church divide into the Catholic and Orthodox church
  A: In the 11th century, the Patriarch of Constantinople was involved in a controversy over authority in ...
Transubstantiation7/17/2009
  Q: I was in a debate recently with my Father over transubstantiation. He recently sent me an email ...
  A: The promise in John 6:36 does refer to the Eucharist -- who eats and drinks will never need another ...
Conscience, Infallibility, and Heresy7/6/2009
  Q: I'd be very grateful if you could either answer my questions or refer me to an intelligent ...
  A: Dr. Hadley, for taking the time to write. Infallibility refers to the dogmas of faith and morals ...
Tubal ligation6/27/2009
  Q: I'm a 25 year old woman, married in the catholic church with two daughters. Last July I had a ...
  A: Christina, I am sorry to learn of your distressing medical issues. I did remember you and your ...
Marriage6/22/2009
  Q: What exactly happens to a Catholic when he marries a Protestant in a Protestant ceremony? Is he ...
  A: If a Catholic marries a Protestant in a Protestant ceremony, in the general law of the Church that ...
Cremation6/13/2009
  Q: My dad a non catholic was cremated and his wishes were for his ashes to be scattered by airplane ...
  A: I think that you are saying that you carried out the scattering of your father's ashes many years ...
dream of latin phrase6/8/2009
  Q: i had a weird dream and need a little help. first off, i am not catholic or really very religious. ...
  A: I do not know how you may have come in contact with the words, which do have a meaning IF they are ...
Original Sin and Dualism6/8/2009
  Q: My question is this: According to Catholic theology/doctrine, is it better to characterize Original ...
  A: Original sin basically involves persons lacking sanctifying grace [that God had given to Adam]. As ...
Are we really in gods image?6/7/2009
  Q: People around the world differ due to the environment they were placed in be it asian, black, tall, ...
  A: My original answer: The reference to mankind in the image and likeness of God in Genesis 1:26 ...
dream of latin phrase6/5/2009
  Q: i had a weird dream and need a little help. first off, i am not catholic or really very religious. ...
  A: adeo -- I go redeo -- I return donatus -- a past participle [masculine singular]: given, bestowed, ...
angels6/4/2009
  Q: I have read that we have a guardian angel. Why are they titled "guardian" It can't be for physical ...
  A: Guardian refers to care and intercession. I think that the primary focus is spiritual -- guardians ...
new americn vs douay rheims5/29/2009
  Q: Why do we use the new american verison when it more resembles the king james ver., instead of the ...
  A: I do not think that the NAB is more like the KJ than the DR. Pope Pius XII asked that current ...
1 Cor 7:14 Interpretation.5/24/2009
  Q: I am a Orthodox, and I am in debate with a Catholic on 1 Cor 7:14. According to this Catholic, 1 Cor ...
  A: There are three main historic opinions about the interpretation of sancitification in the verse: [1] ...
remarriage5/21/2009
  Q: I am a divorced Catholic. I remarried a divorced Lutheran. I have experienced much conflict and ...
  A: I pray that you may have the grace to find a solution to your situtation that would reunite you with ...
Concern5/18/2009
  Q: I am an interpreter with the USA army overseas. I may stay here from one to five years. I am ...
  A: When I said that I did not understand what the question was, I thought that I would have the ...
Aramaic5/2/2009
  Q: I was wondering if you were aware of any online word translators that will translate back and forth ...
  A: There are translations of the Aramaic torah and prophets. There are dictionaries also. You can do ...
After death4/20/2009
  Q: When we die why do we reunite with our body and soul? Why not no just as in the spirit. ANSWER: ...
  A: Since God is a spirit, the reference to humanity as an image after a likeness [Genesis 1:26] does ...
After death4/20/2009
  Q: When we die why do we reunite with our body and soul? Why not no just as in the spirit.
  A: Death separates the soul from the body. The immortal soul continues to live. Reunion with the body ...
Question4/16/2009
  Q: I have a question, to be clear, not from a legal perspective but strictly your opinion and thoughts ...
  A: I do not have any scientific research information. However, in Genesis, when Adam wanted a ...
Question4/15/2009
  Q: I have a question, to be clear, not from a legal perspective but strictly your opinion and thoughts ...
  A: Scripture from the beginning [Genesis] to the later books of the New Testament [especially Pauline ...
Marriage in Peru3/31/2009
  Q: My first marriage was a civil wedding. I am marrying my Peruvian fiance in Peru in a traditional ...
  A: You need to communicate officially with detailed information about your previous marriage and ...
Holy Water3/21/2009
  Q: Can you tell me who started the practice of Holy Water? when? Why? thanks
  A: Here is the article on Holy Water Fonts that appeared in the old Catholic Encylopedia: Vessels ...
Unity of the Church, capital C.3/13/2009
  Q: Are Protestants and Orthodox Christians excluded from Christ's Universal Church on Earth? Or do you ...
  A: The Second Vatican Council spoke to membership in the Church [founded by Jesus Christ]. The council ...
infant baptism3/9/2009
  Q: My 2 1/2 year old son is being baptized against my will. I'm an atheist and my wife was raised ...
  A: I am a theologian. So, allow me to explain the theoligical importance of Baptism. For ...
the books of the bible3/6/2009
  Q: Can you explain why each gospel writer has such a different view of jesus and tell different ...
  A: Scholars have studied the "discordant concordance" of the gospels for many centuries. The root ...
Lent2/28/2009
  Q: My husband and I heard that if you are over 59 years of age you can still eat meat on Fridays during ...
  A: I am not a moral theologian. However, the general rule on abstinence is that it applies to all ...
psalm 91 soldiers death2/24/2009
  Q: I saw that a soldier died on 8/05 and was praying psalm 91 on daily. I truely believe in the ...
  A: This psalm of trust with ocnluding verses of salvation is a favorite. I do not and cannot enter the ...
(Col 1-24)2/21/2009
  Q: I don't understand how there is lacking in Christ's suffering. Wasn't his sacrifice perfect? ...
  A: I appreciate your developing an analogy to illustrate the doctrine of the Eucharist and the Mass. ...
(Col 1-24)2/20/2009
  Q: I don't understand how there is lacking in Christ's suffering. Wasn't his sacrifice perfect?
  A: Christ's sacrifice was perfect. However, it has to be applied to us and received by us. We do that ...
One Baptism1/9/2009
  Q: What exactly does it mean in the Nicene Creed when we say we believe in "one baptism for the ...
  A: The Creed dates from the fourth century -- before the Ortodox separated from the Church headed by ...
Conversion of Jews10/3/2008
  Q: Here is my question again. Just to clarify - I know of course that as per Vatican II it is possible ...
  A: Charles, for writing again. I have had time to do some research. I was unable to find the original ...
Conversion of Jews9/24/2008
  Q: In the TV program 'Children of Abraham'... http://tinyurl.com/4fz4ze ...broadcast in the UK a few ...
  A: I recall seeing something about conversion of Jews recently. However, I cannot find that material ...
Satan8/29/2008
  Q: 1And I saw an angel come down from heaven, having the key of the bottomless pit and a great chain in ...
  A: This passage from Revelation is a true literary and figurative presentation of the final victory of ...
Wondering8/16/2008
  Q: I have been a catholic for the first 12 years of my life I went to ccd. I got my confirmation and ...
  A: While there is life, there is hope. The Sacrament of Reconciliation [Penance; Confession] is always ...
transsubstantion8/14/2008
  Q: Any explanatory comments about transsubstantiation would be appreciated. WIKI Encyclopedia contains ...
  A: Sounds OK to me. The Council of Trent [16th century] explained transsubstantiation in these words: ...
Aux voir!7/30/2008
  Q: Mr. Bode...Nice talking at ya! PS. We need to learn more about the Second Council of ...
  A: Jiminy, I am not a historian of the councils. Constantinople II has been accepted as an ecumenical ...
Reincarnation/Buddhist Theology7/29/2008
  Q: Back a ways Edward Bode (I think) was talking to someone ("Luke"?) and said there is no reference in ...
  A: Please excuse me for misspelling, Jiminy. I am at a loss as to how to respond to your concerns. I ...
Reincarnation/Buddhist Theology7/26/2008
  Q: Back a ways Edward Bode (I think) was talking to someone ("Luke"?) and said there is no reference in ...
  A: In Jn 9;1, I see no reference to reincarnation but rather a belief that the sins of parents could ...
Reincarnation/Buddhist Theology7/24/2008
  Q: Back a ways Edward Bode (I think) was talking to someone ("Luke"?) and said there is no reference in ...
  A: In Jn 9;1, I see no reference to reincarnation but rather a belief that the sins of parents could ...
Heaven7/18/2008
  Q: Can non Catholics especially non Christians enter heaven?
  A: Who enters heaven, supernatural and eternal perfect happiness? First, we leave to the just and ...
what do you think?7/14/2008
  Q: Jesus says he came to fulfill the law, but he says to turn the other cheek instead of doing it eye ...
  A: In Mt 5, Jesus summarizes His relationship to the [old]Law with a series of before and now. Some of ...
baptism by fire7/3/2008
  Q: when I married my husband he was Catholic and I was not. I was given literature to learn about the ...
  A: Your thought is very interesting but one that I have never heard. If the reason for the fire is for ...
baptism by fire7/2/2008
  Q: when I married my husband he was Catholic and I was not. I was given literature to learn about the ...
  A: No Catholic teaching says that a person who dies in a fire goes to heaven in virtue of a baptism by ...
Is it true?6/29/2008
  Q: Is it true that Lucifer once controlled Earth and that God had given it to him to preside over?
  A: No. Satan [Lucifer]tries through lies and seduction and deceit to lead humans away from the path of ...
unclean spirit5/31/2008
  Q: I came across such a passage today: When the unclean spirit has gone out of a person, it wanders ...
  A: I did not mean that Mt or Lk made a mistake or taught an error -- the one God who inspired all ...
unclean spirit5/31/2008
  Q: I came across such a passage today: When the unclean spirit has gone out of a person, it wanders ...
  A: I am not sure that the Mt/Lk passage clearly indicates that the man did in fact replace the "junk" ...
unclean spirit5/30/2008
  Q: I came across such a passage today: When the unclean spirit has gone out of a person, it wanders ...
  A: Nice that you took the time to delve into your concern. The short answer: When you clean out the ...
Emmanuel5/25/2008
  Q: When it was announced to Mary that she was to be the MOther of Jesus, I recall that the angel said ...
  A: Emmanuel [God with us, which Matthew uses in a quotation from Isaiah] expresses the idea of what ...
Sabbath3/24/2008
  Q: When in history did the Catholic Church change the Sabbath from the seventh day of the week, as ...
  A: The book of Acts reflects the practice of the first followers of Jesus gathering on the first day of ...
THE SOUL , AFTER DEATH2/8/2008
  Q: LET ME BE DIRECT........... WHEN YOU DIE , WHAT ARE YOUR EXPECTATIONS AS TO YOUR SOUL......? ARE WE ...
  A: The official teaching of the Catholic Church is: Each person "receives his eternal retribution in ...
Scripture1/24/2008
  Q: Is the Old Testament based on myth? I attended a class on Evolution and the Bible and the priest ...
  A: From what you have said, Sue, I think that several observations are in order: 1 - The OT and the NT ...
validity of messiah1/23/2008
  Q: the old testament specifies that the messiah would be a direct blood descendent of david on his ...
  A: If you would give me the biblical reference to the Exodus passage to which you refer, I would be ...
validity of messiah1/22/2008
  Q: the old testament specifies that the messiah would be a direct blood descendent of david on his ...
  A: I do not know the detailed criteria of what you report about lineage in Judaism. Is this ...
validity of messiah1/22/2008
  Q: the old testament specifies that the messiah would be a direct blood descendent of david on his ...
  A: Matthew calls Jesus "son of David" and "Son of God." Matthew had to have thought that the two ...
reincarnation12/7/2007
  Q: What is your own point of view on reincarnation, and what does the Church say about it? Thank You ...
  A: The [official]Catechism, published by the Vatican in 1997 is a compendium of Catholic teaching based ...
reincarnation12/6/2007
  Q: What is your own point of view on reincarnation, and what does the Church say about it? Thank You ...
  A: I do not know how to persuade a non-Christian concerning the truths of Christian revelation. ...
reincarnation12/6/2007
  Q: What is your own point of view on reincarnation, and what does the Church say about it? Thank You
  A: My position is the same as that of the Church: reincarnation is the antithesis of Chritianity. The ...
SDA?11/10/2007
  Q: Any way I`m part of Seventh Day Adventist and I can't stop wondering why you guys do some of the ...
  A: Magdiel, for trusting that I would provide a polite answer. Jesus respected the teachings of the Old ...
EXISTENCE OF ADAM10/20/2007
  Q: do you believe that Adam is a symbolic character or a factual character ?Many christian churches ...
  A: Science has not proven a contradiction to the existence of a first man and a first woman. Possibly, ...
EXISTENCE OF ADAM10/16/2007
  Q: do you believe that Adam is a symbolic character or a factual character ?Many christian churches ...
  A: The real existence of the/a first man [Adam] is based on the revelation of God in scripture. See ...
Eastern Orthodox relation10/13/2007
  Q: Can you please explain the relationship of the Catholic Church to the Eastern Orthodox Church? It ...
  A: I complement you for seeking to match candidates with Catholic teaching. May I suggest that ...
Eastern Orthodox relation10/6/2007
  Q: Can you please explain the relationship of the Catholic Church to the Eastern Orthodox Church? It ...
  A: In the 11th century, many of the Catholics in eastern Europe and the Near East separated themselves ...
Purgatory/Reincarnation???9/27/2007
  Q: Is it possible that purgatory and reincarnation are one in the same? I do believe that the human ...
  A: Reincarnation contradicts the basic Christian belief that this one life that we experience is the ...
Marriage9/17/2007
  Q: I am looking for some advice from someone who is a good Catholic and follows all the Church ...
  A: Lisa, I commend you for seeing your Catholicism as an important factor for a happy and blessed ...
Marriage9/6/2007
  Q: I'm very thankful for the opportunity to ask you a question which is of a very high importance to ...
  A: Marina, for taking the time to write. Although I cannot provide a complete answer to your quandry, ...
Purgatory8/22/2007
  Q: Do Catholics belive that everybody will pass through Purgatory when they die? Or is it only baptised ...
  A: Catholic teaching does not say that all persons will pass through purgatory before attaining the ...
LORD/Tetragammon8/5/2007
  Q: Can you clarify LORD, Lord, Yahweh, Elohim? As I understand it, the original text has YHWH. This ...
  A: In Hebrew: the word elohim is a general word for God or any god. YHWH are the four letters that ...
a7/24/2007
  Q: Yesterday, I went to a youth oriented church service. It was a service for college aged people and ...
  A: Chris, I have been thinking about your question but am not sure how to answer. Rather than saying I ...
Annulments7/3/2007
  Q: My brother was asking me recently if someone is married in a non-Catholic Church and then divorces ...
  A: Catholics, they alone, are required to enter marriage in accord with the rules of the Catholic ...
how can catholicism be right7/1/2007
  Q: I have recently been saved (a born again Christian) since the 30th January when i accepted Christ as ...
  A: I apologize for giving you an outdated website. I just checked to get the current site: ...
how can catholicism be right6/19/2007
  Q: I have recently been saved (a born again Christian) since the 30th January when i accepted Christ as ...
  A: Nice of you, John, to seek explanations of Catholic beliefs and practices. Purgatory: Two passages ...
Question about religion6/17/2007
  Q: What is armageddon and the day of reckoning? Are they mentioned anywhere in the bible besides ...
  A: The meaning of the Rev passage seems clear: in the struggle between light/good and darkness/evil, ...
Mary the mother of Jesus5/19/2007
  Q: When did Mary begin to take hold of he church Why does she appear to have such a high profile and ...
  A: I am not sure that counting icons would determine the role of Peter and Mary in the Church. The ...
Disposal of amputated body parts5/19/2007
  Q: If a person has an amputation, what is the Catholic Churches teaching on how it should be disposed?
  A: I do not know the answer to your question and have not been able to track down a resource. My best ...
Mary the mother of Jesus5/18/2007
  Q: When did Mary begin to take hold of he church Why does she appear to have such a high profile and ...
  A: I do not think that Mary has "taken hold" of the Catholic church. She has received great veneration ...
Homosexuality4/22/2007
  Q: I notice in many Catholic documents about homosexuality that the term "homosexual inclination" and ...
  A: I really do not know what these other-than-Catholic groups might mean by "orientation." I do not ...
buddhism/christianity4/22/2007
  Q: Edward! I don't know if you can answer this question but maybe you can. I've been reading about Zen ...
  A: I am not a student of Buddhism. The Catholic faith since the time of the apostles has emphasized ...
buddhism/christianity4/21/2007
  Q: Edward! I don't know if you can answer this question but maybe you can. I've been reading about Zen ...
  A: The Council of Vatican II in its decree on non-Christian religions, commented that the Church does ...
talkin with Lord4/9/2007
  Q: Hy Edward! Im Christian and i strongly beleve in God and Jesus Christ.. I was surfing on the ...
  A: All humans are descendants of Adam and Eve [a first set of parents]. Paul talks about this in ...
Bishops3/30/2007
  Q: I have been reading my bible lately and am questioned by what I read. It is in the new testament ...
  A: Nothing in the New Testament requires that clergy be celibate. In the Catholic Church, celibacy of ...
symbols3/28/2007
  Q: "I am looking at a few items for body art and wanted to question the relation to the catholic ...
  A: The lion and the lamb usually appear with a small child as a symbol of peace and comes from the Old ...
quotations3/23/2007
  Q: Edward! Jesus said:"Where there is a dead body, there the vultures will gather." (Luke 37)and ...
  A: Lk 17:37 [see also Mt24:27] shows Jesus' impatience by a saying that means either: [1] the birds of ...
Judging3/23/2007
  Q: It is a common response to any disapproval of immoral behavior in society for someone to say, "Judge ...
  A: Often it is difficult to counter one bible quote [sometimes taken out of context]with another. ...
faith3/19/2007
  Q: Is faith a supernatural free gift, bestowed on only those people whom God has chosen? Or is it ...
  A: Faith is a supernatural,free gift from God. God makes that gift available to everyone. Jesus ...
hierarchy2/8/2007
  Q: I've got another question to you. I have a feeling that many feminists don't like the Roman Catholic ...
  A: Like you, Luke, I do not understand the regimentation for kissing the crucifix on Good Friday. ...
free will2/7/2007
  Q: Is it true that our free will allows us to do only bad things, to do evil, and if there is something ...
  A: Lucas, you have touched the multi-million dollar question -- the explanation of God's actions in ...
Funerals2/2/2007
  Q: A local pro-abortion politician recently died and, to my surprise, received a Catholic funeral Mass ...
  A: The Code of Canon Law for the universal Catholic Church has a rule that speaks to the denial of ...
divorce1/9/2007
  Q: I was raised by a Catholic mother and non-Catholic Father but attend Catholic church with my Mother. ...
  A: I commend you for wanting to receive Baptism and also for your children. I am not a moral theologian ...
annulment12/20/2006
  Q: I am sorry for bothering you again, but how long does this process usually take? So my marriage was ...
  A: The time required [few weeks, months] varies with the time needed for the priest to gather the ...
annulment12/20/2006
  Q: Okay I am sorry for not being clear....I live on long island,NY in the US. I was baptized, my ex ...
  A: I thought of one further issue: Joining officially anothter religion. So:If you were reared as a ...
annulment12/20/2006
  Q: I will be following up with my church, in the mean time I have been trying to gather some ...
  A: The exact requirements of an annulment depend on factors which I do not know in your case. From ...
annulment12/19/2006
  Q: My ex husband and I were married by the justice of the piece...I am Catholic, he is not. I am ...
  A: From what you have said, Jenn, it may be possible for you to obtain an annulment. However, many ...
love of Christ12/12/2006
  Q: Can you explain the concept of love that Christ spoke about? Love of God, love your enemies, love ...
  A: I'll try, Marc, to provide some thoughts. You are correct that one cannot love what one does not ...
The Priesthood12/6/2006
  Q: Bode: How can I explain the Catholic Priesthood from the Bible. A Protestant argued that the ...
  A: Lee, explaining the priesthood from the bible may be a challenging task. However, I recommend these ...
-12/1/2006
  Q: One of the chapters/books in the Bible is entitled "Ecclesiasticus, or the wisdom of Jesus son of ...
  A: The Hebrew original of the book identifies the author as Jesus Ben [son of] Sirach. This not a ...
Mark 1311/23/2006
  Q: Last sundays gospel. Jesus tells the disciples that the end of the world will be within this ...
  A: General comment: God, Who "can neither deceive nor be deceived", has revealed His message for the ...
Divorce11/7/2006
  Q: How does the Church justify forbidding divorce in all circumstances, when Christ clearly allowed for ...
  A: The teaching of the Church rests upon both scripture and tradition. In the NT, Mt 5:32 makes an ...
cremation11/7/2006
  Q: as a roman catholic,can I be cremated?
  A: The current rule of the Church [Canon 1176]states, "The Church earnestly recommends that the pious ...
transubstitution11/4/2006
  Q: I, of course, understand that pantheism is not part of Catholic Dogma or teaching, however, you ...
  A: I thought that I had given the manin scriptural basis for belief in the real and substantial ...
transubstitution11/2/2006
  Q: I am a protestant and would like to ask the question about this teaching. The pantheist believes a ...
  A: First, pantheism had/has no place in Jewish [and Christian] theology. One cannot find any trace of ...
Mortal Sin10/22/2006
  Q: I just wanted to write back because your views re: mortal sin and my question, are really what I ...
  A: Glad to be of some help. The obligation to attend Mass on certain days is a grave obligation ...
Revelation10/19/2006
  Q: Do you believe that God speaks directly to us today, or did His revelation cease with the New ...
  A: Go spoke directly to all mankind in the Jesus era [Jesus was and is the Word of God -- see John 1]. ...
Looking for the text of Last Rites?10/11/2006
  Q: I'm looking for the text of the Last Rites ceremony, particularly in the case of Extreme ...
  A: The Vatican published a new edition of the Rituale Romanum [Latin] a few years ago. I do not know ...
religion9/21/2006
  Q: Saladin, how does god beget a son which is "supposedly" god. Tell this day i have never understood ...
  A: To understand how God the Father can "beget" [a human term which attempts to understand God] God the ...
divorce9/15/2006
  Q: In the situation where a person divorces his wife (or vice versa) without an annulment, remarries ...
  A: Johann, the dilemma that you propose has a solution. In such circumstances [the specifics of which ...
divorce9/15/2006
  Q: What is the Church's position on divorce/annulment? I guess I'm really wondering about so-called ...
  A: Based on Jesus' teaching [see Mk 10:11-12], the Catholic Church holds that marriage which is ...
satan8/16/2006
  Q: So what is the Traditional Catholic belief about the power of Satan (and his demons) in this world? ...
  A: Reports surface still about persons' being possessed by the devil or demons. There was a case in ...
Gay Rights and the Catholic Church8/9/2006
  Q: I am 17 and have been raised Roman Catholic from birth. My problem with the Catholic church lies in ...
  A: Denise, I appreciate your concern and quandry. I, of course, do not know what anti-homosexual ...
The majority8/9/2006
  Q: Bode: What should I answer to Seventh-day Adventists when they say that the majority of Christians ...
  A: Steve, I would not recommend arguing about Sunday worship on the basis that the majority is wrong. ...
church7/10/2006
  Q: 1 Timothy 3:15 "But if I tarry long, that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thyself in ...
  A: According to the Greek text, "pillar and ground" are in apposition to "church". One could make a ...
Ten Commandments7/6/2006
  Q: Bode: We Catholics support the Ten Commandments, we teach them in CCD classes, we hear them in ...
  A: I am not sure that you can satisfactorily explain the Christian change of the Jewish Sabbath to ...
Relationship6/30/2006
  Q: Well, what I was wondering about was what that new relationship means in concrete terms. It's fine ...
  A: In concrete terms, we have special access to God because of sanctifying grace and the sacraments and ...
Relationship6/30/2006
  Q: I've been hearing a lot lately from fundamentalists about having a "relationship" with Jesus. My ...
  A: Winston, you have a nice analysis of our relationship with Jesus/God with its basis in sanctifying ...
born again6/29/2006
  Q: How would you answer a fundamentalist type who asks if you've been "born-again" or "being saved" or ...
  A: I like your answer. At Baptism, God comes, as you said. I would add: Before First Confession and ...
Apologetics6/28/2006
  Q: What do you think is the best argument one could give to a fundamentalist/evangelical Protestant to ...
  A: I have an opinion as to the best apologetic. However, whether it would convince is another question ...
prayer6/26/2006
  Q: What is the official Catholic view of prayer? I mean, I know that we are encouraged to pray that God ...
  A: Prayer is raising one'mind and heart to God or the requesting of good things from God; so said St. ...
Catholics...6/18/2006
  Q: for respnding, a lot of it still doesn't make sense to me, like how you were saying that you have to ...
  A: What I am saying about understanding the bible, Rachel, is that one cannot just look at one ...
Catholics...6/16/2006
  Q: I have many questions I would like to have answered if possible. 1. If someone doesn't pray ...
  A: According to Catholic practice, no one is obliged to pray the rosay. The rosary is a popular ...
Praying to the statue of Mary..6/15/2006
  Q: I have a whole lot of questions but i will settle for one that pertains to the catholic church and ...
  A: I cannot tell you what an individual Catholic thinks when kneeling to pray before a statue of Mary ...
Catholics...6/14/2006
  Q: I have many questions I would like to have answered if possible. 1. If someone doesn't pray ...
  A: Adequate answers to your questions really require a lenghty conference with a knowledgeable priest ...
Bible6/7/2006
  Q: Which Bible do you recommend? I just don't mean the translation- I also mean which Bible would have ...
  A: I know of two editions with which I am familiar. The Catholic Study Bible [Oxford, 1990] contains ...
Morning After Day Pill5/28/2006
  Q: Im a doctor and catholic too, i like to know what the church think about the Morning After Day ...
  A: I appreicate your interest, Dr. Nacho, in doing what is morally correct. Please excuse my short ...
God5/2/2006
  Q: Why does God allow suffering?
  A: Patrick, I have two answers that complement each other. One -- God through suffering allows us to ...
So when saved people die,...2/27/2006
  Q: So when saved people die, will they have to wait until the end of the world to be resurrected and ...
  A: I thought that I had answered this question previously. If you did not receive that answer, please ...
infant baptism2/19/2006
  Q: How can I respond to a friend that is baptist when she says that baptizing an infant is merely ...
  A: For about 1400 years before the Baptists proclaimed their new theory about Baptism, the Christian ...
Hello Edward! Some time...2/18/2006
  Q: Some time ago a friend of mine, who does not attend a church, claimed that the church tries to ...
  A: Rubbish it is! Re virginity: The Jewish law and customs did not favor virginity but frowned upon it. ...
What is the traditional Catholic...1/29/2006
  Q: What is the traditional Catholic belief about demonic influence? I know that we believe in demonic ...
  A: There are two classic places where Catholic teaching speaks in general about the evil influence of ...
Hi Edward! I'd like to...1/28/2006
  Q: I'd like to ask you if it's a sin when you're not able to concentrate during prayers or when you ...
  A: I am not a moral theologian, Luke, but I do have a few thoughts that I could offer about attention ...
Hello Edward! I know that...1/15/2006
  Q: I know that the law of the Church states that people shouldn't use contraceptives and that women who ...
  A: I am not a moral theologian. However, while animals are not human, we do owe them respect [not ...
Scripture- Social justice1/2/2006
  Q: I am a 60 year old Catholic in a new bible study class on Social Justice. My question is in reading ...
  A: Nice to know, Rich, that you are delving into the meaning of sacred scripture. I am not sure how ...
Crusades12/31/2005
  Q: Did not the Pope say that whoever dies on a crusade immediately goes to heaven? If that is the ...
  A: I am not a church historian. However, Samuel, let me comment on what I know about doctrine of the ...
i just had a quick question....12/19/2005
  Q: i just had a quick question. What does it mean when someone, during mass, goes up to receive ...
  A: Usaully, the action indicates that the person has approached for a blessing but is not eligible to ...
Our father - heaven11/14/2005
  Q: In the "Our Father" certainly in Latin, French and Dutch as known to me, the translation of Christ's ...
  A: I wrote to a friend who is an internationally-known scholar on the NT. Here is his response: The ...
moral theology11/13/2005
  Q: what is moral theology?
  A: Moral theology is the study of God's revelation and of human reasoning to determine both in theory ...
Preterist doctrine11/1/2005
  Q: How are you today. I was trying to figure out where and when did the Preterist doctrine come about ...
  A: Since I was not aware of Preterist teaching, I did a web search and found numerous sites. The names ...
Hello Mr Edward! "Let us...10/29/2005
  Q: "Let us make man in our image, after our likeness; and let them have dominion over the fish of the ...
  A: You have stated the basic Catholic principles that mankind has the right to use animals for its ...
Gal. 4:910/20/2005
  Q: Bode: Perhaps you can help me with a statement made by St. Paul. "Now that you have come to know ...
  A: I can understand your consternation, Tommy. The key lies in understanding the nuances of the words. ...
Divine Mercy and Pope9/6/2005
  Q: I read and spread the messages Saint Fastina recorded in her diary that Jesus told her. Is it wrong ...
  A: Michael, I am not conversant with St. Faustina. So, I cannot help with specifics. Generally ...
Prayer8/21/2005
  Q: A young Christian man was just killed, and his father is wondering why his prayers for his son's ...
  A: When we examine scripture, we need to examine all the verses that concern the subject. So, in regard ...
Salvation8/15/2005
  Q: Will all non-Catholics/non-Christians be lost/go to Hell after death?
  A: The short answer is: not necessarily. God wants all to be saved and to come to a knowledge of the ...
Psalm 918/11/2005
  Q: A most loving Christian boy was just killed in Iraq one day after his 19th birthday. He read the ...
  A: To understand the mystery of evil requires the infinite mind of God, who in his wisdom and love ...
Doubts8/4/2005
  Q: Can I be a Christian if I have doubts as to God's existence? I'm not totally sure... Thanks
  A: The customary statement of belief [creed]for a Christian begins: "I believe in one God, the maker of ...
catholic beleifs7/27/2005
  Q: maetriya...ect. I got this information from Nasrinsafai.com. Can you please give me an opinion? Also ...
  A: I took a quick look at the website. I do not see Catholic teaching there. Fransiscans are a ...
question7/26/2005
  Q: what do we beleive of how we were first created? Do we beleive in any science theories? Do we be ...
  A: Re creation of human beings: We believe that God created an immortal, rational soul and infused it ...
question7/23/2005
  Q: //theend.org/book? And also if you dont forgive a mortal sin iss it true you cant go to heaven?
  A: I do not know about Dr. George but the site and the notion are not in the mainstream of Catholic ...
question7/23/2005
  Q: so we dont know how to interpret these things, or how they will happen? will there be poeple alive ...
  A: In the creed, we say "[Jesus] will come to judge the living and the dead." In my opinion, the end ...
catholic beleifs7/21/2005
  Q: Also I heard of something, i dont remeber exactly what it was but I think it is call abomination of ...
  A: To answer your second question first, Eric, the abominable or shameful desolation mentioned in the ...
question6/27/2005
  Q: What do we believe about the second coming. Do we believe in a doomsday when eueryone is suposed to ...
  A: We do believe, Ryan, in the second coming [general judgment] when Jesus comes again at the end of ...
Family planning6/25/2005
  Q: In my travels in NFP circles these days something brought to the forefront is that due to advances ...
  A: Beth, I am not a moral theologian. I am not sure how one balances giving the right to one's body ...
catholic6/22/2005
  Q: Such findings are not surprising in an age of revolutionary advances in technology, researchers say. ...
  A: I cannot speak for Jewish and Muslim teachings, but the Catholic Church does expect the second ...
catholic6/22/2005
  Q: Do we take revelation literallY?
  A: If you are referring to the Book of Revelation, it does contain a literal message presented under ...
Tithing5/23/2005
  Q: Are Roman Catholics required to tithe, i.e. giving back 10% of income to the Church? What is the ...
  A: In the United States, the Catholic bishops have recommended that members tithe. Often, this is ...
Jesus5/22/2005
  Q: Did Jesus have brothers and sisters? And if so, their names please. Answer - If you mean did Joseph ...
  A: Mk 3:31 gives no names, just "brothers" Mk 6:3 lists James, Joses, Judas, Simon and sisters. Jn 7:3 ...
Jesus5/22/2005
  Q: Did Jesus have brothers and sisters? And if so, their names please.
  A: If you mean did Joseph and Mary have children, the answer is no. If you mean were there persons who ...
Bible5/18/2005
  Q: Is there anywhere in the Bible that Jesus says that he accepts the faith of others for salvation? I ...
  A: Re Baptism: No passage says that Jesus accepts the faith of one person for that of another. ...
Re: Sin of Omission5/14/2005
  Q: Would it be considered a sin of omission for Bishops who have been instructed to counsel an ...
  A: I am not a moral theologian, Paul, so I am not qualified to answer your questions. However, the ...
Tongues5/13/2005
  Q: What is the Church's position on speaking in tongues?
  A: I am not aware of an official position of the Catholic Church about the gift of speaking in tongues, ...
Gospel of John - New American Bible4/28/2005
  Q: Do you know how many times the word light is used in the Gospel of John in the New American Bible? ...
  A: I am sorry, Sister, that I do not have or know where one could find the exact info that you seek. ...
catholic4/26/2005
  Q: so we dont know how to interpret these things, or how they will happen, the bowls, 3 days of ...
  A: j, I am not sure about all the bible references which you mention. However, the Book of Revelation ...
Popes4/24/2005
  Q: With the recent election of the Pope, my non-Catholic friends have been bringing up papal history ...
  A: Some popes of the dark ages and the renaissance era did not live exemplary moral lives before they ...
bible4/22/2005
  Q: In Ephesians 4:11 and I Cor 12:28, why does Paul talk about the importance of apostles and prophets ...
  A: Paul is talking about the church established by Jesus, messiah and Lord. Paul uses the word apostle ...
-4/11/2005
  Q: Jesus said "No one who puts his hand to the plow and looks back is fit for the kingdom of God" ...
  A: Your question, Luke, about the saying in Luke 9:62, should be viewed in its context. One usually ...
Judaism4/10/2005
  Q: Jesus said that He is the way, the truth and the light and that no one comes to the Father except ...
  A: I am sorry, Andrew, that I cannot be of much help on your question. I must have missed the matters ...
Re: Homosexuality4/6/2005
  Q: I have a few questions concerning what the Catholic Church Magesterium teaches about homosexual ...
  A: Your questions are really beyond my expertize as I am not a moral theologian. Re 1 & 2 & 3: I am not ...
'official' chatolic standpoint on godliness of the Bible.4/1/2005
  Q: I am not religious: my interest in religions is that of an observer. The Coran states clearly that ...
  A: Catholic belief is that the books of the bible are written by human authors under the inspiration of ...
definition of meat3/25/2005
  Q: My girlfriend who isn't Catholic has asked me WHY fish isn't considered meat, and after looking for ...
  A: Ryan, I am not a moral theologian. However, I do know a few things about the church law on ...
catholic3/24/2005
  Q: do catholics belive that we are living the end times? do we catholics not know how the end timies ...
  A: The gospels [for example, Mk 13:32] and St. Paul [especially 2 Thes] make very clear that we do not ...
catholic question3/24/2005
  Q: i was looking up something father and i found some sites of people wo say they have visions of the ...
  A: The two sites were not attached. Some persons have experienced visions or revelations from God about ...
what catholics beleive3/24/2005
  Q: do catholics belive that we are living the end times? do we catholics not know how the end timies ...
  A: The gospels [for example, Mk 13:32] and St. Paul [especially 2 Thes] make very clear that we do not ...
question about a definition3/11/2005
  Q: I've been trying to understand the passage that goes (sorry, I don't have the scripture to reference ...
  A: I have searched for the reference but have not been able to find it. Without the specific ...
Confession.3/6/2005
  Q: I asked another expert about I John 1:9 about who to confess to and he said Jesus Christ. If we ...
  A: As your questions suppose, Mary, sin is an offense against God; so, God is the one to determine the ...
Hello. If a catholic commits...2/20/2005
  Q: If a catholic commits suicide for whatever reasons, mental illness, depression, etc. ,can he/she ...
  A: The Church currently allows a Catholic funeral Mass for persons who committed suicide. The Catholic ...
Infallibility2/9/2005
  Q: Here is a quote from the Catholic Encyclopedia EXPLANATION OF PAPAL INFALLIBILITY The Vatican ...
  A: I am not sure that the Pope is mistaken in not making a formal definition about women's ordination. ...
Infallibility2/9/2005
  Q: Here is a quote from the Catholic Encyclopedia EXPLANATION OF PAPAL INFALLIBILITY The Vatican ...
  A: Nice to hear from you, Charles, with your concern for the permanence of Catholic teaching. I do not ...
Hello. I had a question dealing...2/8/2005
  Q: I had a question dealing about the Rapture and Tribulation. Can you tell me about it and what the ...
  A: Chris, the rapture is not a Catholic idea but one that comes from a group of evangelicals beginning ...
marriage2/8/2005
  Q: Why does Paul say several times in Corinthians that it is not always good to look for a wife and get ...
  A: To understand all that Paul teaches about matrimony requires a study of all his letters. For ...
Babies' souls1/21/2005
  Q: What happens to the souls of babies who are miscarried, stillborn, aborted or who die without being ...
  A: Jo, as you indicated, the immortal soul [infused at conception]of a human being continues to live ...
Assumption sources and tradition12/26/2004
  Q: I am looking for a book (ancient history) about the Assumption of Mary. Can you help me?
  A: I did a quick check withoug success. You might look at newadvent.org -- old version of the Catholic ...
some ways do the Catholic...12/6/2004
  Q: some ways do the Catholic social teachings of Vatican II contradict the values of our current ...
  A: This sounds like a homework question, which I do not do. I am not an expert on the detailed ...
Hello. I was curious to know...11/27/2004
  Q: I was curious to know what the Church's teach was regarding to evolution. I have heard the Church ...
  A: The church holds that God directly creates the soul of individual human beings. So, the body of the ...
suicide10/22/2004
  Q: Why does Catholicism forbid suicide? Is it in their teaching? Can you give any references? I the ...
  A: From early times, Christian tradition has condemned suicide as an offense against God, the giver of ...
Mass10/20/2004
  Q: I read somewhere that some churches were built with numerous altars so that several masses could be ...
  A: For centuries, many large churches had more than one altar. The extra altars were used for many ...
archeology and the Bible9/18/2004
  Q: What is the differences in The Bible and archeology? Are they related some how? Are they any ...
  A: You have asked a question about which many, many volumes have been written. Two classic books on the ...
Be Like God9/16/2004
  Q: What happens to human being s who strive to be like God on their own terms?
  A: I am not sure what is the exact intent of your question. However: For a creature [human being]to ...
Eating Meat on Fridays9/11/2004
  Q: In RC teaching, was / is eating meat on Fridays a sin and if so since when in history was this so ...
  A: references to Friday abstinence go back at least to the second century AD. Traditionally, meat has ...
doctrine9/8/2004
  Q: What is the difference between doctrine and dogma?
  A: A dogma is an official teaching of the Catholic Church that has been declared part of the revealed ...
Catholic beliefs8/25/2004
  Q: I was wondering if you could tell me, as i am having an argument with a friend, if the following ...
  A: Emily, here are the correct answers to your discussion: 1- F The Holy Spirit is the Third Person 2 - ...
Eucharist8/24/2004
  Q: I am a former Episcopalian and now belong to the Disciples of Christ Church. Both, of course, are ...
  A: I too have seen the news to which you refer. We have talked about the case here. I have two ...
gays6/23/2004
  Q: why do the catholic's hate gays? because the way i see it, god has given the gays the same suffering ...
  A: If Catholics "hate" homosexuals, they are not following the teachings of Jesus or the Catholic ...
interpretation6/16/2004
  Q: i know that the catholic church is the interpreter of the holy bible. does that mean that there is ...
  A: The Church has not officially defined the meaning of every, or most verses, of sacred scripture. In ...
cremation6/15/2004
  Q: Is it more biblical for a Christian's body to be buried or cremated after death? Will the choice, in ...
  A: Christian respect for the body as the temple of the Holy Spirit and the expected resurrection of the ...
Thanks for taking the time...6/6/2004
  Q: I was raised protestant, and my husband is Catholic, as are my children. Lately I have felt very ...
  A: Jesus' words which you quoted convey the essential message that He is the one and the only mediator ...
unforgivable sin6/5/2004
  Q: What exactly is the "unforgivable sin" mentioned in Mark, Luke and Matthew?
  A: Blasphemy against the Spirit will not be forgiven -- Although there are no limits to God's mercy, a ...
Hello, How are you today....4/27/2004
  Q: How are you today. I was wonderering since the Sabbath is on Saturday and God said that the Sabbath ...
  A: Jesus came to fulfill the Law and the Prophets [Mt]. He altered explicitly some things in the ...
Hello, I was wondering what...4/15/2004
  Q: I was wondering what Sacred Tradition is and what examples of it would be. And would this be ...
  A: Tradition is an authentic and valid source of revelation. Tradition is the living transmission of ...
Romans4/14/2004
  Q: Is this a correct interpretation of Romans 7:2? Is it really trying to prove a point about marriage ...
  A: I think that the passage is using monogomous marriage to illustrate Paul's point about fidelity to ...
Hello, i have a question regarding...4/13/2004
  Q: i have a question regarding salvation. Is baptism necessary for salvation? I was discussing this ...
  A: Discussion on the basis of the bible alone can sometimes be difficult. For Catholics, the Council ...
Hello, i was discussing salvation...3/26/2004
  Q: i was discussing salvation with a Protestant friend of mine. He was talking about the theology or ...
  A: Chris! What your friend proposes is the classical Protestant position of the 16th century. The ...
Test questions for high school teachers of moral theology3/13/2004
  Q: - Edward, Thank you for your quick response to my question. Please let my inquiry resonate in your ...
  A: I shall keep your request in mind, Brother. At this time, I do not have contacts at the high school ...
Test questions for high school teachers of moral theology3/13/2004
  Q: Please identify your e-mail with "Edward Bode". I note you have taught religion in high school. As ...
  A: I wish I could help you, Bro. Malcolm. I have not taught in high school for more than 30 years. At ...
why gospel spread word of mouth?2/18/2004
  Q: it seems inconsistent that god's perfect love, as revealed in the bible, is spread by word of mouth. ...
  A: Your question, Troy, has occupied theologians for centuries. Basically, the answer is the mystery of ...
Hello. I had a question about...2/10/2004
  Q: I had a question about indulgences. I read some info. on how they were used/abused in the past. I ...
  A: Cris. Indulgences are still alive and well. They are the remission of the temporal punishment due ...

All Questions in This Category

Email this page
     
User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Kids' Privacy Policy | Help
Copyright  © 2006 About, Inc. AllExperts, AllExperts.com, and About.com are registered trademarks of About, Inc. All rights reserved.