AllExperts > Catholics 
Search      
Catholics
Volunteer
Answers to thousands of questions
 Home · More Catholics Questions · Question Library  · Free Encyclopedia ·
More Catholics Answers
Question Library

Ask a question about Catholics
Volunteer
Experts of the Month
Expert Login

Awards

About Us
Tell friends
Link to Us
Disclaimer

 
 
 
About Charlie Breeding
(Top Expert on this page)

Expertise
I can answer questions like, "Help me reconcile the Catholic Church to Protestant religions" or "Help me understand some of the staunch, unbendable rules that the Vatican asks Catholics to keep" or "How must the Church reconcile other religions or religious beliefs" and more...

Experience
Raised Protestant; converted to Catholicism in 1995 (one of the best things that I've ever done for myself)

Organizations
Board of Directors, North Carolina Right to Life

Education/Credentials
BS in Engineering from West Point
; Professional employed and self-employed; father of four children (b, 18; g, 16; b, 15, g,8) and married to the same woman for 23 years!
   

You are here:  Experts > Religion/Spirituality > Christianity - Catholicism > Catholics

Questions Answered By Expert  Charlie Breeding 
In Category  Catholics

SubjectDate Asked

Christ's body and blood11/11/2009
  Q: I read your answers to some questions.Congratulation!! I'm Maronite, I believe in Christ without ...
  A: Izabelle, Thanks for your question... all the way from Brazil. Off-topic by the way, ...
Church teaching from the Old Testament11/10/2009
  Q: A Jewish anthropologist was trying to understand how the Catholic faith teaches from the New ...
  A: Suz, Thanks for your question. Honestly, I don't see an issue or question from your Jewish ...
Hamlet and Wittenberg11/5/2009
  Q: At the start of Shakespeare's play "Hamlet" we learn that Hamlet had been studying in Wittenberg. ...
  A: Karen, Thanks for your question. Rather than rejecting it, I thought that I'd answer by saying, "I ...
Catholic Church10/8/2009
  Q: I am a Catholic and I believe the Catholic Church was the first and only Church. How did the ...
  A: Jon, Thanks for your question. If you're serious attempting to get at the answer to your question, ...
God's Law10/4/2009
  Q: I’m searching for a certain denomination and was hoping that by contacting you, you could help me in ...
  A: Craig, Thanks for your follow up reply. I'll study and review the referenced website. And thanks ...
God's Law10/2/2009
  Q: I’m searching for a certain denomination and was hoping that by contacting you, you could help me in ...
  A: Craig, Thanks for your question. If you looking for a denomination or church has God’s laws, the ...
baptism9/29/2009
  Q: My daughter's fiance was born into the Catholic faith on his mother's side. However, he was baptized ...
  A: Melanie, Thanks for your question. I am also a convert from the Methodist Church to Catholicism. ...
child understanding Catholic religion9/25/2009
  Q: My step granddaughter is 8 years old, her mother and other relatives practice Baptist religion as so ...
  A: Sarah, Thanks for your question. I'm fond of your name having named my youngest of four, Sarah. I ...
Saved - how?9/16/2009
  Q: I have read many different web sites and read books on what it means to be saved, yet its either ...
  A: Brian, Thanks for your question. I've been traveling so sorry it took me awhile to answer you. You ...
Gaming in Bible8/20/2009
  Q: Many nonprofit organizations including churches use some benign form of gaming (Bingo, raffles, ...
  A: Don, Thanks for your question. Honestly, I'm not an authority on this question. Thus, rather than ...
Veneration8/19/2009
  Q: It is interesting to know your background was Protestant but you later embraced The Catholic Church. ...
  A: Charles, I do not know if we find evidence of the early Church Fathers praying to the Apostles, but ...
Veneration8/18/2009
  Q: It is interesting to know your background was Protestant but you later embraced The Catholic Church. ...
  A: Charles, Thanks for your question. To think about the answer to your question, "Do you find ...
Marriage8/11/2009
  Q: I am a practicing Catholic very dedicated to my faith and have raised my only daughter that way as ...
  A: Lilly, Thanks for your question. My heart goes out to you. Despite your best efforts, sometimes ...
what are the rules for my situation8/9/2009
  Q: My fiance and i just found out that we are having a baby. We were suppose to get married march 2010 ...
  A: Akeesha, Thanks for your question. Congratulations on your good news in a child coming into the ...
faith8/1/2009
  Q: Im writing this in earnest, at a time of great personal doubt. I am hoping you are able to ...
  A: Tom, Thanks for your questions. The fact that you are inquisitive says that you're trying to learn ...
birth control7/31/2009
  Q: why doesnt the church understand that it is so hard not to prac tice birth control when you are ...
  A: Verna, Thanks for your question. The Church does understand. If you are clergy, you're celibate to ...
lust7/27/2009
  Q: Pope John Paul in The Theology of the Body stated that a man can commit adultery "in his heart" even ...
  A: Jaks, Thanks for your question. Truly, I'm not qualified to answer this question. I almost ...
POPE INOCENT III7/13/2009
  Q: Good Morning.... Is this true: AD 1284 Pope Innocent III predicted the end of the world in the ...
  A: Jake, Good morning, and thanks for your question. Honestly, I don't take up questions regarding ...
Catholicism v Protestantism7/10/2009
  Q: I have a friend who labels the Catholic religion as a "cult". How do i reconcile Baptist beliefs ...
  A: Edmund, Thanks for your question. The subject should read, "Catholicism AND Protestantism" as there ...
Trnity in the Bible7/8/2009
  Q: my question is why do Christians believe in the Trinity when it is not even mentioned in the Bible. ...
  A: Brother Daniel, Thanks for your followup. I watched the YouTube video, and to your Muslim faith's ...
Trnity in the Bible7/8/2009
  Q: my question is why do Christians believe in the Trinity when it is not even mentioned in the Bible.
  A: Daniel, Thanks for your question. You ask, "Why do Christians believe in the Trinity when it's not ...
Catholic marriage/anullment6/24/2009
  Q: I will try to be as brief as possible in explaining my situation to you. Im already prepared to ...
  A: First, I've been on Summer vacation and apologize for the length of time it has taken me to respond. ...
Marriage outside of faith and our kids6/16/2009
  Q: My girlfriend is catholic.I am not. We are talking of marriage but she says we may have some ...
  A: Larz, You ask a superb question and I can understand your concern. In some ways, you have no ...
dream of latin phrase6/5/2009
  Q: i had a weird dream and need a little help. first off, i am not catholic or really very religious. ...
  A: Melina, Thanks for your question. I'm not sure that I can answer the question completely, but here ...
Celibacy5/29/2009
  Q: Is it immoral or sinful to be sacramentally married in the Roman Catholic Church? This question ...
  A: Jude, Thanks for your question. "Do I honestly think celibacy should be enforced?" Yes, without a ...
divorce and remarriage5/22/2009
  Q: I am a divorced Catholic. I remarried a divorced Lutheran. I have experienced much conflict and ...
  A: Alice, Let's take your last question first: who wrote the Bible? Who compiled the Bible deciding ...
divorce and remarriage5/21/2009
  Q: I am a divorced Catholic. I remarried a divorced Lutheran. I have experienced much conflict and ...
  A: Alice, Thanks for your question. Your first challenge is to embrace the fact that the Bible is not ...
Im Catholic..Wife..Baptist5/3/2009
  Q: My problem is I was raised Catholic and my wife was raised Baptist/Non-Denominational and we dont ...
  A: George, Thanks for your question. I can identify with your situation given I was like your wife 20 ...
Question4/17/2009
  Q: I had asked you earlier about same sex marriage and you provided me with an excellent answer and ...
  A: Richard, I think the same holds true for women in lesbianism than for men, even though the Bible ...
Question4/15/2009
  Q: I have a question, to be clear, not from a legal perspective but strictly your opinion and thoughts ...
  A: R, Thanks for your question. Personally, I also disagree with same-sex marriage. Sexuality is ...
Communion3/14/2009
  Q: As a Catholic, does the church allow me to take communion in an Anglican church? I don't drive and ...
  A: Joe, If you'll go to the first url address link that I provided above, you'll see an answer to your ...
Communion3/14/2009
  Q: As a Catholic, does the church allow me to take communion in an Anglican church? I don't drive and ...
  A: Joe, Thanks for your question. While I cannot give you an official Church answer, my own opinion ...
no meat on fridays3/13/2009
  Q: can you give me the passage on which catholics are not to eat meat on fridays during lent
  A: Stacie, Thanks for your question. I cannot give you the Bible passage on your question. Why? It ...
Christ's One Church3/10/2009
  Q: You state in a pretty upfront way that you believe the Church of Rome is Christ's One Church ...
  A: Mike, Thanks for your questions. You seem to be attempting to some degree to come to grips in ...
our lady of fatima3/4/2009
  Q: who did our lady of fatima appear to
  A: Marie, Thanks for your question. The true story of the miracles that occured in Portugal during the ...
receiving communion1/11/2009
  Q: I am recently married to a man that is not catholic and has been married twice before. I attend ...
  A: Linda, Thanks for your question. I am so saddened when I get questions like yours, but thrilled for ...
never married catholic planning to wed divorced non catholic1/8/2009
  Q: I am a practicing never married Catholic woman and I am interested in a divorced non catholic man. ...
  A: Bene, Thanks for your question. The answer I believe is no, you would not need a declaration of ...
Catholic-Protestant Wedding1/6/2009
  Q: I am a practicing protestant and my fiance-to-be is a practicing Catholic. In fact, my father is a ...
  A: Kyle, Thanks for your question. Getting married is the second best thing that will happen to you! ...
Eastern Orthodox Church12/16/2008
  Q: What is the official RCC view of the Eastern Orthodox Church. Is there salvation in her?
  A: Michael, Thanks for your question. I can't give you the RCC view of the Eastern Orthodox Church, ...
Romans 3:2311/1/2008
  Q: Is the Catholic Church belief that Mary was without sin a contradiction of Scripture (Romans 3:23 ...
  A: Don, Thanks for your question. Let me ask you a question before I answer yours: If you had to ...
St. Peter as Rock10/30/2008
  Q: What is the difference between Catholic & Protestant beliefs about "Thou art Peter and upon this ...
  A: Barbara, Thanks for your question. As a former Protestant (Methodist) turned Catholic 15 years ago, ...
Mother Teresa10/29/2008
  Q: I am doing a research paper on Mother Teresa. I am suppose to interview an expert! In just a few ...
  A: Elizabeth, Mother Teresa is Agnes Bohaxhiu grew up in Albania and was surrounded by wealth and ...
HalleluYAH10/23/2008
  Q: I have a question for you. I had a vision from the lord and he told me Solomon, a Jew from the tribe ...
  A: Jacqueline, Good to see you back. You said that you "have a question" for me, but it seems like you ...
RE report10/23/2008
  Q: Iam currently doing a Religious education report on " Is the catholic church immoral for banning ...
  A: Taylor, Thanks for your question. I believe there's a typo in the question, "Is the Catholic Church ...
us10/10/2008
  Q: it is said by some that everyone paints a diffrent picture. my perspective of the world and the ...
  A: Connor, Thanks for the quick follow up. Yes, the Bible is clear and the Roman Catholic Church is ...
us10/9/2008
  Q: it is said by some that everyone paints a diffrent picture. my perspective of the world and the ...
  A: Connor, Thanks so much for your question. It took courage to write it, and I want to acknowledge ...
God command of killing8/25/2008
  Q: An Atheist asked me if your God Jesus is love and love us then why He command Saul to killed every ...
  A: Nick, I agree with you. I took this question up at our dinner table with our family tonight, and my ...
God command of killing8/25/2008
  Q: An Atheist asked me if your God Jesus is love and love us then why He command Saul to killed every ...
  A: Nick, Another goodWhen you say, "killing an infant is part of God's love" -- let's be clear, you're ...
God command of killing8/25/2008
  Q: An Atheist asked me if your God Jesus is love and love us then why He command Saul to killed every ...
  A: Nick, This is a superb question! Thank you for asking it -- here's the short answer for your ...
Throne and Lamb8/21/2008
  Q: According to catholic Who is sit on the Throne in Revelation 4:10 and who is the lamb in Revelation ...
  A: Nick, Thanks for your question. Here's my preliminary answer, as I need to do a bit more research ...
Spam7/1/2008
  Q: How do I stop Spam from Catholics.
  A: Jami, Thanks for your question. You stop spam email from Catholics the same way that you stop spam ...
Hell6/16/2008
  Q: I asked many questions and I really appreciate all your answers. Nevertheless I couldn't believe ...
  A: Mona, Yes, I am Catholic. There is more than one version of the Apostles Creed out there - here's ...
Hell6/16/2008
  Q: I asked many questions and I really appreciate all your answers. Nevertheless I couldn't believe ...
  A: Mona, I certainly can't prove it. The Apostles Creed reads: I believe in God, the Father Almighty, ...
Timing of Confirmation6/16/2008
  Q: I fully believe in the sacraments but I also believe that I was too young when they were performed. ...
  A: Alicia, The authority belongs to the Catholic church in Rome. If your mother is leaving the church ...
Timing of Confirmation6/16/2008
  Q: I fully believe in the sacraments but I also believe that I was too young when they were performed. ...
  A: Alicia, Thanks for your question. Unfortunately, my and your opinions about the timing of the ...
Prayer for the dead6/12/2008
  Q: My father died two months ago.I'm a catholic, but was watching Life TV, so I asked some priest who ...
  A: Mona, Go to the tomb today to visit your father's grave ... or tomorrow, Sunday. And then go to ...
Prayer for the dead6/12/2008
  Q: My father died two months ago.I'm a catholic, but was watching Life TV, so I asked some priest who ...
  A: Mona, Dear -- Go out a purchase a Cathechism of the Catholic Church. In the answer above, there ...
Bodily resurrection6/4/2008
  Q: My Catholic cousin claims that at the end of days, we will all be physically resurrected and go to ...
  A: Lynne, To your last question, no Heaven will be in no way like Earth. To explain this to you, ...
DELETING THE VATICAN II5/20/2008
  Q: I have proof that I saw our lady. It was a spring/summer day and it was breezy. I was at a cemetary ...
  A: Jacqueline, You begin the citing proof of your seeing the Blessed Virgin Mary. Whom are you trying ...
Old Rosary.... HELP5/13/2008
  Q: I have a wooden hand made Rosary from France. The year on it is 1830. It is 178 years old. The medal ...
  A: Jacqueline, So, what do I think? I think people are right, that faith means they see things, unseen ...
God with Us......................5/1/2008
  Q: Don't get me wrong but I feel we are in the last days. How the food crisis, war, famine, pestilence, ...
  A: Jacqueline, I agree -- that's why I became Catholic, converting 12 years ago after reading two ...
Rebuilding the Church4/10/2008
  Q: Hi, How are you. I am still called to become a nun. In case you were wondering. My problem is I now ...
  A: Jacqueline, You ask several important questions: "Why are most women’s clothes made the way they ...
Free will in machines????3/29/2008
  Q: I have heard it said, in the computer field, by Christian programmers, that computers cannot have ...
  A: Shawn, Wow, I'm blown away by your post. I'm an Engineer by education, loved physics of all kinds, ...
Urgent!3/24/2008
  Q: For many American fundamentalist Christians, the Rapture forms part of the scenario of events that ...
  A: Jacqueline, The answer to your question is yes, Catholics believe that during the Rapture that Body ...
The Catholic Faith3/19/2008
  Q: I have used this site before, but still have come to disagree with many answers given to the topics ...
  A: Emily, Yes, I used Natural Family Planning for over 18 years of our marriage. On your last question ...
The Catholic Faith3/19/2008
  Q: I have used this site before, but still have come to disagree with many answers given to the topics ...
  A: Emily, Thanks for your question. I'm glad you came back to the site, and the fact that you disagree ...
Another perfect stranger3/15/2008
  Q: I had another revelation from God last night. As I was about to fall asleep I turn on the TV and a ...
  A: Jacqueline, You write well. There's no doubt you likely have an artistic talent as well. And ...
Devouted Spanish Catholic3/10/2008
  Q: Hello, It is me again the one called to religious life. Still discerning...LOL I'll be 22 this month ...
  A: Jacqueline, You have so many questions here, I'm not sure which to answer first. Keep discerning ...
Religion2/11/2008
  Q: Pray for me for my cold to go away. I am attending mass at 7pm today it is a special mass for Our ...
  A: Jacqueline, I'm very familiar with Padre Pio. If you feel a calling to Dominican Sisters of Mary, ...
Convert to cotholism1/28/2008
  Q: I'm dating a Spanish man whose family is very religious. Since I am Swedish by birth him a ...
  A: Camilla, You NEED or want to convert to Catholicism? The first thing I'd advise is to go to a local ...
Protestants & Civil Marriage1/24/2008
  Q: Could you help me understand the fundamental difference between evangelical, protestant Christians ...
  A: Keith, The fundamental commonality of Christians and Catholics is that we both have the same Bible ...
crucifix vs cross12/30/2007
  Q: why do the catholics have Jesus on the cross-crucifix-but the protestants do not?
  A: Cheryl, You ask a very important question, one that as a former Protestant for most of my life, I ...
converting12/19/2007
  Q: my roommate is protestant, and she allows her children to decide what protestant religion they want ...
  A: Btah, Thanks for your question. Two things drove my conversion more than anything else: my wife of ...
automatons of God12/8/2007
  Q: Cardinal Newman states in a prayer: Penetrate my being and take such hold of me that my life becomes ...
  A: James, You ask one of the most important questions that I've been asking myself in the past year. ...
humility12/8/2007
  Q: Mother Theresa says that humility is important because it allows us not to change with praise. Why ...
  A: James, I'm impressed by your question, so allow me to heap a little praise on you. One must always ...
stations of the Cross12/1/2007
  Q: I am a Protestant, but I have attended a Catholic mass around Christmas-time called The Stations Of ...
  A: Kathy, You ask a very popular and common question that many people are curious about, so I'm pleased ...
Calling11/29/2007
  Q: I have a calling to become a nun still. I thought I didnt at first and now it is tugging at my heart ...
  A: Jacqueline, Thanks for your post! First, call me Charlie (vs. Griff). My first question is a ...
Profound discussion questions11/19/2007
  Q: I have two topics to be discussed during a young adult group retreat. 1) Jesus really matters! ...
  A: Daniel, For your first area, you might ask the following discussion questions: 1. When you are in ...
Young adult group11/11/2007
  Q: Our church just formed a young adult group (YAG) with college students through age up to 30, and ...
  A: Daniel, First, congratulations for leading the YAG! We need more leaders like you... Vision should ...
Catholic belief in Holidays and holy days?11/11/2007
  Q: I have been born and raised in a Catholic home. Where my family is religious and my grandparents ...
  A: Jacqueline, You ask some very good questions. First of all, thanksgiving is not a "biblical ...
sacraments from a celtic priest11/4/2007
  Q: Can a Roman Catholic couple receive the sacrament of marriage from a Celtic Catholic priest? Would ...
  A: Mike, I think you're still good to use the Celtic priest in your marriage. I'll put it simply two ...
True meaning of christmas11/1/2007
  Q: It’s true that our most blessed lord humbled him-self to teach the true meaning of Catholicism. ...
  A: Jacqueline, Faith, first is a gift and a mystery. So, with your faith, you don't need any evidence ...
sacraments from a celtic priest10/28/2007
  Q: Can a Roman Catholic couple receive the sacrament of marriage from a Celtic Catholic priest? Would ...
  A: Mike, Thanks for your question. Really, I don't know if a Celtic Catholic Priest is any different ...
Sex and Catholicism10/23/2007
  Q: Why does the Catholic Church (and Christianity in general) seem to have such mixed views on human ...
  A: Hans, I don't believe that the Catholic Church has mixed up views at all on sexuality. It's very ...
Eastern Orthodox relation10/6/2007
  Q: Can you please explain the relationship of the Catholic Church to the Eastern Orthodox Church? It ...
  A: Lisa, I haven't forgotten your question. Honestly, I'm still researching it so give me a little ...
Are we all going to Heaven???????10/3/2007
  Q: I have a Catholic girlfriend. Afew weeks ago me and my mum were talking about my gf and we got on to ...
  A: John, thanks for the courage and initiative to post this question. In many parts of the US, ...
Agnostic9/17/2007
  Q: I am agnaostic, I do believe that there is a god but don't believe in the fascist hypocrypital rules ...
  A: Hey, Pip -- Whoa, be easy on yourself. You do believe there is a God, so ease up ... you're ...
Marriage9/17/2007
  Q: I am looking for some advice from someone who is a good Catholic and follows all the Church ...
  A: There is no set time; start now and pursue it often, but with a loving heart -- one that seeks not ...

All Questions in This Category

Email this page
     
User Agreement | Privacy Policy | Kids' Privacy Policy | Help
Copyright  © 2006 About, Inc. AllExperts, AllExperts.com, and About.com are registered trademarks of About, Inc. All rights reserved.