Expert: charmingbrenda - 8/10/2009

Question
how did prue died? they said prue death was catastrophic but i still don't know how she dies in the show. they said the show just skipped to prue funeral i wanted to know how she died because she was the best character in the show!

Answer
hi dishante!

this will be hard for me to tell because she's my favorite charmed sister and I'm still hurting because they killed her. anyway, prue died in the last episode of season three called all hell break loose which she herself directed (by the way). the episode started when they were saving a doctor from shax (source's personal assassin) they succeeded in saving that doctor's life, but didn't vanquish shax. piper and prue almost died there but leo healed them, after they got healed they went after shax and vanquish him, but they needed power of 3, phoebe wasn't there because she went underworld to save cole. but prue and piper hurt shax pretty bad with their spell.

what they didn't know is that they were caught in a video while vanquishing shax, and their dilemma started. they were exposed, and people were outside the manor and all that. one girl got inside and claimed that she's part of their "coven", prue was pissed and sent her flying outside. that girl got a gun and shoot piper, she got hit straight to her stomach. prue went mad and was calling for phoebe and leo, (leo went after phoebe) but of course they couldn't hear her in the underworld, so she did what she have to do, she went outside to bring piper to the hospital, but the crowd went crazy and are getting in her way, she was so pissed off that she uses her power to send everyone that comes in her way flying. it was so emotional, all she want is to bring piper to the hospital, but she was too late.

meanwhile, phoebe, cole and leo got caught by the source underworld and the source offer them to turn back the time so that piper would be alive (the source let leo to see that he's not bluffing, he told them that piper's dead)but in return phoebe and cole would stay underworld. so of course phoebe agreed to it, and the time returns in time when they were saving that doctor,(the first scene) but the difference is that there was no phoebe to save them so after prue and piper got hit by shax, leo got there and tried to save both of them but he couldnt do it at the same time coz they're both dying, naturally he healed piper first but it's too late for prue.

is my story clear? lol it was a heart breaking episode, specially when piper got hit, prue was crying her heart out.

let me explain the first scene, they brought that doctor in the manor thinking that they were safe there, phoebe went upstairs to find a spell for shax, shax attacks them, and piper and prue tried to save the doctor but they got hit, phoebe came down and said the spell it made shax go away, the doctor was saved, and she called leo for piper and prue to be healed.

so the difference between the first scene and the last scene (the time that the source reset) was there is no phoebe to save them with the spell, so prue and piper got hit and the doctor died.

the first two episode of season 4 is prue's funeral and finding about paige.


i hope i said it enough for you to understand.. ask me again anytime.