I have checked everywhere and have used every song identification app out there but cannot find this song anywhere it's from dead man dating right after the opening credits I know a lot of people say its secret smile I watched it on Netflix is not secret smile and it is not Gnossienne No.1 by Erik Satie the lyrics are "Up here on the rooftop it's amazing how small you really seem watching all the crazy people floating round this crazy city in a dream the sun is rising up over my place that's the city and its warm embrace when the sunlight" I love this song and if you actually find out what it's is I will be so thankful but even if you don't thank you for looking.

Hello Josh,

I looked into what you were saying. The song is Secret Smile by Semisonic: I re-watched that part of the episode and compared it to the youtube video I linked for you and they are exactly the same in my opinion. I don't know if you are thinking of a different version, but this is definitely the version that they used for the episode. The lyrics are identical and the singer's voice is the same. I am an expert on the content of the episodes of Charmed, but beyond that when it concerns specific questions about music, that diverges out of my area of expertise. I hope this is what you were looking for.

If you have any other questions, please don't hesitate to ask.



All Answers

Ask Experts




Hi, My Name is Natalie. CHARMED ! CHARMED ! CHARMED CHARMED ! <3 IT'S WHAT I DEAL WITH, IT'S MY LIFE <3 There are NO questions to which I can't answer I know EVERYTHING about this show I own the DVD's and I've seen all the episodes many times. I am OBSESSED with the show and I know all the spells, demons, personal information on the characters, the love lives of the characters, and many more things BY HEART. I have been watching the episodes of charmed over and over for the past 15 years I know every single episode BY HEART. NOW LOOK, IF YOU WANT INFORMATION, I'M YOUR GIRL, THERE IS NO ONE THAT CAN GIVE YOU THE FULL DETAILS LIKE I CAN ABOUT CHARMED!<3 I LOVE LOVE LOVE CHARMED!


I know all the characters, spells, releshionships, demons, and everything on the show. Like I said, I own all 8 seasons on DVD and I've seen the episodes many times. I know all the episodes out by heart, and I can answer anything about any episode of any season. I have been watching charmed from the time it came out and I have re-watched all the episodes over and over again. I know every single detail about charmed.

I have read thousands of stories online about charmed.

©2017 All rights reserved.