You are here:

Charmed/Prue's death

Advertisement


Cody wrote at 2006-07-08 13:59:39
Well technically it was shown piper and prue got blasted by the sources assain and the next season piper is alive and prue is dead evedently the sources assain was powerfull enough to damage the strongest charmed one to kill her and almost kill piper but leo didnt have enough power to save them both but i do totally agree with you that there is no eppisode that says all that i said in that but i picked it up from watching charmed


Vanessa wrote at 2007-01-15 21:58:43
Hi, judging by what you said, you probably missed the second part of the season finale. I mean, the one where Piper and Prue were thrown through the wall again and Prue was bleeding from the back of her head and Piper's nose was cut up. Since Pheobe was still with the source and Cole, she was unable to call for Leo like before, so when he got there, Prue was already dead and he could only save Piper. I hope this helps a little more.


JC wrote at 2007-10-01 04:07:43
I cannot believe that none of you know the real truth! In fact there is an episode between the end of season 3 and the beginning of season 4. It was aired one time and one time only. This was part of Shannon's exit from the show, that The WB aired the show only once and was never to be seen again. I was not a Charmed fan at the time and actually missed the episode but remember the commercials hyping it. I would love to see this episode but can't find it anywhere. It does bother me to see "experts" telling everyone there is no episode when in fact there is.


Famous wrote at 2007-12-16 20:35:29
There is a missing episode and if I remember correctly Shannen Doherty produced it and may own the rights to the episode. This is the only explanation I have for why there is no evidence of it anywhere. I saw it when it aired and am very upset that it is nowhere to be found.  I will continue to look...


Peppermaud wrote at 2008-07-20 00:38:03
Yes Famous is correct! I saw the episode when it aired also and I have been looking for it for years. It shows how their day was relived and how Phoebe got out of hell. We will find it one day, someone SMART had to have recorded it! GOOD LUCK!


strutterkissgene wrote at 2009-03-10 13:21:01
yes there is a 2nd part to all hell breaks loose...I saw it when it aired and from my memory I remember that shannon doherty ended up sprawled on the cement in front of their house, because she didnt use her powers in public like she had the first time...so she ended up being defeated by shax...


Vladimir wrote at 2009-07-22 18:20:26
Y am from Serbia so sorry for my english.

There is a second part of "All Hell Breaks Loose"!

In that episode, Phoebe was destroyed, Shaks killed Piper, and Prue... Well, she was burn allive in agony. Source killed her.

Cole attakck the Tempus, because Phoebe died, and he reset time again.



They have battle with Source, and thats the final episode. But that ep. never aired anywhere... How I know? From Shannen Doherty!  


Vladimir wrote at 2009-07-22 20:26:04
Y am from Serbia, so sorry for my english.

Yes, there was a second part of "All Hell Breaks Loose"!

In that episode, Phoebe was destroyed, Shax killed Piper, and Prue... Well, Prue was burn allive in agony! Source burn her!

Later, the time was reset again, they killed Shax, Dr. Griffis die, and Prue, Piper and Phoebe stands in front the Source!

Very interesanting episode, I never watched, but thanks to Shannen, I saw a script for that ep.

But "All Hell Breaks Loose" never, never aired anywhere!


Vladimir wrote at 2009-07-22 20:36:13
I am from Serbia, so sorry for  my english!



Yes, there was a second part of "All Hell Breaks Loose"!



In this episode, Phoebe was destroyed, Shax killed Piper, and Prue... Well, she burned allive in agony! Source killed her! He took her soul!



They (Cole and Tempus) reset time again, sisters killed Shax, but Dr. Griffis die in this attack.



Later, Prue, Piper and Phoebe  stands in front the Source, in Hell... Thats the final battle.



I never watched this episode, but I saw and read the script thanks to Shannen Doherty!



And yes, that episode never, but never aired anywhere!  


nikki wrote at 2010-07-20 06:18:00
It is 2010 and i'm still looking for the lost episode and is one,sorry experts. I will find it. I have some tapes from when I use to record the WB I hope its in there. Till then ...keep searching  


teri wrote at 2010-08-29 15:43:31
the episode of all hell breaks loose part two has aired in Australia on TV many times and yet dvds are being sold to many around the world with a missing episode and people are being rip off. how is this possible.

I also have seen the missing show only once and i have a large collection of movies and having a missing episode makes my collection incomplete to say the least.. all i can say is who ever has the full missing episode is one rich bugger because if the episode don't exist then copy right laws don't apply do they lol!!


playitlouder wrote at 2010-10-14 02:32:50
im truly upset. only found out about this the other day - i can't believe i have missed an episode! i will start a discussion on Facebook. someone somewhere has to have it !


AnushaBabe wrote at 2010-10-19 12:12:50
Finally at last it all makes sense.  I am a massive charmed fan and still watch all the re-runs now and always assumed I had just missed the one where Pru actually dies.  In one way I am releaved and in another I feel cheated.  I have never seen this missing episode and would encourage anyone who has it to find a way of showing it.


charmedfamily wrote at 2011-01-04 01:12:35
OMG Im so glad I found this site.  I was trying to explain to my husband and daughter that there must be a missing show cause there are no details from Hell Breaks Loose and Charmed Again.  For all the adoring fans this is a cop out and BS. It would still be nice to show what happened for the new generation of Charmed followers, my daughter included.  


strutterkissgene wrote at 2011-02-07 12:02:58
Hi, its me again, just reinstating the truth.  There is a missing charmed episode.  Like I have said before and many times before, I saw it when it aired.  Prue was left lying on the cement floor outside of the manor in the middle of the street, because she didnt want to use her powers in public on Shax and so she dies.  


bubble wrote at 2011-11-01 11:42:50
I saw it too, finaly a forum where people admit there's an missing episode. All other sites say I must be delerious. I only saw it once and I vaguely remember Prue and Piper laying dead in the manor and Leo only had time to save one... Something like that. But I so want to see it again, because that is the only scene I remember and I don't even know if I remember it right!!


LPatin wrote at 2011-12-17 13:39:27
I saw the original episode when it aired and ever since I was wondering if I just missed it on tv.  I purchase ALL seasons in the special "Book of Shadows" set and expected it to be in there. It's not! If Shannen Doherty really owns the rights and she didn't allow it to be in this set, I officially dislike her and will not purchase anything with her name on it again.  The episode had so much going on.  Prue had to accept death because she had been battling with the concept of death for so long.  And if I remember right, I think there was an option of what could happen and Prue allowed herself to die in order to save her sisters and keep from exposing their powers as they did in the beginning of the "All Hell Breaks Loose" episode.  If anyone knows where to find this episode... please do tell!


Zonian70 wrote at 2011-12-28 14:12:29
Yes, Charmed fans there is a part 2 to "All Hell Breaks Loose" with Leo saving Prue and Piper. Why no one can find it or why experts deny it is beyond me. I saw it when it originally aired. WB should have put it on a 'special' DVD and called it an "alternative" ending. After all, Shannon abrupt departure is not exactly a secret. It would be nice for "charmed" fans to be able to see. These so-called experts need to check into this with WB.  


Desperatetofindanswers wrote at 2012-02-23 20:24:53
If anyone finds the missing episode please don't be afraid to share it!!!


mikeb wrote at 2012-03-10 19:15:17
Yes please post a link cuz i can't find it anywhere and its driving me crazy!


mikeb wrote at 2012-03-14 19:08:34
I'm remembering bits and pieces of the second hour,Peobe had a preminition in her sleep of Prus death and Pru came in and said I'm right Here I'm alive nothing is going to happen to me.And she kept re setting time somehow over and over cuz Prus keeps dying basically like Andy did,and i remember the source tried to kill Pheobe and Coal and Leo helped them get loose from the source and Coal was the one that put the scar and took out the source's eye.


mikeb wrote at 2012-03-14 19:34:15
Actually Pheobe casts a spell that takes her back in time cuz Piper and Pru didn't know or believe her and It's basically two Peobe's in the sametime and she keeps warning the present Peobe of what is going to happen.I think i remember after she gets out of the underworld everything calms down after Cole wounds the source.That is when she has the dream and the death scene with the doctor happens all over again at the end cuz the Pheobe that went back in time could not get to the present Pheobe in time.


CharmedTaj38 wrote at 2012-05-01 22:50:23
I'm So Glad That I Wasn't Wrong!! I Lost All My Recorded Copies- Original Airings- In Storage Shortly Before The Series Finally, and Couldn't Prove It!!


kporte03 wrote at 2012-05-22 02:33:45
Ok...so...does anyone know where I can watch it.  I own 2 sets of the Charmed DVDs and I have been wanting to see this episode forever!  


cloiejean wrote at 2012-08-09 17:22:32
I have been a fan of Charmed since it first aired and have continued to watch as it has been repeated on TNT and every time I see it I am disappointed that the second half of the season 3 finale is missing.  I have only seen it once and that was when it was originally aired.  If you are a "true" fan I know that you saw it as well! :) Not sure why we will never be able to see it again but I think that it's crazy! I even bought season 3 just to see if the missing hour is there and of course it's not! Not sure what all happened when Shannen Doherty left but I am disappointed that this episode will never be seen again!


leah wrote at 2012-09-16 21:23:49
there is a missing episode and i failed to get the chance to see part two i have been looking for it for years and cannot find it any where if anyone know where i can get this copy of charmed or if anyone recorded it please


andyohio wrote at 2013-04-15 19:28:09
I saw the episode on TV at the time Ms Daugherty was leaving the show. She was the director of this episode, both parts and, if memory serves, part of her exit contract was that she got the rights to the second half of the finale, as well as having it written in that her face could never appear on an episode again.  She was jealous of Alyssa Milano's growing fame when she left the series and took the "lost episode" with her. If it still exists she has it. Maybe someday she will get over herself and make it available to Charmed fans everywhere, but don't count on it.


Vasiliki Tzepos wrote at 2013-11-11 03:26:55
I'd like to say that I did see that chapter on TV when it was aired... many years ago... =( but when I bought the DVD of the series I didn't see the second hour of that episode, it was very disappointing... =/ Then I bought the Originals, and it was the same... even on the "extra scenes" of the last DVD from 8th season... again frustrating... Then I looked up on youtube, and those scenes (the second hour of the chapter) is nowhere to be found... I actually thought I was mistaken about the existence of the second part of the chapter... But Hope is the last one to die, so I kept on looking for it, and today I ended up on this site.. =D I do agree with what andyohio said... I did like Prue (the caracter) but now, knowing about the facts, I totally hate what Shannen did with all of us fans of the show...


Vincent wrote at 2014-03-12 01:39:47
I sent a message to Shannen Doherty. I hope she go answer me. I hope: D did the same as me! She go spit épisoe


MikeB wrote at 2014-08-15 17:46:33
I still wish someone who has this recorded will post on youtube.Pheobe casts a spell to take her bacj in time to sace her sisters.It keeps happening over and over.Piper even dies a second time because death told Pheobe she had to chose one of her sisters.At the end Pru chose not to use her powers outside the of the manor.Thats when Leo said i cant heal the dead Piper.


MikeB wrote at 2014-08-15 17:46:40
I still wish someone who has this recorded will post on youtube.Pheobe casts a spell to take her bacj in time to sace her sisters.It keeps happening over and over.Piper even dies a second time because death told Pheobe she had to chose one of her sisters.At the end Pru chose not to use her powers outside the of the manor.Thats when Leo said i cant heal the dead Piper.


MikeB wrote at 2014-08-21 14:06:20
Okay guys i am remembering what all happened,the second hour is very similar to the finale of season one.The source killed Pheobe and Leo helped cole escape.Cole then got Tempess to reset like the other guy mentioned.The source thought all 3 were dead like at the end of the first part..Once time reset he sent more demons to the manor leading to a bigger battle.It ended worse and Leo and Pheobe could'nt find Piper and Pru for all the rubble.Leo found Piper and Pheobe found Pru.So they were not side by side this time.They both were near death Leo healed Piper first,when he got to Pru she was already dead.Piper kept saying heal her damn it!He kept trying and he said i cant heal the dead Piper!It ended like the last espiode showing pictures of Pru going down the stairs and it showed the one with the sisters together and said Pru's and years and screen went black.


MikeB wrote at 2014-08-21 14:06:27
Okay guys i am remembering what all happened,the second hour is very similar to the finale of season one.The source killed Pheobe and Leo helped cole escape.Cole then got Tempess to reset like the other guy mentioned.The source thought all 3 were dead like at the end of the first part..Once time reset he sent more demons to the manor leading to a bigger battle.It ended worse and Leo and Pheobe could'nt find Piper and Pru for all the rubble.Leo found Piper and Pheobe found Pru.So they were not side by side this time.They both were near death Leo healed Piper first,when he got to Pru she was already dead.Piper kept saying heal her damn it!He kept trying and he said i cant heal the dead Piper!It ended like the last espiode showing pictures of Pru going down the stairs and it showed the one with the sisters together and said Pru's and years and screen went black.


MikeB wrote at 2014-08-21 14:06:34
Okay guys i am remembering what all happened,the second hour is very similar to the finale of season one.The source killed Pheobe and Leo helped cole escape.Cole then got Tempess to reset like the other guy mentioned.The source thought all 3 were dead like at the end of the first part..Once time reset he sent more demons to the manor leading to a bigger battle.It ended worse and Leo and Pheobe could'nt find Piper and Pru for all the rubble.Leo found Piper and Pheobe found Pru.So they were not side by side this time.They both were near death Leo healed Piper first,when he got to Pru she was already dead.Piper kept saying heal her damn it!He kept trying and he said i cant heal the dead Piper!It ended like the last espiode showing pictures of Pru going down the stairs and it showed the one with the sisters together and said Pru's and years and screen went black.


Stevo wrote at 2015-04-27 13:35:13
I Own The Box Set And There Is No Missing Episodes So I Gather People Who Haven't Found It Yet Just Havent Thought About It Properly  #Just Sayin  


Jeannie Marie Campion wrote at 2015-05-21 19:04:23
I am Charmed's #1 fan. I have that episode. Vladimir is lying. If he's in Serbia how does he know Doherty? I am a 68 year old woman and one of the few to watch that episode. My friend Alyssa Milano gave me a copy. Shannen never saw it, Alyssa won't allow it, that's why they still won't speak till death, like Joan Fountain and Olivia de Havilland. I'm sorry but I will not make copies for anyone. If you were truly a fan, you would have seen it by now. :)


Ashley wrote at 2015-07-03 01:51:51
Jeannie, I remember watching the episode but my daughter has become a fan of the show over the years; she wasn't alive when it aired so she wasn't obviously able to see it. She would love to see it though. Any way you should share it? :)


Marjo wrote at 2015-09-09 15:06:02
I don't even know why some people deny that this episode aired. I saw it ! We all did !

I hate myself from giving away the first three seasons DVDs to a friend when I was younger. It was so long ago it might as well have been VHS!!! Maybe this damned episode was on it.

If you search on youtube you can find extracts from this episode, for example when Leo and Phoebe are back from the underworld and Leo is trying to save them both but in vain. I beg those you own this episode to put it on the Internet. Otherwise the whole season 4 and Piper's painful grief and remorse does not make so much sens.  


Killy wrote at 2015-09-09 15:14:06
I hate Shannen (if it's really her fault) to keep this episode away from the fans. Does anyone know if she ever explained herself? Did anyone (journalists or else) ever asked her the question?

I watched some videos on youtube where you can see Brian, Shannen and Holly travelling around the world and hosting "Charmed meetings" with fans (not so long ago) but no one ever asked them about that missing episode. It's a shame, I'd like to know the whole story  


Killy wrote at 2015-09-09 15:23:24
The worst thing is that Shannen stated that one of her favorite episode was All Hell Breaks Loose!  


Kira wrote at 2016-02-11 05:41:00
Jeannie: I highly doubt you're friends with Alyssa Milano. You probably don't even have the episode, but if you do then you are cruel, heartless, betch and definitely NOT Charmed's #1 fan.  


Andrew Ace wrote at 2016-02-16 22:51:53
Yes, there is definitely a second episode and it was not only aired that first night, somehow last year when I was first beginning to watch charmed I was recording the series on my DVR and when I recorded the season 3 finale, I only recorded part 2. I watched it and was very confused since I had apparently missed a part 1 and later found it and watched it, so somewhere this episode does still exist.


ConfusedCharmedFan wrote at 2016-03-24 08:31:24
Andrew Ace: I was born the same year as Charmed began, as were many of my friends and fellow fans. I find it unfair that many treat us as lesser fan for being born at the wrong time apparently. I KNOW I watched that episode with my mom, but I was THREE, so of course I have little to no recollection of the episode. If you do still have it on your DVR, is there any way for you to get a copy online for us to be able to enjoy the episode? It sucks to miss out on what appears to be crucial to the storyline.  


Marie wrote at 2016-07-27 02:14:33
Yes, please Andrew! If you could somehow record that episode onto a disk and send it by email or mail I'll venmo you!! I've been dying to watch the infamous missing part 2!  


Stacie wrote at 2016-07-31 20:51:51
I think if the episode exists, but is not included in syndication, it's not really supposed to be considered an actual episode. I absolutely love Charmed and even though I have seen the episodes many,many times, I still watch daily on Netflix. For a while, I thought I has missed an episode when it came to Prue's death. I didn't.  I later learned that when Shannen Doherty exited the show abruptly between seasons 3 and 4, that's when it was decided that what we saw Shax do on the last ep of season 3 would be considered the cause of Prue's death. Seems like on episodes later in the series, the cast throw out hints about Prue's death almost reassuring the audience that hey, Shax killed her. Leo couldn't save them both. The end. I could be wrong, but that's what it looks like to me. And I love love love the show so that's what I will choose to believe. Still, I also love reading other opinions, maybe facts, about this "missing episode." My whole reason for finding this forum is bc when I looked up an episode number as it's listed on netflix, it differs from what I see online.


Charmed

All Answers


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Amy

Expertise

I can answer most questions (I think) about Charmed since I`ve been watching it from season 1.

Experience

I've been running a quite popular Charmed website since Charmed started and have used askme.com to answer questions about the show.

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.