Christianity--Church History/Enoch and Isaiah


Why, when the Word was placed in a collection,why would Enoch's writings not be a part of this collection? Too much information in 1-60? Thank you Mel and Guyna.   Dan

Hi Dan,

The Book of Enoch, along with all the other works of pseudepigrapha (Definition: Spurious writings, especially writings falsely attributed to biblical characters or times.), share some common traits:

1. Multiple contradictions of the scriptures as preserved by the Jews, and as found in the multiple New Testament accounts.  This fails the Biblical test to determine truth, that of "2 or 3 witnesses" that agree.

2. Style, details, language, and oldest physical copies indicate an authorship later than the individual named by the title.

3. An emphasis on, or total preoccupation with accounts (often legendary in scale) of alleged events that have little or no bearing on the true Gospel of Jesus Christ.

4. Claims of validity based mainly, or totally, on other pseudepigraphical works.  An appeal to circular reasoning.

5. With the help of God's spirit, one can recognize that apocryphal works read "flat", that is, there is no apparent inspiration, no depth, no multiple layers of understanding to be explored.  There is no "line upon line, here a little, there a little" application as explained through God's prophet, Isaiah.

In addition, the book of Enoch makes:

6. Statements appearing to support false doctrines, including some false doctrines not documented until after the third century CE.

7. Non-Biblical or anti-Biblical statements reflecting Catholic opinions and attitudes of the period known as the Dark Ages.
Please note that we are not accusing the Roman church of authoring fraud, especially since that organization rejected many apocryphal works.  However, they did approve some of them while wanting to reject the bulk of what we know as the New Testament books.  We are simply pointing out that the text indicates an influence that could only date to a specific period.

We hope this helps.


Mel and Guyna

Christianity--Church History

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Mel and Guyna Horne


We can help with any questions about the history of God's working with mankind from Creation to the Apostles, most questions about the period from the Apostles to "modern Christianity" (90 to 325 AD) and most questions about the confusion within "world Christianity" from 325 AD to the present 33,830 documented denominations. We can discuss major doctrinal differences and their origins but we will not engage in debates over doctrines. We try to avoid trivia unless it had a non-trivial effect or is just really interesting, IOHO. Please do not submit homework questions.


Over 50 years of independent study and over 20 years experience in working with teens, young adults and singles groups. Over two years experience with a prison ministry. Author of three books with two more in development. Published many articles regarding Bible studies and Christian Living.

While we have each, previously attended various denominational and non-denominational organizations, including house churches, we are not affiliated with any denominational organization.

B.A. in Theology with emphasis on Church history and comparative theology. Over 40 years of independent, post-grad study and research at Baylor, Univ. of Houston, Rice, Texas A&M College Station, Univ. of Texas Austin, .

©2017 All rights reserved.