Expert: Stephen Levine - 8/25/2011

Question
Hello Stephen!

I am learning "Allemande from Partita No. 2 in D minor" on flute. I've read a lot of reviews of others playing Bach pieces criticizing the players' styles and how they missed the Bach mark. I understand that Bach is a great composer (if not the greatest!) so I do not want to simplify this piece. What are characteristics specific to playing in the style of Bach? I've already noticed how unique the phrasing is for "Allemande", and I'm sure there is much more to unlock to playing the pieces of this composer. Also, I realize that flute is not the native instrument to this work and to his others, but I feel that many of the techniques will probably transcribe to woodwind. My question, therefore, is, other than constant exposure and osmosis of this style, what are some distinguishably Bach characteristics that I could use in performing this piece?

Many thanks!

Chelsea

Answer
i can only give you the answer my teacher gave to me about the same type of thing. there are as many ways to play a piece as there are players to play it. integrity and your own feelings are what counts in the end. you can play it in the original style, modern style, but what you produce must be in your ears, despite any criticism, how you feel it should be played
steve