You are here:

Coin and Paper Money Collecting/1652 pine tree shilling coin

Advertisement

Expert: - 5/25/2008


Question
Joe, how do I tell fi this coin is a replica or fake? it is in great condition, struck well on center, the tree has 4 roots all pointing to the right. I have searched high and low and can not find a photo that matches it.  John

Answer
Hi John,
This is not going to be easy.  First off, look to see if the surface of the coin has any bumps or porosity.  Also look around the rim for a seam, sometimes 2 halves are produced and then glued together.

Another thing to look at is if the coin just looks "too good".  You have to remember that the minting process 350 years ago is not what it is today.  The coin should have somewhat of a handmade look to it.

Your best bet is to send the coin to Numismatic Guarantee Corp in Sarasota Florida.
For a fee of about $35, they will authenticate it, and if it is genuine, encapsulte it in a hold with serial number and grade.

Good Luck,
Joe Hylas
WWW.AllCoins.US

Coin and Paper Money Collecting

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts

Volunteer

Joe Hylas

Expertise

Numismatic professional with over 30 years experience can answer your questions about US coins, their values, how best to sell them and where to buy them. Interested in starting a collection? Find out which areas are undervalued and how to acquire those coins at the best price.

Experience

Ex-Head Precious Metals trader for Deak-Perera International with 42 offices worldwide. Industry experience since 1978. Has worked co-operatively with US Mint, Royal Canadian Mint, Austrian Mint, Chamber of Mines of South Africa, World Gold Council and Platinum Guild International. Professioanl numismatist specializing in US Coins. Always buying collections, will travel if size of collection warrants. Website: www.AllCoins.US

Organizations
PCGS, NGC, Rotary

Publications
Physician's Money Digest

Education/Credentials
Bachelor's Degree in Business Administration

Awards and Honors
Paul Harris Fellow

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.