You are here:

Coin and Paper Money Collecting/non-copper/bronze 1900 Indian Head Penny


I have an Indian Head Penny, yeaar 1900, that is white in color.
It looks to be the correct size (not struck on a different denomination die).  Listening to it when dropped on a table, it
is definately not copper or bronze, it SOUNDS like it's composed
of nickel, it does not sound like a silver dime.
It's probably in 'fine' condition, and the detail seems correct.
I'm wondering if someone ever tried to counterfeit pennies in the
1900's, or what I'm dealing with.
Do you know if any 1900 indian Head pennies were struck in some metal other than copper/bronze.
Thanks  Dennis

Hello Dennis,

Thanks for your question. This sounds interesting and I would love to help you but I would really need to see the coin. The correct weight of a 1900 Indian Head cent would be 3.11 grams. The copper nickel varieties or the flying eagle cents weigh in at 4.7 grams. You can expect to be at that weight or slightly under if the coin has some wear.

If it does indeed weigh over the 3.11 grams you might have what we call a mule coin. This means that the coin was struck on a different planchet than it was designed for. This does increase the value significantly.

If you can send me the weight and a photo I can give you more information.

David McConaghy
New England Coin Exchange

Coin and Paper Money Collecting

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


David McConaghy


I can answer most questions about coin identification, grading and counterfeit detection. I can answer questions about US and Foreign coins & currency, ancient coins too.


30 years experience as a collector and dealer in rare coins ANA Numismatic Scholar Owner of New England Coin Exchange I have been buying and selling coins in RI for over 30 years

Professional Coin Grading Service - PCGS National Guaranty Corporation - NGC American Numismatic Association - ANA

Cityscape Merchant Circle Numismatic News eBay Providence Journal Bulletin All Experts

Numismatic Scholar Certificate - American Numismatic Association BSEE - New England Institute of Electronics

Past/Present Clients

©2017 All rights reserved.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]