Coin and Paper Money Collecting/fals sau real



va rog sa-mi spune-ti daca aceste 2 monezi sunt false sau reale
va trimit foto in 2 serii deoarece nu imi da voie situl sa trimit 4 foto odata
va multumesc anticipat

Buna seara,
Din imagini este intodeauna dificil sa se decida asupra autenticitatii unei monede, mai ales moderne. Pare a fi un 'shooting thaler' emis pentru concursul de tir din Schaffhausen, 1865 (il gasiti pe aceasta pagina ). Ar trebui sa aiba 37 mm diametru si sa fie din argint, deci in nici un caz magnetica. Sa nu aiba pe muchie vreo dunga inchisa la culoare care sa indice ca e facuta din 2 jumatati imbinate (ca la galvanoplastii). Cand o aruncati usor in aer folosind unghia ar trebui sa aiba un sunet clar, cristalin, nu unul infundat (este batuta cu metode moderne deci n-ar trebui sa aiba defecte in pastila monetara). Cam astea ar fi criteriile principale pentru determinarea autenticitatii.

Presupunand ca e autentica, fiind destul de tocita (prin circulatie, teoretic), deci valoarea numismatica este considerabil redusa ( indica o cotatie de catalog de cca 40$ in stare ''worn'' adica uzata, dar acesta ar fi probabil un caz fericit).

Coin and Paper Money Collecting

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Bogdan C.


I can answer questions regarding certain Eastern European medieval coins, especially coins issued in Wallachia / Walachei/ Transalpina / Tara Romaneasca, Moldavia / Moldawien / Moldau / Moldova, Transylvania / Siebenbürgen / Transilvania for which I can usually make rough estimates of value based on past public sales. Medieval coinage of Serbia, Bulgaria, Hungary is also a field of interest but I usually can provide only identification, not evaluation, because of insufficient bibliography. Questions about coins of the Ottoman Empire and of the Golden Horde might get answer if you allow double of the usual time of 2 days. I cannot answer questions about medieval coins of Western European states or any Russian coins except Sadagura issues (1771-1774), nor questions about ancient or modern coins. NOTE: I will need to see at least a decent picture or a scan of any specific coin you ask about (with both sides, obverse and reverse). Please do not ask what a coin is worth without sending clear images of it along with your question.


Over 20 years of coin collecting as a hobby (ended, switching to study of other public and private collections), access to good numismatic libraries and various online and offline resources.

Member of Romanian Numismatic Society.

Cercetari Numismatice (Bucuresti)/ Numismatic Research (Bucharest).

Biochemistry graduate, History undergraduate.

©2016 All rights reserved.