Expert: Barbara K. Acchino - 4/12/2004

Question
I have figured out that I have a Simons Bros & Co thimble. I am trying to date it. It has little panels for decoration. One plain, then a series of 3 smaller ones that have little designs going down the side this continues all around the thimble. It is marked on one of the panels but I can only make out part of it. It says ?A? MAY 2889. I have been unable to find out anything else about this thimble. Any help you could give would be greatly appreciated. Also, it is kind of dirty. Should I clean it and if I should how should I clean it.
Thank You

Answer
Hello Theresa.  The thimble you have is known as the "Fluted Octagon" and is one of the most plentiful thimble designs Simons made.  The date should be May 28 '89 on the band, as that is the date the patent was issued for that design.  It does not mean the thimble is that old, as that thimble has been issued for many years.  It was still in production in the second half of the 20th century, according to Gay Ann Rogers, in her book American Silver Thimbles.  Your thimble will be found on page 82, if you can get your hands on this book.  Now - about cleaning.  The purist will tell you to use nothing but mild soapy water, as whatever silver cleaning product you use, no matter how mild, will remove some of the silver.  Ove time, this is not a good thing.  However, since some people do not like the look of "patina" (aged), you can use a product called Simichrome, which is what I use.  DO NOT use any of those jewelry dip products (such as Tarnex) as they ruin the finish and your thimble will never look the same.  You didn't ask about value, but I will offer my opinion.  Because this design is so plentiful, it does not command a high price.  If there are no pin holes, dings, dents, needle scratches and the thimble is "in round" (perfectly shaped where you put your finger), then it is worth approximately $20-25.  Of course, if it belonged to a friend or family member, it will have more sentimental value.  There are quite a few books out on thimbles and Simons has a web site you might want to check out.  Enjoy your thimble!  Barb