Expert: Eileen Cronk - 8/10/2007

Question
QUESTION: Hello Eileen,
I have a rocking chair that needs a fiber seat replaced.
The hole measures 10" square and outer edge is 13". When looking at replacement seats I have noticed the design measurement does not fit this measurement (I understand I can cut the outer edge to fit though). Is it ok for the design to be bigger than the hole?  I am not sure what to buy. Any assistance you can give me will be greatly appreciated.
Thank you.
Kindly,
Gail

ANSWER: Hi Gail
Nice to hear from you.
I am a little confused here Gail so help me out LOL
Do you mean a leather replacement seat? I know they have a pattern stamped into them and I feel it would look odd if the pattern had to be cut away.
Now assuming this is what you mean, I will pass on my experience installing these things.
I find after removing the old worn out seat, that there is unsightly nail holes that you will want to overlap or hide with the new seat.
Yes I trim to fit, but never to the extent that the pattern is compromised.
So Perhaps looking for another pattern is the answer.
Now if I am totally off base with my thinking Gail, and its not a leather seat, get back to me.
Good Luck and good question
Kindest Regards
Eileen


---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: Eileen,
This is for a pressed fiber seat (used instead of leather). I do not plan on cutting the design, just the outer edge, if necessary, where you tack it down.  MY concern is the design itself is bigger than the seat opening (this is 10 inches and most designs are at least 11 inches or they are ~ 9inches x 8 inches). Do the designs lay flat or do they curve down to fit into the seat opening??? Depending on which it is, I would think effect the way you choose the size for proper fit of the replacement.
I hope I have made this more clear.
I greatly appreciate your assistance.
Kindly,
Gail

Answer
Hi again Gail
It would look better if the pattern was inside the hole.
As the chair is sat in the seat does tend to curve downward as you say.
But if you have choices, get the correct size for the hole..hopefully the place of purchase will guide you.
Regards
Eileen