Expert: Eileen Cronk - 7/18/2006

Question
Hello Eileen,

I have a Wooten desk. It was purchased by my great grandfather around 1876, I have the original catalog. It is in need of restoration. I have been told by several people that it may be worth more if I don't restore it.  I know its what they call the "extra grade" model.  I also have newspaper articles linking the desk to a hoax started by PT Barnum.

What are your thoughts?

Best Regards,

Todd Belinsky
Alpharetta GA.

Answer
Hi Todd
Nice to hear from you.
This is a very interesting question and I will give you my best answer which is also my opinion LOL.
In my opinion, any antique piece should be sold in "as is" condition.
But in your case I suspect you are keeping this heirloom from your Great Grama.
You say it is in need of restoration so if you plan on keeping it I would have some "conservative restoration" done to it so its looks good in your home.
Any repairs of course should be tended to, but perhaps the finish only needs cleaning and waxing.
And if the hutch needs a total refinish its so bad then by all means have it done by a pro.
Your question about it being worth more not restored depends on the condition now. If its in bad shape, you can only increase the value with a proper refinishing job.
Have I totally confused you yet? LOL
Bottom line..if you are selling it, leave it alone.
If you are keeping it, do what has to be done so you can live with it.
Thanks for a great question.
Regards
Eileen