Construction Law/Approval for Shop Drawings
I am working as a Consultant QS in a Engineering firm. Our contract is based on FIDIC Red Book(1999). In the Shop Drawings for plumbing work contractor has indicated wrong diameter ( different to Contract drawing ) and Engineer has approved the same without noticing the change. Later at site Engineer found the mistake and asked to carry out the work as per the Contract drawings. But contractor calim additional Cost and time since the Engineer already approved the shop drawings. Can the contractor claim for additional money and time?
Your kind respond is highly appreciated.
Thank you for this question.
The answer you seek will depend upon what the purpose of the shop drawings is under your contract and the status they have. Usually shop drawings are intended only as a mechanism for the contractor to explain its working arrangements and to show minor detailing. They are not intended to supersede or otherwise change any design detail. Indeed under the FIDIC 1999 Red Book contract the Contractor does not have authority to make any change unilaterally. As such, approval by the Engineer does not relieve the Contractor from complying with its obligations under the Contract, including constructing to designs.
The second scenario is where the designs are incomplete and the requirement shop drawings is to "fill in the gaps", then information given on the shop drawings may carry more weight and importance. This is where you contract should define the exact purpose.
If the analysis in my first paragraph is correct, the Contractor has produced work that is not in accordance with the specification/contract and can be required to correct its mistake at its own cost. The fact that the Engineer approved the shop drawings does not detract from the Contractor's responsibility and liability.
If, however, the analysis follows my second paragraph then, subject to the precise wording of the contract (which I have not seen) the Engineer was approving the Contractor's designs and the Contractor has a much stronger argument.
I hope that this assists you.
Follow me on Twitter: @CernoOrg
For my regular industry newsletter e-mail to email@example.com, stating SUBSCRIBE in the subject line
Training and consulting services are available, bespoke to companies and individuals.
John Dowse can be contacted by e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org (When e-mailing, please include “AllExperts” in the subject line.)