You are here:

Cricket/Dismissal vs Out



In one-day match, a batsman who has been struggling badly is caught.  but the fielding captain tells the umpire to withdraw the appeal and let the batsman continue.  Should the umpire give his consent to this or not?


ANSWER: Whatever sort of cricket do you umpire???

Umpires are there to adjudicate on disputes between teams not to interfere unnecessarily or officiously if both sides are in agreement.

27.8 does allow "The captain of the fielding side may withdraw an appeal only if he obtains the consent of the umpire within whose jurisdiction the appeal falls."

It does not specify conditions for the umpire to decide.  The Law is primarily to cope with mistakes (eg close catch just bounced off ground) and unfair situations (eg accidental collision with running batsmen leading to run out).

In your case, I would allow it to be withdrawn BUT I would guess the struggling batsman would be only too glad to retreat to the pavilion anyway.

---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------


Thanks for your feedback.

Now the question in this case remains that whether the fielding captain tries to gain undue advantage by letting the struggling batsman to remain on the wicket for more time so that this batsman could consume more balls without scoring too many runs. (its a one day match)

Taking this point into consideration, should the umpire give his consent to the request of the fielding captain?


It is not the role of the umpire to override the wishes of both sides unnecessarily..

If the fielding captain wishes to withdraw the appeal, I would let him.  That is his prerogative.

That puts the onus on the struggling batsman.  He may decide to leave the wicket - if so I would record him as Caught.  If he wishes to stay, then the fielding side has what they want!


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Colin Pearson


Cricket umpiring and scoring. I can answer questions on MCC Laws of Cricket but not ICC and other special regulations, which are frequently changing. I cannot answer questions on careers as a cricket umpiring. For details of courses, visit (anywhere that has advertised), (UK only)


I passed The Association of Cricket Umpires and Scorers Full membership examinations in 1961 and have been an instructor since 1973, and examiner since 1977 and have undergone the first stage training as an Umpire Assessor for ECB Association of Cricket Officials. I was Chairman of Training Board for ACU&S from 1981 to 1997.

ECB Association of Cricket Officials British Computer Society Society of Expert Witnesses Chartered Institute of Arbitrators Rotary International

MA Hons Cantab 1966 DMS Part 1, 1975 Enterprise Reader (rtd), Staffordshire University)

Awards and Honors
Taylor Scholarship 1963 Life Vice President ACU&S 1998

©2017 All rights reserved.