Crime & Law Enforcement Issues & Death Penalty/police lie on witness stand

Advertisement


Question
what are some of the reasons why an officer might lie in th ewitness stand?  what can be done proactively to avoid this taking place?  Should the officer be allowed to keep their job?

Answer
Hey, Rudy. Thanks for sending me your question. It's also a very interesting question. First, about testifying, if you know that you arrested the person legitimately from the start, you'll be 100% confident & never have to lie. On the other hand, if you lied in the beginning when you first made the arrest, unfortunately, in order to keep the case alive, the lie(s) must be kept alive. Regardless, it does happen, although, not as often as you would think.

The most serious reason is because of police corruption. Lies to obtain a search or arrest warrant from a judge lead to further lying in court. Eventually, 90% of the time, those cops' pictures end up on the front page of the paper. Another reason may be that, sometimes, cops may have either made mistakes during the arrest or their original testimony & would rather lie than admit that they messed up. I believe this is due to the image that cops have, we know the way that the public views us & believe that we must protect that image at all costs. Anything less would be too embarrassing. Then you have some rogue cops out there who may fabricate evidence because of how strongly they believe a person should be put away.

For whatever reasons a cop may lie on the stand, it is always unacceptable & cannot be tolerated. There is nothing that can be done to completely prevent it. This is because law enforcement is like anything else, there will be some level of dishonesty in any profession.

How do we deter dishonesty on the stand? I think better training on police procedures, the law, may help, for the ones that may make honest mistakes from the beginning. Other than that, I don't know, except that I think that cops seeing what happens to other cops who get caught is a pretty big deterrent. There isn't much worse than a cop's dishonesty being spread all over the media. As far as should cops be allowed to keep their jobs, I think that, depending on the severity of the act, they should either be reassigned permanently to a desk job where their credibility will never be allowed or fired and even arrested.

I hope I've answered your question. Please feel free to contact me again and I'd really appreciate it if you could rate me. Thank you and good luck.  

Crime & Law Enforcement Issues & Death Penalty

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Patrick Malloy

Expertise

I can answer questions relating to arrests, arrest procedures, domestic situations, traffic citations, auto accidents. i cannot answer many questions regarding other types of law rather than Criminal Law and/Police related questions.

Experience

Throughout my 18 year career as a police officer in Philadelphia, I have worked both uniform and plain clothes in a variety of assignments. I don't know it all, but I surely can give expert advice on most issues. And if I don't know something, then I simply tap the vast array of resources that I have at my disposal.

Organizations
Fraternal Order of Police Lodge #5.

Education/Credentials
Training Credentials: Tactical Response Situational Training, Mental Health, Criminal Procedure, Vehicle Law & Code, Crime Scene Investigation, Court Testimony Procedure, Police Safety Coordination. Hostage Negotiation.

Awards and Honors
Several Departmental Commendations ( Arrests for crimes such as Homicide, Bank Robbery, 'Most Wanted', Shooting, Domestic Assault and other types).

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.