Critics of Catholicism/Should I take it literally?

Advertisement


Question
QUESTION: Is the Bible to be taken literally according to the Catholic Church?

Thank you.

ANSWER: Hi David.

No, not always.  There is poetry, song, history, genealogy, parable, simile and metaphor, etc.

We do, of course, believe that it is inspired by God and without error.

Is there a passage or passages that you can cite that you wonder about - as to whether we would take it literally or not?

The book of Proverbs is an excellent place to see examples of non-literal teaching.

Rick.



---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: A few minor things early in the book of Genesis  I was wondering about:

Do Catholics believe that there is water above the atmosphere?  At least, that's what I understand the "dome" to be, correct me if I'm wrong.  (Genesis 1:6-7)

Do Catholics believe that man at one point could live to be over 900 years old? (Genesis 5:3-32)

Do Catholics believe the Nephilim once existed?  
(Genesis 6:4)

I realize these are very minor quirks in the Bible and I am not trying to attack the church with my questions.

Answer
With this sort of historical issue there is no official pronouncement by the Church as to whether they are literal or not.  They may be literal, or they may be descriptions of things that neither we nor the writer fully understood.

The one thing that is certainly true of historical descriptions such as these: Catholics believe that they certainly could be literal.

For example, I believe that the earth may be billions of years old, or that it may be only 6500 or so years old.

Remember that good Christians have been trying to figure out the true meaning of so many Scripture passages for nearly 2000 years.  The best we can do with much of it is try to learn and dwell on how the passages, in context, can strengthen our relationship with God: How to understand and serve Him better.

Does that make sense?

Rick.  

Critics of Catholicism

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


Rick Jackson

Expertise

I can help clarify fact vs. fiction regarding the teachings of the Catholic Faith. I believe that Catholicism is the best representation of the Historic Christian Faith and that this can be shown with Scripture, reason and history.

I am an ecumenical apologist. I'm not interested in telling non-Catholics why they are wrong, but am happy to explain and confirm what we believe and why we; from Scripture, reason and history.

There are some issues where I will have to politely agree to disagree with my non-Catholic brother in Christ, however there is so much that we share in common, I'd prefer to clarify those first. :)

Experience

Experience in the area
As a former Protestant (Church of the Nazarene) I came to the faith by recognizing, after lengthy study, that Catholocism is the best representation of the Historic Christian Faith. Very interested in "ecumenical apologetics", and have started a website pursuing it: www.catholictruths.com

Organizations

Active member/supporter and webservant:
Biblical Archaeology Society | Diocese of Columbus Catholic Record Society | St. Gabriel Radio | Catholic Truths

Active member and/or supporter:
Catholic Answers | EWTN | Dead Theologians Society

Publications
Catholic Truths

Education/Credentials
Some College. Received religious instruction by the Dominicans. Have attended several "seminars" (or viewed via DVD) by Scott Hahn, Patrick Madrid and other apologists.

©2012 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company. All rights reserved.