You are here:

Dog Training/Crying with in crate


I have had puppies before but my new puppy Piper hate the dog crate.. She is a really good puppy until we have to crate her to go to bed or to leave for a little while..I do not work so she is with me every minute the rest of the day. She will just cry and cry and sometimes seems like she is screaming.. :o( I have to crate her because where we live when maintance comes in they want them crated.. She does stop after what seems like a long while but it breaks my heart to hear her do this.. Is there anything I can do to make this time better for her to to help her get use to it easier.. Thanks Valerie

Hi Valerie,

Thank you for you for your question.

What you need to do is create a positive association for Piper with her crate. You can do this by feeding her in her crate and by giving her things like a Kong with peanut butter or spreadable cheese packed inside. You could also moisten her kibble and pack that in there with a little honey or peanut butter to make it tastier.

I would recommend keeping the crate door open so she can go into the crate at will and avoid closing the door unless necessary. If there are two doors on your crate, leave them both open during the day and when you are home for her to come and go at will. Place the crate in a room you are in, but a quiet place out of the flow of traffic.

Where is the crate located? i would recommend placing in your bedroom at night so she can see and be with you. You could try some soft music to calm her, such as Through A Dog's Ear ( You could also try a ticking clock on the outside of the crate, which would simulate a heartbeat. Make sure if you do this you pick it up when she is out of the crate so she doesn't chew it.

I would also recommend you make going into and out of the crate a game. If you know how to teach a dog to target your hand with her nose, you can have her target it to lead her into the crate and then back out, making it a game and making going into the crate a non-issue. You could also toss toys in her crate -- even play fetch -- but make sure you do not bribe her into going into her crate or trick her into going in.

You can also desensitize your puppy to the crate by having her follow (willingly) your finger into the crate - or waiting until she goes into the crate - or have her target the palm of your hand to go into the crate - then close the door, click (if you know how to do clicker training)at the moment the door is closed, then open the door and give her a treat. You could build the duration of the closed door, clicking while the door is still closed just before you open it. If you have not had instruction in clicker training, skip the clicking and just open the door and give a treat.

You can also feed treats through the crate, especially if you have a wire one. Use really high value treats (something your puppy finds really yummy and likes more than other treats, such as chicken).

Be careful not to respond to her crying or she will learn that crying gets what she wants and she will continue to do it or do it even more. However, I don't believe in causing the dog any unnecessary stress, so try to make the crate a pleasant place to be, and be cognizant of when you put her in it. She is probably not reacting to the crate so much as what it has come to mean - that she will be separated from you.

It is necessary for her to learn to like her crate - all dogs should learn this because as you know, they may need to be crated during their lives - at the vet's, to be transported, or in your case, when maintenance comes around.

I recommend only crating when necessary and only as long as necessary until your puppy is housebroken and safe alone at night (won't get into things and harm herself) or when your gone.
Really try to avoid leaving her in the crate any longer than necessary.

Also, since you are home during the day, be careful she doesn't tend to develop separation anxiety. Make your comings and goings non-eventful, that is, avoid giving her a lot of attention on arrival home or when leaving, or making a big deal out of your coming home or leaving. Try to leave the house during the day so she gets used to you being gone and coming home.

Hope that helps.


Dog Training

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Cindy Ludwig, M.A., R.N., KPA-CTP, CPDT-KA


My specialty is clicker training. I'm a Karen Pryor Academy graduate and Certified Training Partner (certified clicker trainer). Karen Pryor was a marine mammal trainer and one of the early proponents of force-free animal training who helped popularize clicker training in the early 90's. I also do behavior modification with dogs that have fear, anxiety and aggression. I work with service dogs and was a certified therapy dog evaluator with two other organizations before starting my own therapy dog program, the first of its kind requiring all dog candidates to be trained with force-free methods and all evaluators to demonstrate a commitment to force-free methods. I made weekly visits with my own therapy dog to a nursing center in Dubuque, Iowa for four and a half years. I have an undergraduate degree in science and am a registered nurse with a previous specialty and certification in critical care, so I can answer questions pertaining to biology, behavior and pharmacology but because I am not a licensed veterinarian I cannot legally or ethically answer questions requesting a diagnosis. I have done graduate work in animal learning and wolf ethology, and have also completed coursework in dog biology, behavior and pet nutrition at regionally accredited U.S. universities. I continue my study of applied behavior analysis with top experts in the field. For more information and to schedule a consultation or enroll in classes, see my Canine Connection website:


Prior to becoming a full time professional dog trainer in May 2009 and opening my business, Canine Connection LLC I worked part time as a professional dog trainer and behavior consultant and also volunteered at humane societies in several states over a period from 1992-2009. My previous full time occupation was in the medical profession. I have completed various continuing education programs including but not limited to the Purdue University Veterinary School Principles and Techniques of Behavior Modification course; Clicker Expo; undergraduate courses in dog biology, behavior, and pet nutrition; and graduate coursework in wolf ethology. I was a Field Representative for Paws with a Cause for 3 years and train service dogs. My Golden Retriever that accompanies me in my work as a Field Representative is a "career changed" dog from the Paws breeding program that I have clicker trained as a demonstration service dog. This same dog I trained to earn the first Dog Scout title in the State of Iowa. She and I were also members of the Badger Kennel Club Drill Team and performed with the group annually at the Alliant Energy Center in Madison, Wisconsin. My dog, Ginger and I provided weekly pet therapy visits to a local nursing center for the past three and a half years. I continue my education by participating in seminars and class offerings provided by such notable experts as Dr. Sophia Yin, Dr. Ray Coppinger, Michele Pouliot and others. My services include in-home private training and behavior modification, group classes and pet sitting. More information is available on my website:

Founder and owner, Canine Connection LLC; Founder, Canine Connection Positively Trained Certified Therapy Dogs; Association of Professional Dog Trainers (APDT); 2010 APDT Education Committee; Truly Dog-Friendly Trainer Coalition; Doggone Safe; American Kennel Club

Top Tips from Top Trainers: 1001 Practical Tips & Techniques for Successful Dog Care and Training (March 2010); The Golden View; Family Connections;; Animal info Publications; HubPages; Finding Fuzzybutt Four Blog; Petopia Newsletter, Galena, Illinois; Suite 101;;; Dubuque 365 Ink Magazine; Dubuque Telegraph Herald; Columbia Business Times; Columbia Senior Times; Columbia Missourian; Columbia Daily Tribune; Graphic Education Corporation; Belson-Hanwright; Critical Care Nurse; Journal of Emergency Nursing; Home Healthcare Nurse; Nursing; Journal of Emergency Medical Services; Shape; Houston Community College Egalitarian; Findlay College Obelisk

B.S., Science; M.A., Higher & Adult Education with graduate work in animal learning, canine biology and behavior, pet nutrition; Graduate, Karen Pryor Academy for Animal Training & Behavior; Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner; Diploma, professional nursing; licensed registered nurse (R.N.); Paramedic completion program; previously licensed paramedic in Texas and Missouri

©2017 All rights reserved.