Dog Training/Speakers



I am doing a research project and was wondering whether dogs of some breed could be trained to follow commands that occur over a loudspeaker. I have attempted to test this with my dog who is a miniature schnauzer, but she blocks the speaker out of her mind. I know dogs can tell the different between a person's voice and an electronic recording of a person's voice, but in your experience, can they be trained to follow commands given in recordings?

Thank you for your time!

Great question, Zach. Here's something to consider first. Can you dog respond to your verbal cues (coming directly from you) without seeing you? For example, if you stand behind a closed door and ask her to "sit", will she respond or does she have to see you? Many times, we inadvertently give our dogs extra cues with our body language that we are not even aware of. Set up a camera and see if she can pass this test first. If she can't, then video YOURSELF and see what body language you are using and train yourself to be perfectly still while you give verbal cues.

If/when she CAN pass the out-of-sight test, then progress to recording your own voice on a digital recorder right next to you. Gradually move it further away from you. Be sure you're providing high enough value reinforcers for her to do this. Very gradually work up to something with bigger speakers, then to a loudspeaker.

Good luck! Let me know if you have questions - and I'd love to hear if you are successful!

Dog Training

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Barb Gadola, CPDT-KA, KPA CTP


I can answer questions related to problem dog behaviors, teaching polite manners, puppy raising, and any type of training-related issues. My website page, offers a wealth of information on training and behavior issues as well.


I've been training dogs since 1989 and own and operate Distinctive Dog Training LLC in Keller TX. I specialize in providing practical and positive solutions for families through personalized training in their home.

Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner
Victoria Stilwell Positively! Licensed Trainer
Association of Pet Dog Trainers
Association of Animal Behavior Professionals
Truly Dog Friendly Coalition

BS in Education
Graduate work in Behavioral Psychology
Karen Pryor Academy Dog Training Program
Certified Professional Dog Trainer

©2017 All rights reserved.