You are here:

Electronics/NPN VS PNP replacment

Advertisement


Question
http://electronics.stackexchange.com/questions/57790/can-the-common-emmiter-ampl

A blog at the above post seems to indicate that a NPN can be swapped with a PNP by simply using a negative power supply.

So, lets say I have the original NPN circuit with a 9v battery connected with +Vcc at the top of the circuit, and ground at the bottom. Can the NPN be swapped with a PNP and the polarity of the battery switched? Making The bottom of the circuit +VCC and the top GND? Is that really all that needs to be done? - Thanks

Answer
Yes, it is possible; at least theoretically.

If you assume a one transistor circuit biased for class A operation and the operating characteristics (beta, biasing voltages, etc.) are similar in each transistor it will work.

In practice, however, it is more likely the circuit will need to be rebiased in order to get the NPN centered up for class A operation.  And, the gain or distortion of the circuit may be little different.

One would probably never want to do such a swap in practice; only for theory of operation, perhaps.

Hope this helps.  

Electronics

All Answers


Answers by Expert:


Ask Experts

Volunteer


ZZ

Expertise

Electronics questions about AC, DC and digital theory.

Experience

Graduate electrical engineer with over 40 years in electronic design, manufacturing, project organization and patent review. Experience in fields of industrial and consumer electronics (audio, video, acoustics, etc.)

Organizations
IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers); Senior Life member AES (Audio Engineering Society), Fellow Life member

Education/Credentials
BSEE University of North Dakota

©2016 About.com. All rights reserved.