Question I have an Icart picture of "Coursings II". It has an embossed Atelier stamp in the lower left hand corner with a date of 1908. Have you seen this stamp before? Is it genuine?
Answer Hello John, Please confirm the spelling of the title? What is its provenance? Have you read the excellent advice provided by John Bates owner of Lockport Street Gallery in Plainfield, Il http://www.lockportstreetgallery.com/icartinfo5.htm ? Cheers, Brent
John - How am I supposed to answer your question - Have you seen this stamp before? You did not supply an image. Did you read the article I referred you onto? How can I determine if something is genuine without knowing what you are asking about? I asked you to confirm the spelling of the title because I could not find the title as part of Icart's listed works. The problem with not being able to respond back to me is not something I can control so I suggest you point this out to AllExperts admin not provide negative feedback.... Thank you, Brent
Knowledgeability = 5
Clarity of Response = 7
Politeness = 10
Did not deal with the main question as to whether the Atelier stamp is a legitimate Icart stamp. The expert asked me additional questions about provenance and title. When I tried a follow up, I was told to consult another expert. No other experts seem to be as qualified.