Fine Art/J.F. Cropsey


With further checking, it is the American Autumn, Starrucca Valley; signed by J. F.Cropsey 1865. It is 40 x 24, color has faded with some still around the edges, smooth surface and it is attached to a backing material about 1/4 inch thick. My grandfather purchased it from a dealer, who also sold paintings and prints to other including the Dow family, about 40-50 years ago. I am in Midland, Michigan and there are many places he could have purchased it from, he just doesn't remember. It looks like a lithograph, but I am not sure.

Thanks for your help,
The text above is a follow-up to ...

I bought my grandfathers house many years ago, when doing repairs, I found a large (about 3x4) painting or print. My grandfather was told that it was an original painting, but it looks like a print to me. It is the scene of two men and a dog, on a ledge, looking at a train going along a bridge in the distance. It is signed J.F. Cropsey 1865 in the lower right.
If its a Jasper Francis Cropsey [American Hudson River School Painter, 1823-1900] then it's a very nice work of art. The question is whether its an original or a print.  What makes you think that its a print?  Is is on paper?  On canvas?  are there any brushstrokes?  Where did he acquire it?  Please let me know and maybe I can help.

Dear Mike,

Thank you for your reply,

Since you mention "smooth surface",  I would guess that its a print on panel.  Some posters were adhered to panels before framing them.  These works were sold at furnuture stores all over America.  However, how is it signed?  Is it part of the print? or hand signed?  If the signature is as flat as the image, then it is not hand signed, confirming that it is not an original. I hope that this helps.

Happy Holidays

Fine Art

All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Alejandro Rojas Salazar


I will answer questions about collecting limited edition prints. (i.e. lithographs, serigraphs, giclees, etchings, etc.)


I have been an art dealer for 10 years in Boston, La Jolla, and Laguna Beach. I am the Executive Director of Madison GAllery in La Jolla.

Harvard University (2001)Masters Degree in Theology and Art History Boston College (1999)- Masters Degree in Sociology and Art HIstory Colorado College (1995)- BA in Sociology and Art History

©2016 All rights reserved.