You are here:

Fish/comet goldfish not eating


QUESTION: My comet, Rin, won't eat. he was eating fine two days ago, but now he won't open his mouth. I change the water weekly, and the tank is a ten gallon tank with a filter. Rin is only about an inch and a half right now, but when he gets bigger I will buy a bigger tank. but Rin tries to eat, but can't open his mouth to eat, and I am afraid he may starve to death if I don't figure out what to do soon@ could you please help me save my Rin? he's my only companion here at college!

ANSWER: Unable to open the mouth seems like mouth rot to me. Mouth rot can be a cause of poor water parameters such as a low acidic PH or high nitrites, nitrates, ammonia.

I am sorry to inform you but Rin is in much too small of an aquarium right now. Comet Goldfish can grow several inches a month and it's going to grow past the size of that tank quite soon or permanently stunt which will lead to more problems. He needs a 75g with double/triple filtration. In a 10 gallon with such a high bio-load fish its impossible to maintain good water quality despite your water changes.

The best thing would be to setup a larger aquarium, cycle it, and put Rin in so he can have good water quality and less stress.

- Ash

[an error occurred while processing this directive]---------- FOLLOW-UP ----------

QUESTION: the maximum size of an aquarium we can have here is 20 gallons, if I change the water more frequently, say every three days, would it be safe to keep him in a 20 gallon tank?

I totally understand how you are limited in college but I am afraid that a 20 gallon is not much better and no where near to close to the proper tank size. Is there any local ponds or stores you could possibly donate him to so he won't get stunted or catch diseases in the future.


All Answers

Answers by Expert:

Ask Experts


Ash WolFF


My knowledge of fish ranges from freshwater and saltwater fish compatibility and care from easy livebearers to monster fish. I can help you set up a simple freshwater aquarium to a complicated reef tank. I would be pleased to assist anyone who is new to the aquarium hobby.


I have been in the aquarium hobby for eight years mostly dealing with large and small aquariums. I keep mostly monster fish (Arowana's, Large Cichlids; Oscars, and freshwater/saltwater eels specifically) but now that I am in college I am keeping a 30 gallon tropical community and a 45 gallon brackish aquarium while my father tends to the big monsters I left behind.

I'm on YouTube! My 30 gallon community posts are the only ones that are up so far. My Brackish tank is next! I'm on Yahoo Answers:

I am currently in college aiming for a job in Marine Biology.

©2017 All rights reserved.

[an error occurred while processing this directive]